Abstract
We report a direct lattice calculation of both the $I=0$ and $I=2$ $\pi\pi$ scattering phase shifts using G-parity boundary conditions on an ensemble of $32^3 \times 64$ gauge configurations at physical quark mass. This extends an earlier calculation of the RBC/UKQCD Collaboration by including additional operators and more statistics. We apply both multistate fitting and the generalized eigenvalue treatment to this set of operators in order to understand and reduce excited state contamination and to study $\pi\pi$ scattering at energies in the energy region around the kaon mass. These results are compared with predictions from dispersion theory.
Introduction
A central goal in modern particle physics is the precise determination of CP violation parameters, such as $Re(\epsilon'/\epsilon)$, which quantify the asymmetry between matter and antimatter. Calculating these values from first principles within the Standard Model requires a non-perturbative treatment of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). Specifically, the decay of a kaon into two pions ($K \to \pi\pi$) involves complex hadronic interactions that are best studied using Lattice QCD. A prerequisite for these calculations is an accurate determination of the $\pi\pi$ scattering phase shifts in both the isospin $I=0$ and $I=2$ channels.
Methodology
This study utilizes a $32^3 \times 64$ lattice ensemble with physical pion masses ($m_\pi \approx 143.1$ MeV), employing Möbius domain wall fermions. To achieve high precision, several advanced techniques were implemented:
- G-parity Boundary Conditions (GPBC): These conditions force ground-state pions to carry non-zero momentum, allowing the two-pion energy to align closely with the kaon mass ($m_K$).
- All-to-all Propagators: The use of 900 low modes and 1536 random modes significantly improved the signal-to-noise ratio and allowed for the efficient calculation of complex diagrams.
- Operator Basis Expansion: A critical advancement in this work is the inclusion of a $\sigma$ (quark-antiquark) interpolating operator alongside the standard $\pi\pi$ operator in the $I=0$ channel.
- GEVP and Multistate Fitting: A $2 \times 2$ correlation matrix was constructed to disentangle the ground state from excited state contamination using the Generalized Eigenvalue Problem (GEVP).
The calculation involves evaluating various diagrammatic contributions, including vacuum-subtracted diagrams and connected diagrams like the "Cross" and "Rectangle" types.
Results and Discussion
The results for the $I=2$ channel are highly precise, yielding a phase shift of $\delta = -11.3(0.1)^\circ$ at an energy of 573.9 MeV, which is in excellent agreement with dispersion theory predictions.
The $I=0$ channel presented a greater challenge. Initial calculations using only a single $\pi\pi$ operator resulted in a phase shift of $\delta = 19.1(2.3)^\circ$, a $5\sigma$ discrepancy from the theoretical prediction of $35.0^\circ$. This discrepancy was traced to excited state contamination. By incorporating the $\sigma$ operator and applying the GEVP method, the result shifted to $\delta = 34.7(1.2)(3.0)^\circ$ at 475.6 MeV. This updated value is now statistically consistent with the Roy equation predictions from dispersion theory.
Conclusion
By increasing statistics and refining the operator basis, this work successfully resolves the previous discrepancy in the $I=0$ $\pi\pi$ scattering phase shift. The alignment of Lattice QCD results with dispersion theory at physical pion masses validates the current approach for calculating $K \to \pi\pi$ matrix elements. Future efforts will focus on adding a third operator to further reduce systematic errors and exploring moving frames to map the energy dependence of the phase shifts more comprehensively.
Summary updated