Structural Analysis of an <scp>l</scp> -Cysteine Desulfurase from an Ssp DNA Phosphorothioation System

Liqiong Liu, Susu Jiang, Xing Mai, Chao Chen, Chongde Lai, Na Li, Guangfeng Liu, Dan Wu, Haiyan Gao, Liang Hong, Pan Tan, Shi Chen, Zixin Deng, Geng Wu, Lianrong WangmBio 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper elucidates the structural basis for how SspA, a crucial enzyme in the SspDNA phosphorothioation system, activates sulfur from cysteine. By solving the crystal structure of SspA with its substrate and cofactor, the researchers reveal a dynamic mechanism where the enzyme undergoes conformational changes to bring its catalytic cysteine close enough to the substrate for sulfur transfer, a process vital for DNA modification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

DNA phosphorothioation (PT) is a fascinating epigenetic modification where a sulfur atom replaces a non-bridging oxygen in the DNA backbone. This modification is carried out by complex systems like DndABCDE and SspABCD. A key step in this process is the mobilization of sulfur from L-cysteine, a task performed by cysteine desulfurases, specifically DndA in the Dnd system and SspA in the Ssp system. While both enzymes perform a similar function, SspA cannot be functionally replaced by DndA, suggesting unique properties. The problem addressed here is understanding the molecular mechanism by which SspA specifically recognizes its cysteine substrate and PLP cofactor, and how it overcomes the significant distance between its catalytic cysteine and the substrate to initiate sulfur transfer, which is crucial for the Ssp-mediated DNA PT modification.

Methods

The core of this study involved X-ray crystallography to determine the high-resolution (1.80 Å) crystal structure of Vibrio cyclitrophicus SspA in complex with L-cysteine and its cofactor, pyridoxal phosphate (PLP). This structural data was then complemented by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and normal mode (NM) analysis to investigate the dynamic behavior of SspA, particularly the movement of its catalytic cysteine. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) was employed to validate the MD simulation findings by examining SspA in solution. Additionally, pulldown assays were used to explore potential interactions between SspA and other components of the Ssp system, specifically SspD. Biochemical assays, including LC-MS/MS detection of PT modification, were used to confirm the functional importance of key residues identified through structural analysis.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study was the crystal structure of Vibrio cyclitrophicus SspA in complex with cysteine and PLP, deposited in the Protein Data Bank under accession number 6M4J. This structure served as the basis for MD simulations, NM analysis, and SAXS data fitting. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing methods and analyses were applied to the SspA system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Sulfur Transfer Mechanism: The most striking insight is the revelation of a dynamic mechanism for sulfur transfer. Despite a significant distance (8.9 Å) between the catalytic cysteine (Cys314) and the substrate cysteine, SspA undergoes a conformational change. This movement, driven by the flexibility of the active site region, brings Cys314 into close proximity, enabling the nucleophilic attack required for sulfur mobilization.
  • Conserved Binding Modes: The structural analysis suggests that SspA shares a common binding mode for its cysteine substrate and PLP cofactor with other known cysteine desulfurases like DndA and IscS. This implies a conserved evolutionary strategy for sulfur mobilization across different biological pathways.
  • SspA-SspD Interaction: The pulldown assay revealed a complex formation between SspA and SspD, an ATP pyrophosphatase. This suggests a potential direct transfer of activated sulfur from SspA to SspD, providing a crucial link in the Ssp-mediated DNA PT modification pathway.
  • Intrinsic Flexibility of Cysteine Desulfurases: Both MD simulations and NM analysis across SspA, IscS, and DndA indicate that the movement of the catalytic cysteine towards the substrate is an intrinsic property of cysteine desulfurases, regardless of the secondary structure element housing the catalytic residue.

Key Results

  • The crystal structure of SspA in complex with cysteine and PLP was determined at 1.80 Å resolution.
  • SspA forms a symmetric dimer, with a fold similar to other cysteine desulfurases.
  • Key residues involved in substrate and cofactor recognition were identified, and mutations in these residues (R340E and N150D) significantly impaired PT modification.
  • MD simulations showed that the catalytic cysteine (Cys314) moved 5.5 Å towards the cysteine substrate, reducing the distance to 3.4 Å.
  • SAXS data analysis supported the MD simulation findings, confirming the conformational mobility of SspA in solution.
  • Pulldown experiments demonstrated that SspA forms a complex with SspD.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that while the crystal structure provides a static snapshot, the dynamic nature of the enzyme is crucial for its function. The MD simulations and SAXS data address this by highlighting the conformational changes. However, the precise details of how the activated sulfur is transferred from SspD to the DNA backbone remain to be fully elucidated. Future work could focus on:

  • Determining the structure of the SspA-SspD complex to visualize the sulfur transfer interface.
  • Investigating the role of SspD in accepting and further processing the activated sulfur.
  • Exploring the complete SspABCD-SspE pathway for ssDNA PT modification in greater detail.
  • Further characterizing the unique physiological properties of SspA that prevent functional replacement by DndA.

Summary updated

Abstract

DNA phosphorothioate (PT) modification, in which the nonbridging oxygen in the sugar-phosphate backbone is substituted by sulfur, is catalyzed by DndABCDE or SspABCD in a double-stranded or single-stranded manner, respectively. In Dnd and Ssp systems, mobilization of sulfur in PT formation starts with the activation of the sulfur atom of cysteine catalyzed by the DndA and SspA cysteine desulfurases, respectively. Despite playing the same biochemical role, SspA cannot be functionally replaced by DndA, indicating its unique physiological properties. In this study, we solved the crystal structure of <i>Vibrio cyclitrophicus</i> SspA in complex with its natural substrate, cysteine, and cofactor, pyridoxal phosphate (PLP), at a resolution of 1.80 Å. Our solved structure revealed the molecular mechanism that SspA employs to recognize its cysteine substrate and PLP cofactor, suggesting a common binding mode shared by cysteine desulfurases. In addition, although the distance between the catalytic Cys314 and the substrate cysteine is 8.9 Å, which is too far for direct interaction, our structural modeling and biochemical analysis revealed a conformational change in the active site region toward the cysteine substrate to move them close to each other to facilitate the nucleophilic attack. Finally, the pulldown analysis showed that SspA could form a complex with SspD, an ATP pyrophosphatase, suggesting that SspD might potentially accept the activated sulfur atom directly from SspA, providing further insights into the biochemical pathway of Ssp-mediated PT modification.<b>IMPORTANCE</b> Apart from its roles in Fe-S cluster assembly, tRNA thiolation, and sulfur-containing cofactor biosynthesis, cysteine desulfurase serves as a sulfur donor in the DNA PT modification, in which a sulfur atom substitutes a nonbridging oxygen in the DNA phosphodiester backbone. The initial sulfur mobilization from l-cysteine is catalyzed by the SspA cysteine desulfurase in the SspABCD-mediated DNA PT modification system. By determining the crystal structure of SspA, the study presents the molecular mechanism that SspA employs to recognize its cysteine substrate and PLP cofactor. To overcome the long distance (8.9 Å) between the catalytic Cys314 and the cysteine substrate, a conformational change occurs to bring Cys314 to the vicinity of the substrate, allowing for nucleophilic attack.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020structural,
  author = {Liqiong Liu and Susu Jiang and Xing Mai and Chao Chen and Chongde Lai and Na Li and Guangfeng Liu and Dan Wu and Haiyan Gao and Liang Hong and Pan Tan and Shi Chen and Zixin Deng and Geng Wu and Lianrong Wang},
  title = {{Structural Analysis of an <scp>l</scp> -Cysteine Desulfurase from an Ssp DNA Phosphorothioation System}},
  booktitle = {mBio},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1128/mbio.00488-20},
}
Figure