Structural insights into the π-π-π stacking mechanism and DNA-binding activity of the YEATS domain

Brianna J. Klein, Kendra R. Vann, Forest H. Andrews, Wei Wang, Jibo Zhang, Yi Zhang, Anastasia A. Beloglazkina, Wenyi Mi, Yuanyuan Li, Haitao Li, Xiaobing Shi, Andrei G. Kutateladze, Brian D. Strahl, Wenshe Ray Liu, Tatiana G. KutateladzeNature Communications 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper delves into how YEATS domains, crucial for reading histone modifications, interact with acylated lysines and DNA. Researchers discovered that the yeast Taf14-YEATS domain specifically recognizes crotonyllysine through a unique π-π-π stacking mechanism, while the human AF9-YEATS domain exhibits broader acyllysine recognition and, surprisingly, binds to DNA.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Histone acylation, particularly lysine crotonylation, is a vital epigenetic mark influencing gene expression. However, distinguishing between different acyllysine modifications can be challenging for "reader" proteins. While YEATS domains are known to bind acyllysines, their precise recognition mechanisms and potential for broader interactions, like DNA binding, were not fully understood. This study aims to elucidate the structural basis for YEATS domain selectivity towards specific acyllysine marks and to uncover previously unknown functions, such as DNA binding.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • X-ray Crystallography: To determine the high-resolution structures of YEATS domains (Taf14-YEATS and AF9-YEATS) in complex with various histone peptides. This allowed visualization of the precise interactions.
  • Biochemical Assays:
    • Tryptophan Fluorescence Spectroscopy: To measure binding affinities (K<sub>a</sub>) of YEATS domains to different histone peptides.
  • NMR Titration: To observe changes in protein resonances upon peptide binding, providing insights into interaction interfaces and affinities.
  • Peptide Pulldown Assays: To confirm binding of GST-fused YEATS domains to biotinylated histone peptides.
  • Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assays (EMSA): To assess the binding of AF9-YEATS to DNA and nucleosomes.
  • Site-Directed Mutagenesis: To engineer specific mutations in YEATS domains (e.g., Taf14-YEATS G82A, AF9-YEATS Y78W) to probe the role of specific residues in binding selectivity and function.
  • Quantitative PCR (qPCR): To evaluate the in vivo impact of YEATS domain mutations on gene expression, linking molecular interactions to cellular outcomes.
  • Computational Chemistry (DFT): To analyze the electronic properties of the π-π-π stacking interactions.

Datasets

The study utilized synthetic histone H3 peptides with various acyl modifications (crotonyllysine (H3K9cr), butyryllysine (H3K9bu), acetyllysine (H3K9ac), succinyllysine (H3K9su), and hydroxyisobutyryllysine (H3K9hib)). Additionally, a 147-bp 601 Widom DNA fragment and reconstituted nucleosome core particles (NCPs) were used to study DNA and chromatin interactions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Taf14-YEATS's Crotonyl Specificity: The yeast Taf14-YEATS domain exhibits a remarkable selectivity for crotonyllysine. This is achieved through a sophisticated π-π-π stacking mechanism involving not only the crotonyl amide but also its alkene moiety, facilitated by the dynamic conformation of the W81 residue.
  • AF9-YEATS's Broader Acyl Recognition: In contrast, the human AF9-YEATS domain is less selective, binding comparably to both saturated and unsaturated acyllysines, primarily through stacking with the acyl amide. This is attributed to its conserved YA motif, which limits interactions with the crotonyl alkene.
  • Unveiling DNA Binding by AF9-YEATS: A significant discovery is the previously uncharacterized DNA-binding activity of AF9-YEATS. This interaction is mediated by positively charged residues on the protein surface, distinct from its histone-binding site, suggesting a bivalent mode of chromatin interaction.
  • Engineering Specificity: The researchers successfully engineered a Taf14-YEATS mutant (G82A) that enhances crotonyllysine selectivity by optimizing the π-π-π stacking with the crotonyl alkene.
  • Functional Implications: Mutations in Taf14-YEATS affecting acyllysine binding had differential impacts on gene expression, suggesting distinct roles for crotonylation and acetylation in regulating specific genes.

Key Results

  • Taf14-YEATS showed a ~3-fold reduction in binding affinity when crotonyllysine was replaced with butyryllysine.
  • The crystal structure of Taf14-YEATS revealed that W81 adopts two conformations (r1 and r2) to engage both the crotonyl amide and alkene, while in the H3K9bu complex, only the r1 conformation is utilized for amide stacking.
  • The Taf14-YEATS G82A mutant showed a K<sub>a</sub> of 124 µM for H3K9cr, placing its affinity in the range of established acetyllysine readers.
  • AF9-YEATS bound to H3K9cr, H3K9bu, and H3K9ac peptides with comparable affinities (K<sub>a</sub> ~3.7-4.3 µM).
  • AF9-YEATS demonstrated binding to 15-bp and 20-bp DNA fragments with K<sub>a</sub> values of 47 µM and 57 µM, respectively.
  • EMSA experiments confirmed that AF9-YEATS binds to both DNA and H3K9cr-containing nucleosomes, indicating bivalent interaction.
  • Mutating key positively charged residues in AF9-YEATS (RKK mutant) significantly reduced its DNA and nucleosome binding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Taf14-YEATS DNA Binding: The study explicitly shows that Taf14-YEATS does not bind DNA, a limitation that contrasts with AF9-YEATS.
  • Conservation of Bivalent Binding: While AF9-YEATS exhibits bivalent binding, this is not conserved in Taf14-YEATS. The paper speculates that this bivalent interaction might be conserved in other human YEATS readers like ENL and YEATS2, but lost in yeast YEATS domains. Future work could explore this conservation across different organisms.
  • In Vivo Relevance of AF9-YEATS DNA Binding: The functional consequences of AF9-YEATS's DNA binding in a cellular context are not fully explored. Further studies could investigate how this bivalent interaction impacts chromatin structure and gene regulation in vivo.
  • Broader Acyllysine Recognition: While AF9-YEATS shows less selectivity, understanding the precise molecular basis for this broader recognition could lead to the design of more specific inhibitors or probes.

The findings provide a deeper understanding of how YEATS domains interpret epigenetic signals and open new avenues for exploring their roles in cellular processes and disease.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The YEATS domain has been identified as a reader of histone acylation and more recently emerged as a promising anti-cancer therapeutic target. Here, we detail the structural mechanisms for π-π-π stacking involving the YEATS domains of yeast Taf14 and human AF9 and acylated histone H3 peptides and explore DNA-binding activities of these domains. Taf14-YEATS selects for crotonyllysine, forming π stacking with both the crotonyl amide and the alkene moiety, whereas AF9-YEATS exhibits comparable affinities to saturated and unsaturated acyllysines, engaging them through π stacking with the acyl amide. Importantly, AF9-YEATS is capable of binding to DNA, whereas Taf14-YEATS is not. Using a structure-guided approach, we engineered a mutant of Taf14-YEATS that engages crotonyllysine through the aromatic-aliphatic-aromatic π stacking and shows high selectivity for the crotonyl H3K9 modification. Our findings shed light on the molecular principles underlying recognition of acyllysine marks and reveal a previously unidentified DNA-binding activity of AF9-YEATS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{klein2018structural,
  author = {Brianna J. Klein and Kendra R. Vann and Forest H. Andrews and Wei Wang and Jibo Zhang and Yi Zhang and Anastasia A. Beloglazkina and Wenyi Mi and Yuanyuan Li and Haitao Li and Xiaobing Shi and Andrei G. Kutateladze and Brian D. Strahl and Wenshe Ray Liu and Tatiana G. Kutateladze},
  title = {{Structural insights into the π-π-π stacking mechanism and DNA-binding activity of the YEATS domain}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-07072-6},
}
Figure