Students’ implicit epistemologies when working at the intersection of engineering and the arts

Joshua Cruz, Noa Bruhis, Nadia Kellam, Suren JayasuriyaInternational Journal of STEM Education 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Background: This paper explores the epistemologies and discourse of undergraduate students at the transdisciplinary intersection of engineering and the arts. Our research questions focus on the kinds of knowledge that students value, use, and identify within an interdisciplinary digital media program, as well as how they talk about using these epistemologies while navigating this transdisciplinary intersection.

Methods: Six interviews were conducted with students pursuing a semester-long senior capstone project in the digital culture undergraduate degree program in the School of Arts, Media and Engineering at Arizona State University. Using deductive coding followed by discourse analysis, a variety of student epistemologies including positivism, constructionism, and pragmatism were observed.

Results: “Border epistemologies” are introduced as a way to think and/or construct knowledge with differing value across disciplines. Further, discourse analysis highlighted students’ identifications with being either an artist or an engineer and revealed linguistic choice in how students use knowledge and problem-solve in these situations.

Conclusions: Students in a digital media program use fluid, changing epistemological viewpoints when working on their projects, partly driven by orientations with arts and/or engineering. The findings from this study can lead to implications for the design and teaching of transdisciplinary capstones in the future.

Introduction

While "STEAM" (STEM + Arts) education is a growing trend, the integration of these fields is often superficial. STEM fields typically lean on positivism—the belief that there is an objective, discoverable truth (e.g., a "correct" way to code). In contrast, the arts often lean on constructionism—the idea that knowledge is interpreted and socially negotiated.

When students enter transdisciplinary programs like Arizona State University’s "Digital Culture" major, they must reconcile these conflicting "ways of knowing" (epistemologies). This study investigates how students manage this mental friction and how it affects their professional identity as they move between technical engineering tasks and expressive artistic creation.

Methodology and Participants

The researchers employed a two-step qualitative approach. First, they conducted hour-long semi-structured interviews with six senior capstone students. These interviews were analyzed using a priori deductive coding to tag responses with established philosophical categories (e.g., Positivism, Pragmatism, Constructionism). This was followed by discourse analysis to examine specific linguistic choices—such as conjunctions like "but" or "so"—to see how students positioned themselves relative to different disciplines.

Table 1: Participant demographics and project descriptions.

As shown in Table 1, the participant pool consisted of six undergraduate students (5 female, 1 male) working on diverse capstone projects ranging from EEG headbands to augmented reality games. The interview protocol (Table 2) was designed to elicit reflections on their problem-solving processes and the types of knowledge they prioritized.

Table 2: Semi-structured interview questions used in the study.

Findings: Navigating "Border Epistemologies"

The study identified three dominant epistemological alignments in the STEAM environment:

  • Constructionism/Interpretation: Linked almost exclusively to artistic themes. Knowledge is seen as something the viewer interprets, not an absolute truth.
  • Positivism ("Right" vs. "Wrong"): Frequently appeared when students discussed coding or hardware. Students often deferred to professors as "holders of knowledge" and sought the "right" syntax.
  • Pragmatism ("Working"): The most common bridge. Students cared less about absolute truth and more about whether the system was "usable" or "functional."

Key Insights

  • The "Deficiency" Trap: Students who identified primarily as artists often felt "deficient" or like "outsiders" when faced with engineering tasks. They perceived engineering as having a "correct way" that they hadn't mastered, leading to a "me vs. them" mentality regarding engineering students.
  • Engineering as "Easy" vs. Art as "Hard": Interestingly, some students viewed engineering as "easier" because it has a stable truth to learn, whereas art was seen as "harder" because it requires "critical thinking" to negotiate meaning with an audience.
  • Linguistic Markers of Shifting Logic: Words like "realistic" or "it works" serve as anchors. When a student says they need to be "realistic," they are often signaling a shift from an artistic epistemology to a positivist/pragmatic engineering one to satisfy project requirements.

Discussion and Conclusion

The authors conclude that students in these programs are in a constant state of "epistemological boundary crossing." While this fluidity is necessary for transdisciplinary work, it can be emotionally taxing and often reinforces traditional hierarchies where technical knowledge is viewed as more "objective" than artistic knowledge.

Limitations and Future Work

With only six participants from a single program, the findings are "transferable" (providing a deep model) rather than "generalizable" to all STEM students. Future research should examine how these conflicting epistemologies play out in real-time during group collaborations and how faculty discourse intentionally or unintentionally reinforces the idea that engineering knowledge should take precedence over artistic knowledge.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background This paper explores the epistemologies and discourse of undergraduate students at the transdisciplinary intersection of engineering and the arts. Our research questions focus on the kinds of knowledge that students value, use, and identify within an interdisciplinary digital media program, as well as how they talk about using these epistemologies while navigating this transdisciplinary intersection. Six interviews were conducted with students pursuing a semester-long senior capstone project in the digital culture undergraduate degree program in the School of Arts, Media and Engineering at Arizona State University that emphasizes the intersection between arts, media, and engineering. Results Using deductive coding followed by discourse analysis, a variety of student epistemologies including positivism, constructionism, and pragmatism were observed. “Border epistemologies” are introduced as a way to think and/or construct knowledge with differing value across disciplines. Further, discourse analysis highlighted students’ identifications with being either an artist or an engineer and revealed linguistic choice in how students use knowledge and problem-solve in these situations. Conclusions Students in a digital media program use fluid, changing epistemological viewpoints when working on their projects, partly driven by orientations with arts and/or engineering. The findings from this study can lead to implications for the design and teaching of transdisciplinary capstones in the future.
BibTeX
@article{cruz2021students,
  author = {Joshua Cruz and Noa Bruhis and Nadia Kellam and Suren Jayasuriya},
  title = {{Students’ implicit epistemologies when working at the intersection of engineering and the arts}},
  journal = {International Journal of STEM Education},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s40594-021-00289-w},
}

Loading related content...

Figure