Student Textbook Use in Introductory Physics

Karen Cummings, Tim French, Patrick Cooney2002 · DOI

Abstract

This article, presented at the 2002 Physics Education Research Conference, reports on a two-part study examining the extent to which students use a textbook in calculus-based introductory physics courses for scientists and engineers. The first aspect of the study is an investigation of how the placement of worked examples influences student use of the textbook. The second aspect studied is how course assignments can be used to encourage students to read the textbook.

Introduction

Educators often struggle with the realization that students rarely engage deeply with assigned textbooks. This study addresses two primary questions regarding this "engagement gap":

  1. Does the physical layout of the textbook—specifically the placement of worked examples—influence whether students read the explanatory text?
  2. Can specific course assignments effectively encourage students to read before attending lectures?

The researchers sought to determine if the traditional industry standard of placing examples at the end of chapters aligns with student preferences and if changing this layout could alter reading habits.

Methods

The study was conducted across two institutions: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) and Millersville University.

At RPI, a crossover experimental design was used with 87 volunteers (67 of whom provided consistent longitudinal data). Students were split into two cohorts:

  • Group A used a textbook with examples at the end of the chapter for the first half of the semester, then switched to a version with dispersed examples.
  • Group B started with dispersed examples and switched to the end-of-chapter format mid-semester.

This design allowed students to compare both formats directly. Reading habits were tracked via nine weekly online surveys. At Millersville University, the study was observational; students used a standard textbook but were required to complete "just-in-time" reading assignments before class.

Results and Discussion

Layout Preference vs. Behavior

The data revealed a significant and stable preference for textbooks where worked examples are interspersed throughout the text. Students reported that this "dispersed" format was more helpful for learning.

Student preference for dispersed vs. end-of-chapter worked examples.

However, a critical finding was that preference did not translate into behavior. While students preferred the dispersed layout, switching them to their non-preferred format had no measurable impact on the amount of reading they actually performed. Even "non-readers"—students who primarily used the book to find formulas for homework—expressed a preference for the dispersed layout.

The Impact of Course Structure

The most significant factor influencing reading rates was not the textbook's design, but the course's incentive structure. At RPI, where reading was encouraged but not required for specific assignments, reading rates were low, fluctuating between 20% and 40%. In contrast, Millersville University students, who were required to submit answers to reading exercises before class as part of a "just-in-time" teaching model, showed much higher engagement.

Comparison of reading rates at RPI (weekly surveys) vs. Millersville University (M.U.).

The Millersville cohort maintained a reading rate of approximately 58%, nearly double the average seen at RPI. This suggests that students generally do not view reading as an intrinsically useful intellectual endeavor for physics unless it is tied directly to their course grade or immediate classroom preparation.

Conclusion

The study concludes that while students overwhelmingly prefer textbooks with interspersed worked examples, layout changes alone are insufficient to change student behavior. To bridge the engagement gap, instructors must implement pedagogical strategies, such as "just-in-time" assignments, that explicitly require and reward reading.

Future research should explore the efficacy of different types of reading assignments and the potential for digital, interactive textbooks to further enhance student engagement.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article, presented at the 2002 Physics Education Research Conference, reports on a two part study examining the extent to which students use a textbook in calculus-based introductory physics courses for scientists and engineers. The first aspect of the study is an investigation of how the placement of worked examples influences student use of the textbook. The second aspect studied is how course assignments can be used to encourage students to read the textbook.
BibTeX
@misc{cummings2002student,
  author = {Karen Cummings and Tim French and Patrick Cooney},
  title = {{Student Textbook Use in Introductory Physics}},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1119/perc.2002.pr.001},
}
Figure