Structural analysis of cross α-helical nanotubes provides insight into the designability of filamentous peptide nanomaterials

Fengbin Wang, O.m. Gnewou, Charles Modlin, Leticia C. Beltrán, Chunfu Xu, Zhangli Su, Puneet Juneja, Gevorg Grigoryan, Edward H. Egelman, Vincent P. ConticelloNature Communications 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach to designing self-assembling peptide nanotubes with a unique "cross-α" architecture. By identifying and leveraging a specific "arginine clasp" interaction, researchers demonstrate precise control over nanotube structure and dimensions, paving the way for predictable design of peptide-based nanomaterials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing synthetic protein-like materials that self-assemble into ordered structures is a major goal in nanotechnology and biomedicine. While native protein filaments offer inspiration, their complex structure-function relationships and the inherent flexibility of helical symmetry make de novo design challenging. Specifically, predicting and controlling how individual peptide subunits (protomers) interact to form higher-order structures (quaternary structure) is a significant hurdle. This paper tackles the problem of designing predictable, self-assembling peptide nanotubes by focusing on controlling the lateral interactions between the building blocks of these filaments, which have an unusual "cross-α" architecture.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Rational Design: Based on previous work with "Form I" and "Form II" peptides, they hypothesized that specific arginine residues could mediate crucial lateral interactions. They designed a series of peptides derived from the Form I sequence, systematically varying peptide length to test the robustness of this hypothesized interaction.
  • Near-Atomic Resolution Cryo-Electron Microscopy (Cryo-EM): This was the core experimental technique. They used direct electron detection cryo-EM to obtain high-resolution 3D reconstructions of the self-assembled peptide nanotubes. This allowed them to visualize the atomic-level details of how the peptides assembled.
  • Computational Modeling and Analysis:
    • Rosetta Modeling: Used initially to generate atomic models from cryo-EM density maps.
  • PISA Analysis: Employed to quantify the buried surface area and crossing angles at the interfaces between interacting helices.
  • Structural Alignment and RMSD Calculations: Used to compare the structures of different designed peptides and assess the conservation of key structural elements.
  • Database Searching (PDB): To investigate the "designability" of the identified arginine clasp motif, they searched the Protein Data Bank (PDB) for similar structural motifs in naturally occurring proteins.
  • Computational Optimization (dTERMen): Used to design new peptide sequences with modified interaction motifs (e.g., replacing the arginine clasp with a leucine zipper) to test the specificity and robustness of the arginine clasp.

Datasets

The primary "dataset" in this study consists of the self-assembled peptide nanotubes generated from designed peptide sequences. The structural information derived from these assemblies was then compared against existing structural data in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) for motif analysis. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Arginine Clasp" Motif: The discovery of a specific interaction motif involving a pair of arginine residues (RxxxR) that robustly mediates cohesive interactions between peptide protofilaments in the cross-α nanotubes. This motif acts like a "clasp," holding the structural units together.
  • Designability of Lateral Interactions: The study demonstrates that these lateral interactions, particularly the arginine clasp, are highly designable and can be precisely controlled to dictate the structure and dimensions of the resulting nanotubes.
  • Peptide Length as a Control Knob: The length of the peptide subunit directly influences the number of protofilaments that assemble into a nanotube, allowing for tunable control over the overall diameter and structure of the nanomaterial.
  • Non-Native Interaction: The arginine clasp motif appears to be a "non-native" interaction, meaning it's not commonly observed in natural protein structures, highlighting the power of rational design to create novel functional interfaces.
  • Structural Plasticity: Even minor sequence changes (like switching arginine to lysine) can lead to significant changes in helical symmetry and assembly, underscoring the delicate balance in self-assembly.

Key Results

  • Seven High-Resolution Cryo-EM Structures: The study successfully determined near-atomic resolution structures of seven designed peptide nanotubes, providing unprecedented detail of their assembly.
  • Tunable Nanotube Dimensions: By varying peptide length, the researchers could control the number of protofilaments in the nanotubes, generating structures with dimensions comparable to biological filaments like flagella and pili. For example, shorter peptides led to fewer protofilaments and narrower nanotubes.
  • Robustness of the Arginine Clasp: Mutagenesis studies confirmed that the presence and specific orientation of the arginine residues were critical for forming the desired cross-α nanotube structure. Replacing the arginine clasp with other motifs (like LxxxL) led to less stable or different assembly pathways.
  • Limited Natural Occurrence of Arginine Clasp: Database searches revealed that the specific geometry of the arginine clasp interaction is rare in natural protein structures, suggesting it's a product of rational design rather than evolutionary selection for this particular interface.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Native Designability: While the arginine clasp is a powerful design element, its rarity in nature suggests it might not be universally applicable or easily discoverable through natural evolutionary processes.
  • Context-Specific Robustness: The paper notes that the arginine clasp's robustness might be limited to specific structural contexts, and its absence can lead to alternative assembly pathways.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that the arginine clasp may represent a broader class of "local interaction motifs" that can mediate quaternary interactions in specific contexts. Future work could focus on identifying and exploiting other such motifs for de novo design of helical assemblies. The study also highlights the importance of high-resolution structural analysis (like cryo-EM) for uncovering these critical local interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The exquisite structure-function correlations observed in filamentous protein assemblies provide a paradigm for the design of synthetic peptide-based nanomaterials. However, the plasticity of quaternary structure in sequence-space and the lability of helical symmetry present significant challenges to the de novo design and structural analysis of such filaments. Here, we describe a rational approach to design self-assembling peptide nanotubes based on controlling lateral interactions between protofilaments having an unusual cross-α supramolecular architecture. Near-atomic resolution cryo-EM structural analysis of seven designed nanotubes provides insight into the designability of interfaces within these synthetic peptide assemblies and identifies a non-native structural interaction based on a pair of arginine residues. This arginine clasp motif can robustly mediate cohesive interactions between protofilaments within the cross-α nanotubes. The structure of the resultant assemblies can be controlled through the sequence and length of the peptide subunits, which generates synthetic peptide filaments of similar dimensions to flagella and pili.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021structural,
  author = {Fengbin Wang and O.M. Gnewou and Charles Modlin and Leticia C. Beltrán and Chunfu Xu and Zhangli Su and Puneet Juneja and Gevorg Grigoryan and Edward H. Egelman and Vincent P. Conticello},
  title = {{Structural analysis of cross α-helical nanotubes provides insight into the designability of filamentous peptide nanomaterials}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-20689-w},
}
Figure