Structure Prior Effects in Bayesian Approaches of Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping

Shuai Wang, Weiwei Chen, Chunmei Wang, Tian Liu, Yi Wang, Chu Pan, Ketao Mu, Ce Zhu, Xiang Zhang, Jian ChengBioMed 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how incorporating structural information from MRI magnitude images improves Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping (QSM). By using a "structure prior," researchers found that QSM algorithms produce more accurate and visually appealing results, particularly in reducing artifacts, across simulations, phantom experiments, and human brain data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping (QSM) is a powerful MRI technique that generates maps of magnetic susceptibility, which can reveal important information about tissue composition, such as iron content or the presence of contrast agents. However, reconstructing these maps from MRI data is an "ill-posed" problem, meaning there isn't a single, unique solution. This ambiguity can lead to artifacts, especially streaking, that obscure important details and reduce diagnostic accuracy. Previous QSM methods have relied on various regularization techniques (like piece-wise constant, smooth, or sparse priors) to guide the reconstruction towards a plausible solution. This paper specifically addresses the question of whether incorporating structural information from the MRI magnitude image itself, as a "structure prior," can further enhance the accuracy and image quality of Bayesian QSM approaches.

Methods

The core of this research lies in evaluating six different QSM algorithms, some of which are enhanced with a "structure prior." The Bayesian QSM framework is used, where the goal is to find the susceptibility map ($\chi$) that minimizes a cost function. This cost function has two main components: a data fidelity term (how well the reconstructed map explains the measured MRI data) and a regularization term (which enforces desired properties on the map).

The paper explores several regularization terms:

  • Gradient L2 norm (GL2): Encourages smooth susceptibility maps.
  • Gradient L1 norm (GL1): Promotes sparsity in the gradients, leading to sharper edges.
  • Total Variation (TV) norm: Encourages piecewise constant regions, preserving edges while reducing noise.
  • Wavelet L1 norm: Utilizes wavelet transforms for sparsity.
  • Combined priors (e.g., TV + Wavelet): Merges different regularization strategies.
  • MEDI (Morphology Enabled Dipole Inversion): A specific algorithm that incorporates a structure prior.

The "structure prior" ($m$) is derived from the MRI magnitude image. It essentially highlights regions with significant structural gradients (edges) and assigns them a different weight in the regularization process. This is achieved by setting gradients above a certain threshold to 1 and below to 0, effectively telling the algorithm to pay more attention to structural boundaries. The paper then compares the performance of algorithms with and without this structure prior, using different solvers (Conjugate Gradient and Lagged Diffusivity Fixed Point Method).

Datasets

The paper utilizes three types of datasets for evaluation:

  • Numerical Simulation: A synthetic "Zubal-type" phantom was created, mimicking a human brain with a spherical lesion to simulate a low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) region. This phantom had known susceptibility values, allowing for precise accuracy measurements.
  • Phantom Experiments: A physical phantom was constructed using spherical balloons filled with varying concentrations of Gadolinium-DTPA (Gd-DTPA) in water. This allowed for controlled experiments with known susceptibility values.
  • In Vivo Brain Imaging: Data from 36 human patients were used. These were divided into two groups: 18 consecutive cases without hemorrhagic lesions (group 1) and 18 consecutive cases with hemorrhages (group 2). This dataset was crucial for evaluating clinical applicability and image quality in real-world scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structure Matters: The most significant finding is that incorporating structural information from the magnitude image as a "structure prior" consistently improves QSM results. This prior acts as a powerful guide, helping to resolve the inherent ambiguities in the reconstruction process.
  • Artifact Reduction: The structure prior is particularly effective at reducing streaking artifacts, which are a common problem in QSM, especially those originating from blood vessels or hemorrhages.
  • Improved Accuracy and Image Quality: Both quantitative accuracy (measured by NRMSE and regression slopes) and qualitative image quality (assessed by expert radiologists) are enhanced when using the structure prior.
  • Prior Type Influence: While the structure prior generally improves performance, the specific regularization norm (L1, L2, TV) also plays a role. L1-based methods (like GL1 and MEDI) seem to benefit more from the structure prior, especially in challenging cases with significant artifacts.
  • MEDI's Robustness: The MEDI algorithm, which inherently incorporates a structure prior, consistently demonstrated superior performance in terms of both accuracy and image quality across various evaluations.

Key Results

  • Numerical Simulation: The structure prior significantly reduced streaking artifacts for GL2, TV, and GL1 methods. This led to reduced relative errors (NRMSE) and improved regression slopes (closer to 1), indicating higher accuracy.
  • Phantom Experiments: Regression slopes for QSM reconstructions were consistently improved (closer to 1) when the structure prior was applied, demonstrating enhanced accuracy.
  • In Vivo Brain Imaging:
    • Group 1 (No Hemorrhages): Image quality scores were significantly higher with the structure prior. Artifacts from vessels were reduced, and small veins appeared more clearly.
  • Group 2 (With Hemorrhages): Similar improvements were observed, with the structure prior effectively reducing artifacts originating from vessels and hemorrhages.
  • Quantitative Scores: The paper provides specific p-values indicating statistically significant improvements when using the structure prior for various methods and groups. For example, the difference in image quality was statistically significant for GL2, TV, and GL1 (p < 0.001) in group 1.
  • Inter- and Intraobserver Variability: The study found good to excellent agreement among radiologists in assessing image quality, suggesting the subjective evaluations were reliable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Phantom Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the phantom experiments, while useful, used a simplified spherical geometry with uniform Gd concentrations. Real human brain tissue has more complex and subtle contrasts, which might present different challenges.
  • MEDI Prior Imperfection: While MEDI shows excellent results, the paper notes that some cortical folds can appear smoothed, suggesting that the current structure prior in MEDI might still be imperfect.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future work should focus on developing more sophisticated structure priors, potentially by incorporating more detailed edge detection from local field maps or by improving the identification and matching of structures for more accurate QSM. They also highlight the need for further research into more physically meaningful priors. The paper also briefly mentions the impact of different solvers, suggesting that a detailed analysis of solver effects could be a future research avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantitative susceptibility mapping (QSM) has shown its potential for anatomical and functional MRI, as it can quantify, for <i>in vivo</i> tissues, magnetic biomarkers and contrast agents which have differential susceptibilities to the surroundings substances. For reconstructing the QSM with a single orientation, various methods have been proposed to identify a unique solution for the susceptibility map. Bayesian QSM approach is the major type which uses various regularization terms, such as a piece-wise constant, a smooth, a sparse, or a morphological prior. Six QSM algorithms with or without structure prior are systematically discussed to address the structure prior effects. The methods are evaluated using simulations, phantom experiments with the given susceptibility, and human brain data. The accuracy and image quality of QSM were increased when using structure prior in the simulation and phantom compared to same regularization term without it, respectively. The image quality of QSM method using the structure prior is better comparing, respectively, to the method without it by either sharpening the image or reducing streaking artifacts <i>in vivo</i>. The structure priors improve the performance of the various QSMs using regularized minimization including L1, L2, and TV norm.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2016structure,
  author = {Shuai Wang and Weiwei Chen and Chunmei Wang and Tian Liu and Yi Wang and Chu Pan and Ketao Mu and Ce Zhu and Xiang Zhang and Jian Cheng},
  title = {{Structure Prior Effects in Bayesian Approaches of Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping}},
  booktitle = {BioMed},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1155/2016/2738231},
}
Figure