Student experience using synchronous and asynchronous instruction in mathematics classes

Nagham M. Mohammad, Mihai Nica, Daniel Kraus, Kimberly M. Levere, Rachel OknerPedagogical 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how first-year university calculus students experienced synchronous and asynchronous online learning. It found that synchronous instruction generally led to more comfort asking questions, a greater sense of similarity to in-person classes, and higher perceived collaboration, though it also came with more technology issues. The findings offer practical recommendations for designing more effective online mathematics courses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic forced a rapid shift to online education, particularly impacting post-secondary mathematics, a field often considered challenging to teach effectively online due to its cumulative and feedback-dependent nature. While online learning has been explored, there's a lack of specific pedagogical research on how different online instructional modalities (synchronous vs. asynchronous) affect student experiences in undergraduate mathematics. This study aims to fill that gap by examining student perceptions of various aspects of their online learning experience in large first-year calculus classes.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative and qualitative data from student surveys. They administered an online survey to 496 first-year calculus students across three different online course structures at the University of Guelph. The survey included Likert scale questions to gauge student perceptions on factors like attitudes towards questions, similarity to face-to-face learning, technology issues, self-regulation, and interactivity. It also included open-ended questions for qualitative feedback. Statistical analysis, including Kruskal-Wallis tests and post-hoc Dunn's tests, was used to identify significant differences between the three course groups.

Datasets

The study utilized survey responses from 496 first-year students enrolled in three large calculus courses at the University of Guelph during the Fall 2020 semester. No new datasets were introduced; the data was collected through surveys designed by the authors for this specific research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synchronous learning fosters question-asking: Students in synchronous lectures felt significantly more comfortable asking questions in real-time compared to those in asynchronous settings. This highlights the value of immediate interaction for clarifying doubts in mathematics.
  • Synchronous feels more "real": Students in synchronous classes perceived their online learning experience as more similar to traditional face-to-face instruction, suggesting that real-time interaction contributes to a more familiar and engaging learning environment.
  • Collaboration thrives in synchronous settings: Synchronous instruction led to a significantly higher sense of collaboration among students, likely due to the real-time interaction and peer engagement inherent in live sessions.
  • Technology is a double-edged sword: While synchronous learning offered perceived benefits, it also correlated with more reported technology issues, likely due to the reliance on stable internet connections and real-time platform functionality.
  • Asynchronous offers flexibility but lacks engagement: Asynchronous learning was appreciated for its flexibility in pace and scheduling, but it was associated with a lower sense of collaboration and made it harder for students to ask questions in real-time.

Key Results

  • Student attitudes towards questions: Synchronously-lectured students (MATH1200) were significantly more comfortable asking questions in real-time than those in asynchronous courses (MATH1080DE).
  • Similarity to face-to-face learning: Synchronous students (MATH1200) reported a significantly higher similarity to traditional face-to-face learning compared to asynchronous students (MATH1080DE).
  • Technology issues: Students in synchronous lectures (MATH1200) reported significantly more technology-related issues than those in asynchronous or DE courses (MATH1080DE, MATH*1030).
  • Ability to keep up with course material: Synchronous students (MATH1200) felt significantly more able to stay on top of course material than those in asynchronous settings (MATH1080DE, MATH*1030).
  • Student-student collaboration: Synchronous students (MATH1200) reported a much higher sense of collaboration than students in asynchronous settings (MATH1080DE, MATH*1030).
  • Learning method preferences: While many students across all formats preferred face-to-face learning, synchronous students showed a stronger preference for it. Conversely, students in asynchronous settings generally preferred synchronous delivery of lectures.
  • No significant differences: Time-management abilities and student-teacher communication challenges did not show significant differences across the three groups.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Scope: The study focused on first-year mathematics students in large classes, limiting the generalizability of findings to other student populations or academic disciplines.
  • Observational Design: The study was observational, meaning confounding variables like instructor attitude or teaching style could influence student responses.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research could involve experimental designs where instructors teach multiple sections using different formats or where students are randomly assigned to groups. They also propose exploring blended or hybrid learning approaches and investigating whether course delivery type impacts student achievement. Further research could also examine the preferences of upper-year students.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper aims to study the effects that asynchronous and synchronous instructional methods have on student perceptions and attitudes towards online education. We analyze both qualitative and quantitative survey responses from 496 students in three large (greater than 200 enrolled students) first-year calculus classes at the University of Guelph. The survey results show significant differences among the three online instructional formats in students’ attitudes toward asking questions, the similarity of each instructional modality to face-to-face delivery, technology issues encountered, students’ perceived ability to keep up with course content, how collaborative the course felt, and student preferences for mode of delivery. There were no significant differences reported in relation to time-management skills or communication with instructors. Qualitative analysis of student comments also revealed perceived strengths and weaknesses of each mode of instruction. The results are used to make suggestions for improving student experience in online, post-secondary mathematical teaching.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mohammad2024student,
  author = {Nagham M. Mohammad and Mihai Nica and Daniel Kraus and Kimberly M. Levere and Rachel Okner},
  title = {{Student experience using synchronous and asynchronous instruction in mathematics classes}},
  booktitle = {Pedagogical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.29333/pr/14244},
}
Figure