Structure-guided computational insecticide discovery targeting β -N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase of Ostrinia furnacalis

Adeena Tahir, Abdul Rauf Siddiqi, Arooma Maryam, Sundeep Chaitanya Vedithi, Tom L. BlundellJournal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents a structure-guided computational approach to discover novel, environmentally friendly insecticides targeting the Ostrinia furnacalis (corn borer) enzyme β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase (OfHex1). By virtually screening a library of existing compounds and performing molecular dynamics simulations, the researchers identified five promising candidates that specifically bind to the insect enzyme, offering a potential alternative to broad-spectrum pesticides.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional insecticides, while effective, often have significant drawbacks: they can cause collateral damage to beneficial insects and mammals, lead to pest resistance, and pose environmental hazards. The Ostrinia furnacalis moth is a major agricultural pest, causing substantial losses to corn crops globally. The researchers aim to address the need for more targeted and environmentally benign pest control by identifying specific inhibitors of a crucial enzyme in O. furnacalis, β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase (OfHex1). This enzyme is vital for insect chitin breakdown and is absent in humans and plants, making it an attractive target for selective insecticides. The challenge lies in finding compounds that are potent against OfHex1 while avoiding interactions with similar enzymes in non-target organisms.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged computational strategy:

  • Structure-Guided Virtual Screening: They utilized the crystal structures of O. furnacalis OfHex1 (PDB Id: 3NSN) and human β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase (PDB Id: 1NP0), along with an AlphaFold model for Trichogramma pretiosum (a beneficial parasitoid), as targets.
  • Ligand Preparation: A library of 20,313 commercially available and "insecticide-like" compounds was prepared using LigPrep to generate 44,943 ready-to-dock conformers.
  • Molecular Docking: The Glide docking algorithm (Schrödinger Suite) was used for virtual screening. This involved:
  • Reference Docking: Co-crystallized ligands were redocked to validate the docking protocol and establish binding constraints.
  • Virtual Screening Workflow (VSW): Compounds were screened against the OfHex1 target.
  • Hit Selection: Compounds that showed high binding scores to OfHex1 but not to human or T. pretiosum homologues were selected.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: Promising hits were subjected to MD simulations using Desmond to assess the stability of their interactions with OfHex1 over time.
  • MM/GBSA Calculations: Binding free energies were calculated to further evaluate the affinity of the selected compounds.
  • Comprehensive Pesticide Likeness Analysis (CoPLA): This analysis assessed the "pesticide-likeness" of the top compounds using established rules (Tice, Hao) and quantitative metrics to predict their potential as agrochemicals and their safety profile.

Datasets

  • Protein Structures:
    • Ostrinia furnacalis β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase (OfHex1) crystal structure (PDB Id: 3NSN).
  • Human β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase crystal structure (PDB Id: 1NP0).
  • AlphaFold model of Trichogramma pretiosum β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase.
  • Compound Library: A library of 20,313 commercially available and "insecticide-like" compounds, extracted from published literature and databases (e.g., ChemFACES, LifeChemicals, InsectiPAD, Otava Chemicals, EU Pesticide Database, Enamine Insecticides Clusters, ChemDIV).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Enzyme Specificity is Key: The distinct differences in the substrate binding site of O. furnacalis OfHex1 compared to its human and T. pretiosum counterparts are crucial for designing selective inhibitors.
  • Computational Power for Discovery: The study demonstrates the effectiveness of a multi-step computational approach (virtual screening, docking, MD simulations, MM/GBSA) in identifying potential drug candidates from large chemical libraries.
  • Importance of Stability: Molecular dynamics simulations were essential to confirm that the initial docking poses represented stable interactions, not just transient binding.
  • Pesticide-Likeness Matters: Beyond just binding affinity, evaluating compounds for their "pesticide-likeness" (considering properties like molecular weight, toxicity, and environmental impact) is critical for developing practical agrochemicals.
  • Conserved Residues, Unique Opportunities: While key catalytic residues are conserved across species, the presence of unique loops in OfHex1 (e.g., L314-335 and L478-496) offers specific binding opportunities not present in human homologues.

Key Results

  • 18 OfHex1-Specific Hits: The virtual screening identified 18 unique conformers from 15 compounds that specifically bound to O. furnacalis OfHex1 and not to human or T. pretiosum homologues.
  • 5 Promising Candidates: After MD simulations and binding free energy calculations, five compounds were identified as having consistent and stable binding to the OfHex1 active site.
  • Favorable Binding Scores: These five compounds exhibited strong docking scores (Glide g-scores < -12.950 kcal/mol) and binding energies.
  • Low-Risk Toxicity Profile: Comprehensive pesticide likeness analysis indicated that these five compounds have a low-risk toxicity probability for both humans and honeybees.
  • Diverse Chemical Scaffolds: The identified compounds represent a diverse range of chemical structures, increasing the likelihood of finding a lead compound with desirable properties.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Vitro Validation Needed: The authors acknowledge that further in vitro validation is required to confirm the utility and potency of these identified compounds as potential insecticides.
  • Further Optimization: While promising, the identified compounds may require further structural modifications to optimize their efficacy, selectivity, and pharmacokinetic properties for practical application.
  • Mechanism of Action: While interactions with key residues like W490, W524, E328, and Y475 were highlighted, a deeper understanding of the precise mechanism by which these compounds inhibit OfHex1 activity could guide future drug design.
  • Environmental Impact Studies: While CoPLA provides an initial assessment, more detailed environmental impact studies would be necessary for any candidate moving towards development.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Ostrinia furnacalis</i> is a species of moth in the Crambidae family that is harmful to maize and other corn crops in Southeast Asia and the Western Pacific regions. <i>Ostrinia furnacalis</i> causes devastating losses to economically important corn fields. The β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase is an essential enzyme in <i>O. furnacalis</i> and its substrate binding +1 active site is different from that of the plants and humans β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidases. To develop environment-friendly insecticides against OfHex1, we conducted structure-guided computational insecticide discovery to identify potential inhibitors that can bind the active site and inhibit the substrate binding and activity of the enzyme. We adopted a three-pronged strategy to conduct virtual screening using Glide and virtual screening workflow (VSW) in Schrödinger Suite-2022-3, against crystal structures of OfHex1 (PDB Id:3NSN), its homologue in humans (PDB Id: 1NP0) and Alphafold model of β-N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase from <i>Trichogramma pretiosum</i>, an egg parasitoid that protects the crops from <i>O. furnacalis.</i> A library of 20,313 commercially available and "insecticide-like" compounds was extracted from published literature. LigPrep enabled 44,943 ready-to-dock conformers generation. Glide docking revealed 18 OfHex1-specific hits that were absent in human and <i>T. pretiosum</i> screens. Reference docking was conducted using inhibitors/natural ligands in the crystal structures and hits with better docking scores than the reference were selected for MD simulations using Desmond to understand the stability of hit-target interactions. We noted five compounds that bound to OfHex1 TMX active-site based on their docking scores, consistent binding as noted by MD simulations and their insecticide/pesticide likeliness as noted by the Comprehensive Pesticide Likeness Analysis.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.
BibTeX
@article{tahir2023structure,
  author = {Adeena Tahir and Abdul Rauf Siddiqi and Arooma Maryam and Sundeep Chaitanya Vedithi and Tom L. Blundell},
  title = {{Structure-guided computational insecticide discovery targeting <i>β</i> -N-acetyl-D-hexosaminidase of <i>Ostrinia furnacalis</i>}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1080/07391102.2023.2264394},
}
Figure