Structure–Property Relevance of Two Pairs of Isomeric Steviol Rebaudiosides and the Underlying Mechanism

Zhuoyu Zhou, Wanjie Wang, Qinbing Guo, Haijun Wang, Yongmei XiaFoods 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the specific structure of steviol glycosides (SGs), particularly the type and position of sugar attachments, dictates their solubility, sweetness, and stability. By synthesizing a novel SG isomer and comparing it with existing ones, the researchers found that glycosidic linkage type and position are more critical than the number of sugar units for these properties, offering insights for designing better natural sweeteners.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Steviol glycosides (SGs) are popular natural sweeteners derived from the Stevia plant, offering a calorie-free alternative to sugar. However, their widespread adoption is hindered by certain limitations, primarily poor solubility and sometimes undesirable aftertastes (like bitterness). While it's known that adding more sugar units (glycosylation) can improve taste and solubility, the precise relationship between SG structure and these properties remains unclear. Specifically, how the type of sugar linkage (e.g., α-1,6 vs. β-1,2) and its position on the steviol backbone influence solubility, sweetness, and stability is not well understood. This lack of clarity makes it challenging to rationally design new SGs with improved characteristics. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by systematically comparing isomeric SGs to pinpoint the structural determinants of their physicochemical and sensory properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Enzymatic Synthesis: A novel SG isomer, RA1G (an α-1,6-mono-glucosylated rebaudioside A), was synthesized using alternansucrase, an enzyme known for its ability to create specific glycosidic linkages. Reaction conditions (temperature, pH, substrate ratios, metal ions, enzyme dosage) were optimized to maximize RA1G yield.
  • Structural Characterization: The synthesized RA1G was characterized using standard analytical techniques including High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC), Mass Spectrometry (MS), and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy (¹H, ¹³C, COSY, TOCSY, HSQC, HMBC) to confirm its structure and purity.
  • Physicochemical Property Measurement:
    • Solubility: Determined in water and ethanol/water mixtures at 25 °C.
  • Crystal Properties: Analyzed using X-ray Powder Diffraction (XRD) and Polarizing Microscopy.
  • Thermal Stability: Assessed using Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) and Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC).
  • Solution Interfacial Properties: Measured using a surface tensiometer.
  • Sensory Evaluation: A panel of human evaluators assessed the sweetness, bitterness, and other taste attributes of aqueous solutions of the SGs.
  • Computational Simulation: Molecular docking simulations were performed to estimate the binding energies of the SGs with sweet (hT1R2/hT1R3) and bitter (hT2R4) taste receptors. Solvation free energy calculations were also conducted to understand solubility mechanisms.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study relies on:

  • Commercial SGs: Rebaudioside A (RA), Rebaudioside D (RD), and Rebaudioside E (RE) were purchased with specified purities.
  • Synthesized SG: RA1G was produced in this study.
  • Computational Models: Homology models of human sweet and bitter taste receptors were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Glycosidic Linkage is King: The most significant finding is that the type and position of the glycosidic linkage are far more influential on SG properties (solubility, sweetness, stability) than simply the number of sugar units. This challenges the intuitive assumption that more sugar always equals better properties.
  • The C19 Position's Dual Nature: Attaching a glucose at the C19 position of the steviol backbone can have opposing effects. While it can increase polarity, the specific β-1,2 linkage in RD and RE seems to hinder hydrogen bonding with water, leading to poor solubility.
  • The Power of α-1,6: The α-1,6 linkage in the synthesized RA1G appears to confer greater flexibility and enhance water solubility significantly, making it a promising candidate for improved sweetener formulations.
  • Sweetness vs. Bitterness Trade-off: Computational modeling suggests an inverse relationship between binding energy to sweet receptors and sweetness intensity, and similarly for bitter receptors and bitterness. This implies that structural modifications can be tuned to optimize taste profiles.
  • RA1G: A Promising Alternative: RA1G exhibits a desirable combination of good sweetness (similar to RD), significantly improved solubility (much higher than RA and RD), and a pleasant taste profile, suggesting its potential for broader food and beverage applications.

Key Results

  • Solubility: RA1G demonstrated exceptional aqueous solubility (58.90 mg/mL), which is 13 times that of RA (4.55 mg/mL) and a remarkable 137 times that of RD (0.43 mg/mL). RE also showed low solubility (0.34 mg/mL).
  • Sweetness: Sensory evaluation indicated the sweetness order as RA > RD ~ RA1G > RE. While RA1G was slightly less sweet than RA, its sweetness was comparable to RD and it offered a "pleasant and pure sweetness" with a mint-like flavor, mitigating bitterness.
  • Stability: All tested SGs showed high stability (over 98% retention) in simulated digestive fluids (pH 1.5 and 6.8) for 8 hours. Thermal stability generally increased with the number of sugar moieties and the presence of β-glycosidic bonds. RA1G was stable up to 225 °C.
  • Computational Binding Energies:
    • Sweet receptors (hT1R2/hT1R3): RA (-20.7 kcal/mol) < RD (-17.2 kcal/mol) < RA1G (-15.7 kcal/mol) < RE (−15 kcal/mol). RA had the highest binding energy, correlating with its highest sweetness.
  • Bitter receptor (hT2R4): RA (-9.6 kcal/mol) > RE (-6.6 kcal/mol) > RA1G (-6.3 kcal/mol) > RD (-5.5 kcal/mol). RD had the lowest binding energy, correlating with its least bitter perception.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Isomer Pairs: While the study compares two pairs of isomers (RA/RE and RD/RA1G), a more comprehensive study across a wider range of isomers could further solidify the structure-property relationships.
  • Computational vs. Experimental: While computational simulations provide valuable mechanistic insights, experimental validation of all predicted interactions and energies is crucial. The paper notes that bitterness perception is complex and may involve more than just hydrogen bonds.
  • Sensory Panel Size: The sensory evaluation panel was relatively small (10 people). Larger, more diverse panels could provide more robust sensory data.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the insights gained can guide the synthesis of novel SGs with tailored properties. Further exploration into the specific interactions governing solubility and taste perception, especially for bitterness, is warranted. The potential of RA1G as a functional ingredient in food and beverage applications due to its improved solubility and taste profile is highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although enormous efforts have been made to prepare tasty and soluble steviol glycosides (SGs), the structure–property relationship of SGs still remains unclear, neither in experiment fact nor in the mechanism, such as the influence of linkage type and position of substituted glucosyl on physiochemical properties and sensory features of SGs. The favorable SGs, rebaudioside D (RD) and rebaudioside A (RA), possess good edulcorant quality, poor solubility, and other significantly different physical properties. This research chose two pairs of isomeric SGs, RA and its isomer rebaudioside E (RE) and RD and its isomer RA1G (a synthetic SG, α-1,6-mono-glucosylated RA), to conduct a comparative study, aiming to reveal the structure–property relevance on their solubility, sweetness, stability, and crystal structure. The RA1G presents an aqueous solubility 13 times that of RA and 137 times that of RD and exhibits better edulcorant quality than that of RA, similar to RD. The results indicate that the glucosyl linkage type and position have a stronger impact on the properties of the SGs than the number of glucosyl moieties. The underlying mechanism of their structure–property relevance was elucidated by analyzing the interaction energies between the SGs with solvent and human receptor proteins, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2025structureproperty,
  author = {Zhuoyu Zhou and Wanjie Wang and Qinbing Guo and Haijun Wang and Yongmei Xia},
  title = {{Structure–Property Relevance of Two Pairs of Isomeric Steviol Rebaudiosides and the Underlying Mechanism}},
  booktitle = {Foods},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/foods14111917},
}
Figure