Structure Prediction of Epitaxial Organic Interfaces with Ogre, Demonstrated for TCNQ on TTF

Saeed Moayedpour, Imaneul Bier, Wen Wen, Derek Dardzinski, Olexandr Isayev, Noa MaromarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

This paper introduces a significant update to Ogre, an open-source Python package designed to solve one of the trickiest puzzles in materials science: predicting how complex organic molecules arrange themselves at an interface. By combining traditional crystallography algorithms with modern machine learning and Bayesian optimization, the authors provide a pathway to design better organic electronics.

TL;DR

The authors present an automated workflow in the open-source tool Ogre to predict the structure of epitaxial organic-organic interfaces. By leveraging machine-learned interatomic potentials and Bayesian optimization, they successfully identified the previously unknown interface structure of the TCNQ/TTF donor-acceptor system, showing excellent agreement with experimental spectroscopic data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of organic electronics (like OLEDs and flexible solar cells), the "interface" is where the magic happens—charges are created, moved, or recombined there. When these interfaces are epitaxial (highly ordered), the device performance skyrockets.

However, predicting these structures computationally is a nightmare. Unlike inorganic crystals (like silicon), which have rigid covalent bonds and can be modeled as simple spheres, organic molecules have complex shapes and are held together by weak van der Waals forces. Standard methods for inorganic interfaces fail here, and using high-accuracy Density Functional Theory (DFT) is too computationally expensive for the thousands of atoms required to model these large molecular supercells.

Methods

The authors implemented a multi-step workflow within the Ogre package:

  1. Surface Selection (OgreSWAMP): The tool identifies the most stable facets of the individual crystals by calculating surface energies.
  2. Lattice Matching: Using the Zur and McGill algorithm, Ogre finds "commensurate" supercells—ways the two different crystal lattices can overlay with minimal strain. Because organic epitaxy is "weak," the authors allow for a looser 5% misfit tolerance.
  3. Surface Matching via Bayesian Optimization (BO): This is the core innovation. To find the optimal vertical distance ($z$) and lateral shift ($xy$) between layers, Ogre uses BO to efficiently sample the 3D space.
  4. Machine Learning Potentials: Instead of slow DFT, the BO objective function uses ANI-2x, a deep neural network interatomic potential, supplemented with Grimme D3 dispersion corrections to account for van der Waals forces. This approach is roughly 500 times faster than DFT while maintaining near-DFT accuracy.
  5. Final Ranking: The most promising candidates are refined and ranked using high-level DFT (HSE hybrid functionals).

Datasets

  • ANI-2x: The neural network potentials were pre-trained on a massive, diverse dataset of organic molecule conformations using active learning.
  • TCNQ/TTF: The primary benchmark used is the interface between 7,7,8,8-tetracyanoquinodimethane (TCNQ) and tetrathiafulvalene (TTF).
  • Experimental Validation: Results were compared against existing Ultraviolet Photoemission Spectroscopy (UPS) data from previous literature to verify the electronic "fingerprint" of the predicted structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Weak Epitaxy" Advantage: Organic molecules don't have "dangling bonds" like inorganic surfaces. This means they can achieve stable, ordered growth even when the lattices don't match perfectly, a phenomenon the authors successfully capture by loosening traditional misfit constraints.
  • ML-Powered Search: The use of ANI+D3 potentials allows the researchers to map out the Potential Energy Surface (PES) of an interface containing over 1,000 atoms in seconds.
  • Solving a Cold Case: The structure of TCNQ on TTF had been experimentally probed in 2017, but the exact physical arrangement of the molecules remained a mystery until this study.

Key Results

  • The Winning Structure: The most stable configuration was identified as TCNQ(001) on TTF(100), closely followed by TCNQ(010) on TTF(100).
  • Spectroscopic Match: The calculated Density of States (DOS) for the predicted structure showed a near-perfect match with experimental UPS data.
  • Charge Transfer State: The model correctly predicted a Charge Transfer (CT) state at the interface (around -1.5 eV), confirming that electrons move from the TTF donor to the TCNQ acceptor, creating a conductive "metallic" layer at the junction.
  • Efficiency: The BO algorithm converged to the global minimum within 300 iterations, a fraction of the 47,000+ points a traditional grid search would require.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized Interfaces: Ogre currently predicts "ideal" interfaces. It does not yet account for temperature effects, entropy, or the kinetics of how a film actually grows (which can lead to defects or metastable structures).
  • Flat Surfaces Only: The current model assumes perfectly flat, cleaved surfaces and does not account for molecular "reconstructions" or rough morphologies.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest integrating Ogre into fully automated materials discovery pipelines, allowing researchers to screen thousands of potential organic pairs for the next generation of high-performance transistors and solar cells.

Check out the code: Ogre is open-source and available on GitHub.

Summary updated

Abstract

Highly ordered epitaxial interfaces between organic semiconductors are considered as a promising avenue for enhancing the performance of organic electronic devices including solar cells, light emitting diodes, and transistors, thanks to their well-controlled, uniform electronic properties and high carrier mobilities. Although the phenomenon of organic epitaxy has been known for decades, computational methods for structure prediction of epitaxial organic interfaces have lagged far behind the existing methods for their inorganic counterparts. We present a method for structure prediction of epitaxial organic interfaces based on lattice matching followed by surface matching, implemented in the open-source Python package, Ogre. The lattice matching step produces domain-matched interfaces, where commensurability is achieved with different integer multiples of the substrate and film unit cells. In the surface matching step, Bayesian optimization (BO) is used to find the interfacial distance and registry between the substrate and film. The BO objective function is based on dispersion corrected deep neural network interatomic potentials, shown to be in excellent agreement with density functional theory (DFT). The application of Ogre is demonstrated for an epitaxial interface of 7,7,8,8-tetracyanoquinodimethane (TCNQ) on tetrathiafulvalene (TTF), whose electronic structure has been probed by ultraviolet photoemission spectroscopy (UPS), but whose structure had been hitherto unknown [Organic Electronics 48, 371 (2017)]. We find that TCNQ(001) on top of TTF(100) is the most stable interface configuration, closely followed by TCNQ(010) on top of TTF(100). The density of states, calculated using DFT, is in excellent agreement with UPS, including the presence of an interface charge transfer state.
BibTeX
@misc{moayedpour2023structure,
  author = {Saeed Moayedpour and Imaneul Bier and Wen Wen and Derek Dardzinski and Olexandr Isayev and Noa Marom},
  title = {{Structure Prediction of Epitaxial Organic Interfaces with Ogre, Demonstrated for TCNQ on TTF}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2301.07594},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.07594},
}
Figure