Structure-based analysis of CysZ-mediated cellular uptake of sulfate

Zahra Assur Sanghai, Qun Liu, Oliver B. Clarke, Edgar Leal Pinto, Brian Kloss, Shantelle Tabuso, J. Love, Marco Punta, Surajit Banerjee, Kanagalaghatta R. Rajashankar, Burkhard Rost, Diomedes E. Logothetis, Matthias Quick, Wayne A. Hendrickson, Filippo ManciabioRxiv 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Sulfur is an essential element for all living cells, serving as a core component of amino acids, co-factors, and vitamins. In the environment, it is most commonly found as sulfate ($SO_4^{2-}$). Despite its importance, the molecular mechanisms governing its cellular delivery have remained poorly understood. CysZ has long been identified as a sulfate permease, yet its sequence family lacked any known structural precedent. This study provides the first high-resolution insights into the molecular mechanism of CysZ-mediated sulfate translocation. By combining X-ray crystallography, functional uptake experiments in cells and proteoliposomes, and single-channel conductance measurements, we reveal that CysZ possesses a unique protein fold and a rare dual-topology assembly, functioning as a specialized ion channel rather than a traditional transporter.

Introduction

Acquiring inorganic sulfate from the environment is a fundamental requirement for most bacteria and plants. While several families of sulfate transporters have been characterized, the CysZ family remained a "black box" in structural biology. CysZ was known to be a highly specific sulfate permease, but its lack of sequence similarity to other known proteins made it impossible to model its function. This research addresses this gap, explaining how CysZ recognizes sulfate, moves it across the hydrophobic membrane, and regulates the process to prevent the accumulation of toxic metabolic intermediates.

Methodology

The researchers employed a structural genomics approach, screening 63 bacterial homologs of CysZ to identify candidates suitable for high-resolution study. They successfully determined the crystal structures of CysZ from three species: Idiomarina loihiensis (IlCysZ), Pseudomonas fragi (PfCysZ), and Pseudomonas denitrificans (PdCysZ).

Key techniques included:

  • X-ray Crystallography: Structures were solved at resolutions up to 2.1 Å using Single-wavelength Anomalous Diffraction (SAD) with selenate and selenomethionine.
  • Functional Assays: The team measured the uptake of radioactive $^{35}S$-labeled sulfate in both live E. coli cells and purified protein reconstituted into artificial proteoliposomes.
  • Electrophysiology: Planar lipid bilayers were used to measure the electrical conductance of single CysZ channels.
  • Biochemical Mapping: Disulfide crosslinking and cysteine accessibility scans were utilized to confirm the protein's orientation and topology within the membrane.

A Novel Architecture: Dual Topology and Symmetry

The most striking discovery is that CysZ represents a completely novel protein fold. Each individual protomer possesses a "tripod-like" shape, consisting of two long transmembrane helices and two pairs of shorter "hemi-penetrating" helices that only partially span the membrane.

Furthermore, CysZ exhibits a rare "dual topology." Protomers insert into the membrane in two opposite orientations—essentially upside-down relative to one another. In Pseudomonas denitrificans, these protomers assemble into a trimer of antiparallel dimers, forming a near-perfect D3 symmetric hexamer. This arrangement ensures that the "top" and "bottom" of the complex are functionally identical, a unique solution for facilitating ion passage.

Functional Insights: A Specialized Sulfate Channel

While many sulfate transporters utilize ATP or secondary ion gradients (like sodium or protons) to pump molecules against a gradient, CysZ appears to function as a facilitated diffusion channel. It allows sulfate to move down its own concentration gradient with high efficiency. Single-channel measurements for IlCysZ revealed a conductance of approximately 92 pS, supporting its role as a high-capacity conduit.

Specificity and Feedback Inhibition

CysZ is highly specific for sulfate, with an $EC_{50}$ of 0.81 µM. However, the study found that the protein is even more sensitive to sulfite ($SO_3^{2-}$), an intermediate in the sulfur assimilation pathway. Sulfite binds to CysZ with a nearly 10-fold higher affinity ($IC_{50}$ of 0.12 µM) than sulfate, effectively acting as a molecular plug. This likely serves as a critical feedback mechanism: if sulfite levels rise to toxic levels within the cell, CysZ is inhibited, halting further sulfate uptake until the metabolic bottleneck is cleared.

Critical Residues

Mutational analysis highlighted the importance of highly conserved residues identified through the alignment of 150 CysZ family sequences. Specifically, mutating conserved arginine residues (such as R23 in PdCysZ) completely abolished sulfate uptake. These positively charged residues are essential for coordinating the negatively charged sulfate ion as it enters the pore.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a definitive structural blueprint for the CysZ family, revealing a novel fold and an unexpected dual-topology assembly. While the current structures likely represent a "closed" state of the channel, they provide the necessary framework to understand sulfate translocation.

Future studies will be required to capture the protein in its "open" state and to further elucidate the "hydrophobic gating" mechanism—specifically, how the protein's greasy interior residues shift to allow the hydrophilic sulfate ion to pass through the membrane. Additionally, the biogenesis of dual-topology proteins remains a compelling question for the field of membrane protein folding.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Sulfur, most abundantly found in the environment as sulfate (SO 4 2- ), is an essential element in metabolites required by all living cells, including amino acids, co-factors and vitamins. Current understanding of the cellular delivery of SO 4 2- at the molecular level is limited however. CysZ has been described as a SO 4 2- permease, but its sequence family is without known structural precedent. Based on crystallographic structure information, SO 4 2- binding and uptake experiments in cells and proteoliposomes, and single-channel conductance measurements, we provide insight into the molecular mechanism of CysZ-mediated translocation of SO 4 2- across membranes. CysZ properties differ markedly from those of known transporters and ion channels. The structures display a hitherto unknown fold with dual topology, assembling in CysZ from Pseudomonas denitrificans as a trimer of antiparallel dimers in the membrane. CysZ structures from two other species recapitulate dimers from this assembly. Mutational studies highlight the functional relevance of conserved CysZ residues.
BibTeX
@misc{sanghai2017structure,
  author = {Zahra Assur Sanghai and Qun Liu and Oliver B. Clarke and Edgar Leal Pinto and Brian Kloss and Shantelle Tabuso and J. Love and Marco Punta and Surajit Banerjee and Kanagalaghatta R. Rajashankar and Burkhard Rost and Diomedes E. Logothetis and Matthias Quick and Wayne A. Hendrickson and Filippo Mancia},
  title = {{Structure-based analysis of CysZ-mediated cellular uptake of sulfate}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/131318},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure