Structures promoting research, training, and technology transfer in mobility: lessons learned from a visit to European centers

Michael L. Boninger, Rachel E. Cowan, Benjamin J. FreglyJournal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores successful models for advancing mobility-related assistive technology by examining European research centers. It highlights the critical need for multidisciplinary teams, experiential learning, and robust technology transfer frameworks to bridge the gap between research and real-world impact for individuals with mobility impairments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the persistent challenge of developing and implementing effective assistive technologies for individuals with mobility impairments. While society's choices contribute significantly to disability, the authors argue that a lack of investment and coordinated effort in research, education, and technology transfer hinders progress. They identify a shortage of well-trained researchers and a need for better models to foster innovation and ensure that research translates into tangible improvements in clinical care and daily life for users.

Methods

The authors, a multidisciplinary team of senior researchers with mobility impairments, physicians, engineers, and rehabilitation scientists, visited approximately 30 rehabilitation research laboratories across 8 European countries. The visits were facilitated by the World Technology Evaluation Center (WTEC) and included universities, private companies, and funding agencies. The team used a questionnaire to gather information from each site and conducted separate group visits. The paper then synthesizes findings across four key areas: education, research, technology transfer, and cross-country collaboration.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Multidisciplinary Teams are Paramount: Success hinges on bringing together diverse expertise (clinicians, engineers, industry partners, and crucially, end-users) to tackle complex problems.
  • Experiential Learning is Key: Moving beyond didactic lectures to hands-on, problem-based learning (like the REHANDFUN course) significantly enhances student understanding and teamwork.
  • Proximity Fuels Collaboration: While interdisciplinary work is discussed, actual close physical proximity among team members is vital for effective collaboration.
  • Inclusion of End-Users is Critically Lacking: A significant gap exists in the inclusion of individuals with mobility impairments as students, teachers, or researchers, despite their essential perspective.
  • Technology Transfer Needs Supportive Policies: Clear policies, particularly regarding intellectual property and conflict of interest, are crucial for facilitating the transition of research into commercially viable products.
  • Industry Collaboration is a Strong Model: Built-in industry partnerships, whether through nearby startups or integrated collaborations, significantly boost technology transfer success.
  • Centers of Excellence are Necessary: Creating specialized centers with substantial infrastructure and funding is essential for tackling the complex challenges in mobility technology.
  • Targeted Programs for Disabled Individuals: Encouraging individuals with disabilities to pursue careers in engineering and related fields is vital for ensuring technologies truly meet their needs.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results in terms of specific performance metrics. Instead, it offers qualitative insights and identifies best practices observed in European centers. The "results" are the identification of successful structures and models in education, research, and technology transfer, along with critical gaps. For example, the paper highlights the success of institutions like Imperial College London and Aalborg University for their innovative educational approaches, and the collaborative model in Zurich involving ETH Zurich, Balgrist Hospital, ZAR, and Hocoma as a strong example of research and technology transfer synergy.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the trip was limited to one week, meaning many outstanding laboratories were likely not included. A significant limitation identified across all areas is the lack of inclusion of individuals with mobility impairments within the educational and research teams. They also note that while collaborations fostered by funding mechanisms can be positive, not all collaborations function effectively, and the drive for funding can sometimes lead to superficial partnerships.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Establishing more multidisciplinary teams in both research and education.
  • Developing supportive policies for technology transfer.
  • Incorporating more experiential learning into educational programs.
  • Investing in "centers of excellence" to foster innovation.
  • Creating targeted programs to encourage individuals with disabilities to enter engineering and related fields.
  • Expanding information exchange to include other parts of the world beyond Europe and the US.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to describe the education, research, technology transfer, and cooperative models that appear to have the greatest likelihood of successfully tackling the issue of technology to improve mobility. Ideally better models in each of these areas will lead to an increased number of researchers who are more productive. There will be increased international collaboration that will allow for better research with small and/or disadvantaged populations, and the research completed will lead to changes in clinical care that positively impact individuals with impair mobility.
BibTeX
@article{boninger2012structures,
  author = {Michael L. Boninger and Rachel E. Cowan and Benjamin J. Fregly},
  title = {{Structures promoting research, training, and technology transfer in mobility: lessons learned from a visit to European centers}},
  journal = {Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1186/1743-0003-9-19},
}

Loading related content...

Figure