Structural, electronic, magnetic properties of Cu-doped lead-apatite Pb$_{10-x}$Cu$_x$(PO$_4$)$_6$O

Jianfeng Zhang, H. Li, Ming Yan, Miao Gao, Fengjie Ma, Xun-Wang Yan, Zhenbo XiearXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The recent report of superconductivity in the Cu-doped PbPO compound stimulates extensive research into its physical properties. This study investigates the detailed atomic and electronic structures necessary to explain these properties. Through first-principles electronic structure calculations, we find that the partial replacement of Pb at the $4f$ site by Cu, rather than at the $6h$ site, is crucial for dominating the electronic state at the Fermi energy. However, the ground state of $Pb_{10-x}Cu_x(PO_4)_6O$ ($x = 1$) is determined to be a semiconducting phase, aligning with experimental measurements.

Introduction: The LK-99 Mystery

In mid-2023, reports of room-temperature superconductivity in a copper-doped lead-apatite compound (LK-99) captured global attention. Early theoretical suggestions posited that substituting copper (Cu) for lead (Pb) at the $4f$ Wyckoff site would create "flat bands" at the Fermi level—a classic signature of potential superconductivity. However, the lead-apatite structure contains two distinct sites for lead: $4f$ and $6h$. This paper addresses the critical question: Where does the copper actually reside? The answer fundamentally changes the material's electronic properties.

Computational Methods

The authors employed Density Functional Theory (DFT) using the VASP package. To accurately model the strongly localized $3d$ electrons of copper, they utilized the GGA+U method with a Hubbard correction of $U = 4.0$ eV. Structural optimization was performed for both possible doping sites ($4f$ and $6h$) to determine the thermodynamically stable ground state.

Key Insights: Site Preference and Electronic States

The study reveals several findings that challenge the initial superconductivity hype:

  • The $6h$ Site is More Stable: Energetic calculations show that substituting Pb at the $6h$ site is more favorable than at the $4f$ site, contradicting the assumptions of early LK-99 papers.
  • Metallic vs. Semiconducting: While $4f$ substitution leads to a metallic state, the more stable $6h$ substitution results in a semiconductor with a calculated band gap of approximately 0.9 eV.
  • Localized Magnetism: The Cu $3d$ orbitals do not form a broad conduction band; instead, they are highly localized and spin-polarized, creating a local magnetic moment of ~1.0 $\mu_B$ per copper atom.

Results and Discussion

Total energy calculations confirm the stability of the $6h$ configuration. As shown in the table below, the $Cu^{6h}$ configuration consistently exhibits lower total energy than the $Cu^{4f}$ configuration in both fixed and optimized lattice scenarios.

Total energy comparison for Cu substitution at 4f and 6h sites.

The electronic density of states (DOS) further illustrates this difference. While the $4f$ site (Figure 5a) shows states crossing the Fermi level ($E_F$), the more stable $6h$ site (Figure 5b) exhibits a clear energy gap, identifying the material as a semiconductor.

Total density of states (TDOS) comparison for (a) 4f and (b) 6h Cu-substitution sites.

Conclusion

This theoretical "reality check" suggests that the ground state of Cu-doped lead-apatite is semiconducting rather than superconducting. While specific synthesis techniques might "trap" copper in the $4f$ site to produce metallic behavior, the thermodynamically preferred $6h$ site results in the dark, non-conductive ceramic observed in many replication attempts. Future work will need to explore the roles of oxygen vacancies and non-equilibrium synthesis in potentially altering these properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent report of superconductivity in the Cu-doped PbPO compound stimulates the extensive researches on its physical properties. Herein, the detailed atomic and electronic structures of this compound are investigated, which are the necessary information to explain the physical properties, including possible superconductivity. By the first-principles electronic structure calculations, we find that the partial replacement of Pb at $4f$ site by Cu atom, instead of Pb at $6h$ site, plays a crucial role in dominating the electronic state at Fermi energy. The $3d$ electronic orbitals of Cu atom emerge near the Fermi energy and exhibit strong spin-polarization, resulting in the local moment around the doped Cu atom. Particularly, the ground state of Pb$_{10-x}$Cu$_x$(PO$_4$)$_6$O (x = 1) is determined to be a semiconducting phase, in good agreement with the experimental measurements.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023structural,
  author = {Jianfeng Zhang and H. Li and Ming Yan and Miao Gao and Fengjie Ma and Xun-Wang Yan and Zhenbo Xie},
  title = {{Structural, electronic, magnetic properties of Cu-doped lead-apatite Pb$\_\{10-x\}$Cu$\_x$(PO$\_4$)$\_6$O}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.04344},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04344},
}
Figure