Structural Design and Optimization of Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cell Ejector

Hangyu Jiang, Zhou Zhao, Peiyong NiSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of improving hydrogen utilization in Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells (PEMFCs) by optimizing the design of hydrogen ejectors. Through detailed CFD simulations and experimental validation, the researchers identified key structural parameters that significantly impact ejector performance, leading to a 9% increase in the ejector ratio.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells (PEMFCs) are a promising clean energy technology, but they require a consistent supply of hydrogen. To ensure efficient operation and prevent performance degradation, excess hydrogen is often supplied, leading to unreacted hydrogen that needs to be recycled. Traditional methods for hydrogen recycling, like compressors, consume power and can cause vibrations. Hydrogen ejectors offer a more efficient, lightweight, and cost-effective solution by using pressure differences to recirculate hydrogen. However, optimizing their performance is crucial for maximizing hydrogen utilization and overall fuel cell efficiency. This paper addresses the need for a systematic approach to optimize the structural design of these ejectors to achieve higher efficiency.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Theoretical Design: They began by using the Sokolov design method to calculate the initial dimensions of the ejector's nozzle and mixing chamber.
  • 3D Fluid Simulation (CFD): A detailed three-dimensional computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model of the ejector was established using ANSYS Workbench. This allowed them to simulate the complex fluid dynamics within the ejector.
  • Turbulence Modeling: The k-ɛ RNG standard wall function was chosen to accurately model the low Reynolds number flow.
  • Grid Independence: A grid of 1.2 million cells was determined to be sufficient for accurate simulations.
  • Boundary Conditions: Pressure boundaries were used for inlets and outlets, with specific values for working fluid and ejector fluid pressures and temperatures.
  • Parametric Study: The CFD model was used to systematically investigate the influence of several key structural parameters on the ejector's performance, measured by the "ejector ratio" (the ratio of ejector fluid mass flow rate to working fluid mass flow rate). These parameters included:
  • Nozzle Exit Position (NXP)
    • Mixing Chamber Diameter ($d_m$)
    • Mixing Chamber Length-to-Diameter Ratio ($l_m/d_m$)
    • Nozzle Contour Curvature ($K$)
  • Optimization: Based on the simulation results, optimal values for these parameters were identified to maximize the ejector ratio.
  • Experimental Validation: A physical ejector was manufactured based on the optimized design. A test bench was then set up using nitrogen gas (as a safer surrogate for hydrogen) to experimentally verify the simulation results. The experimental data was compared with simulation predictions to confirm the model's accuracy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulation data generated from their CFD model and experimental data collected from their test bench.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interdependence of Parameters: The study highlights that optimizing ejector performance isn't about tuning a single parameter in isolation. The optimal values for NXP, mixing chamber diameter, and length-to-diameter ratio are influenced by operating conditions (working fluid pressure) and interact with each other.
  • Nozzle Curvature Matters: The shape of the nozzle's outer contour, specifically its curvature, has a significant impact on the flow angle of the ejector fluid and, consequently, the overall ejection ratio. This is a less commonly optimized parameter in previous studies.
  • Sweet Spot for Each Parameter: For each structural parameter investigated, there's an optimal range or value that maximizes the ejector ratio. Deviating too far from these optima, either too large or too small, leads to decreased performance due to factors like momentum loss, insufficient mixing space, or increased flow resistance.
  • Predictive Power of CFD: The CFD model proved to be highly accurate, with experimental validation showing a maximum error of only 2.44% for the ejector ratio, underscoring its utility for design and optimization.

Key Results

  • Optimized Ejector Ratio: The optimized ejector achieved a maximum ejector ratio of 1.21 at rated operating conditions.
  • Performance Improvement: This optimized ratio represents a 9% improvement compared to the ejector's performance before optimization (ejection ratio of 1.11).
  • Optimal Structural Parameters: The optimal structural parameters identified were:
  • Nozzle Exit Position (NXP): 9 mm
    • Mixing Chamber Diameter ($d_m$): 7 mm
    • Mixing Chamber Length-to-Diameter Ratio ($l_m/d_m$): 9
    • Nozzle Profile Curvature ($K$): 0.02
  • Model Accuracy: The CFD simulation model demonstrated high accuracy, with a maximum error of 4.88% compared to experimental data from literature [28] and a maximum error of 2.75% for flow rate and 2.44% for ejector ratio in their own experimental validation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Working Fluid: The experimental validation used nitrogen instead of hydrogen for safety reasons. While nitrogen is a reasonable surrogate for many fluid dynamic properties, direct testing with hydrogen would provide the most definitive validation.
  • Operating Range: The study focused on optimizing for rated power conditions, though the influence of different working fluid pressures was investigated. Further exploration of the ejector's performance across a wider range of operating conditions, including transient behavior, could be beneficial.
  • Material Properties: While AL6061 was chosen for its formability and strength, the long-term durability and performance of the ejector under actual PEMFC operating conditions (e.g., hydrogen embrittlement) were not explicitly studied.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors suggest that their optimization scheme, particularly the inclusion of nozzle contour shape optimization, can effectively improve ejector ratio and thus hydrogen utilization. Further research could explore more complex nozzle geometries or investigate the integration of these optimized ejectors into complete PEMFC systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs) produce electrical energy using hydrogen as an energy source, characterized by enhanced energy conversion efficiency and diminished emissions, contributing to the sustainable development of energy. The hydrogen ejector is essential for improving the hydrogen utilization efficiency in PEMFCs. In this study, the theoretical design and simulation optimization of a hydrogen ejector used for a hydrogen fuel cell are performed in order to improve the efficiency of the hydrogen ejector. According to Sokolov’s design method, the dimensions of the ejector nozzle and mixing chamber were calculated. A three-dimensional fluid simulation model of the ejector was established, and the accuracy of the model was verified by the experimental results. The influences of the nozzle outlet distance, the mixing chamber diameter, the length–diameter ratio of the mixing chamber, and the nozzle curvature on the ejector ratio were studied under multiple working conditions, and the optimal structural size of the ejector was obtained to satisfy the working conditions. It was found that the maximum ejector ratio of 1.21 could be achieved at a nozzle exit distance of 9 mm, a mixing chamber diameter of 7 mm, a mixing chamber length–diameter ratio of 9, and a nozzle curvature of 0.02. This work can provide some insights into the relationship between the structural parameters and performance of hydrogen ejectors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2024structural,
  author = {Hangyu Jiang and Zhou Zhao and Peiyong Ni},
  title = {{Structural Design and Optimization of Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cell Ejector}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su162210089},
}
Figure