Structuring the skies: Diel dynamics of migratory animal movement in the lower atmosphere

Silvia Giuntini, Carolyn S. Burt, Annika L. Abbott, Carrie Ann Adams, Maria Carolina T. D. Belotti, Yuting Deng, Miguel F. Jimenez, Jeffrey F. Kelly, Subhransu Maji, Meredith Nash-Martin, Steven L. Simon, Daniel Sheldon, Kyle G. HortonEcology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages a massive dataset of weather radar observations to reveal the structured, diel (daily) patterns of migratory animal movement in the lower atmosphere. By analyzing over 108 million radar scans, the research demonstrates that the airspace is predominantly used at night, with distinct temporal and spatial envelopes of activity, highlighting its critical role as a dynamic ecological habitat.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite the lower atmosphere being a vast and vital ecological habitat, supporting trillions of organisms for migration, foraging, and even resting, it remains largely understudied and unprioritized for conservation. This lack of understanding hinders our ability to address ecological consequences related to its complex spatial and temporal structure, especially in the face of increasing anthropogenic impacts like structures and light pollution. The paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically characterizing how migratory animals utilize airspace across 24-hour cycles, seasons, and varying latitudes.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated approach to process weather surveillance radar data from 143 NEXRAD sites across the contiguous United States, spanning from 1995 to 2022. Key methodological steps included:

  • Precipitation Removal: A convolutional neural network (MISTNET algorithm) was used to distinguish biological targets from precipitation, a standard but crucial step in radar-based aeroecology.
  • Vertical Profile Generation: Data from the lowest five elevation scans (2.5 to 50 km range) were used to construct vertical profiles of reflectivity up to 3000 m above ground level at 100-m intervals.
  • Reflectivity Traffic Rate Calculation: This metric, representing the total radar cross-section crossing a transect per hour, was computed by vertically integrating reflectivity and ground speed. This is a standard approach for quantifying aerial biomass.
  • Temporal Regularization: Radar scans, which are not collected at perfectly regular intervals, were interpolated to 5-minute intervals to ensure consistent temporal sampling.
  • Diel Activity Calculation: The study calculated the percentage of activity occurring during diurnal and nocturnal phases at a seasonal level, rather than a daily average, to better represent dominant migration system behaviors.
  • Peak Activity Window Determination: Generalized additive models (GAMs) were fitted to time series of traffic rates to identify the hour after sunset when aerial activity peaked.
  • Spatial Envelope Calculation: Instead of just identifying peak flight heights, the study focused on the vertical range (50% and 75% envelopes) that encompassed the majority of migrant passage during peak activity periods.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of over 108 million 5-minute weather surveillance radar scans from 143 NEXRAD sites across the contiguous United States, collected between 1995 and 2022. This represents a substantial temporal coverage, with an average of 26 years of data per station. The paper also references existing datasets for specific analyses, such as:

  • Sheldon et al. (2023) for processed weather surveillance radar data.
  • Horton (2025c) for summarized seasonal flight envelopes and timing of peak migration.
  • Horton (2025a) for percentage of diel activity data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Airspace as a Structured Habitat: The study strongly reinforces the idea that the lower atmosphere is not just empty space but a structured, dynamic habitat with predictable temporal and spatial organization, crucial for migratory species.
  • Nocturnal Dominance: The overwhelming preference for nocturnal activity (88% in spring and autumn) highlights the importance of darkness for many migratory species, likely for predator avoidance and thermoregulation.
  • Latitudinal Gradients: The observed increase in nocturnal activity with latitude in spring and autumn, and its decrease in summer, suggests complex interactions between migration timing, insect abundance, and environmental cues.
  • Predictable Peak Activity: The consistent timing of peak activity a few hours after sunset provides a predictable window for understanding migration intensity, which has implications for conservation.
  • Vertical Stratification: The identification of a specific vertical envelope for peak activity (around 355m to 871m above ground level) reveals a defined "highway" for migration, offering insights into collision risk with infrastructure.

Key Results

  • Nocturnal Activity: 87.7% of spring and 87.6% of autumn aerial activity occurred during nocturnal phases. Summer showed a more balanced distribution, with 70% of stations having more nocturnal activity, and 54% of overall activity being nocturnal.
  • Latitudinal Trends: Nocturnal activity increased with latitude in spring (slope = 0.257, p = 0.001) and autumn (slope = 0.250, p = 0.016), but decreased with latitude in summer (slope = -0.423, p = 0.011).
  • Peak Activity Timing: Peak aerial activity occurred approximately 4.1 ± 0.7 hours after local sunset in spring and 4.0 ± 0.8 hours after local sunset in autumn. Summer peaks were earlier and more variable (3.6 ± 2.5 hours after sunset).
  • Vertical Envelope: During peak activity, 50% of aerial activity was contained within a mean vertical envelope of 516 ± 264 meters, starting at a mean height of 355 ± 440 meters above ground level.
  • Seasonal Differences: Mean traffic rates were 1.3 times higher in autumn than spring, and 6.3 times higher than summer. Spring traffic rates were 4.6 times greater than summer.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Taxonomic Resolution: The study acknowledges that weather radar data cannot definitively differentiate between birds, bats, and insects. While evidence suggests a bias towards larger reflectors (likely birds at night), further research with biologically dedicated radars or other sensor fusion techniques is needed for finer taxonomic composition.
  • Lowest Altitude Detection: The radar's limited ability to detect very low-altitude movements means some aerial activity, particularly during summer, may have gone undetected.
  • Behavioral Context: The analysis focuses on the spatial and temporal distribution of aerial density, not the specific behavioral context (e.g., foraging, resting, active migration).
  • Summer Flight Height Variability: Due to high variability, flight heights during the summer season were not characterized in detail.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Integrating Data Sources: Combining radar data with extrinsic tracking data (e.g., from loggers) and nocturnal flight call monitoring could provide a more comprehensive understanding of individual flight behavior and taxonomic composition.
  • Investigating Competition: Further research is needed to explore whether competition shapes aerial habitat use, particularly during active migration.
  • Conservation Applications: Applying these findings to assess collision risk with human infrastructure (e.g., wind turbines) and to develop targeted conservation strategies, such as lights-out guidelines, is a key future direction.
  • Broader Taxonomic and Behavioral Studies: Expanding research to include more detailed taxonomic identification and the behavioral mechanisms driving flight altitude is crucial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Earth's lower atmosphere is a vital ecological habitat, home to trillions of organisms that live, forage, and migrate through this medium. Despite its importance, this space is seldom considered a primary habitat for ecological or conservation prioritization, making it one of the least studied environments. However, it plays a crucial role as a global conduit for the transfer of biomass, weather, and inorganic materials. Fundamental research is essential to address core ecological questions related to the ecological consequences of this habitat's intricate spatial and temporal structure. To advance our understanding of airspace use by migratory animals, we analyzed over 108 million 5-min radar observations from 143 NEXRAD sites, focusing on 24-h diel cycles across the contiguous United States. This extensive dataset, spanning from 1995 to 2022, allowed us to quantify aerial space use by systematically identifying peak activity times, the portion of the airspace that contained the majority of migration activity, and the percentage of migrants passing across diurnal and nocturnal diel cycles. We found that airspace is used predominantly during nocturnal periods in both spring and autumn (88%), while summer exhibited a more balanced distribution (54% nocturnal). Additionally, the percentage of nocturnal activity increased with latitude in spring and autumn but decreased in summer. Peak aerial activity typically occurred about 4 h after local sunset in both spring and autumn, with variations based on latitude and longitude. During these peak times, on average, half of the aerial movement was confined within a vertical band of 516 meters, starting around 355 m above ground level. Our research underscores the need to view the lower atmosphere as a structured habitat with significant ecological importance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{giuntini2025structuring,
  author = {Silvia Giuntini and Carolyn S. Burt and Annika L. Abbott and Carrie Ann Adams and Maria Carolina T. D. Belotti and Yuting Deng and Miguel F. Jimenez and Jeffrey F. Kelly and Subhransu Maji and Meredith Nash-Martin and Steven L. Simon and Daniel Sheldon and Kyle G. Horton},
  title = {{Structuring the skies: Diel dynamics of migratory animal movement in the lower atmosphere}},
  booktitle = {Ecology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1002/ecy.70247},
}
Figure