StruAP: A Tool for Bundling Linguistic Trees through Structure-based Abstract Pattern

Kohsuke Yanai, Misa Sato, Toshihiko Yanase, Kenzo Kurotsuchi, Yuta Koreeda, Yoshiki NiwaEMNLP 2017

TL;DR

This paper introduces StruAP, a novel tool designed to simplify the creation of linguistic tree structure patterns for relation extraction. By abstracting syntax trees into intuitive patterns and providing a comprehensive workflow, StruAP aims to empower users, even non-researchers, to define custom relations and build extraction modules efficiently.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing robust relation extraction systems often requires defining specific linguistic patterns that capture semantic relationships between entities in text. Traditional approaches, while effective, can be complex and time-consuming, especially when dealing with custom, domain-specific relations. Implementing these patterns often involves intricate logic for traversing linguistic trees (like constituency or dependency trees), making it difficult to develop and maintain extraction modules. Existing tools often rely on general relation taxonomies and require significant training data for each new relation, hindering flexibility and speed. This paper addresses the need for a more accessible and efficient method for defining and utilizing custom linguistic patterns for relation extraction, particularly for use cases that demand bespoke relation definitions.

Methods

StruAP's core innovation lies in its "structure-based abstract pattern" approach. Instead of relying on path-based patterns or complex query languages, users define patterns by abstracting directly from syntax trees generated by parsers (like Stanford's CoreNLP). The tool offers an intuitive pattern syntax that represents generalized tree structures, allowing users to focus on essential elements of a relation. Key features include:

  • Intuitive Pattern Syntax: An abstracted representation of syntax parser outputs, making patterns easier to understand and create.
  • Recursive Pattern Calls: Enables the definition of complex patterns by referencing other patterns, promoting modularity and reusability.
  • Lexicon Reference: Allows users to define word lists (e.g., for verbs indicating "increase" or "cause") in separate files, simplifying patterns and handling variations.
  • Whole Workflow Support: StruAP guides users through the entire process, from sample text selection and pattern definition to validation and index creation.

The tool's architecture involves parsing texts, storing linguistic trees, and building a text search index for efficient retrieval of extracted relations.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention specific datasets used for training or evaluation in the traditional sense. Instead, it focuses on the tool's ability to work with arbitrary text data. The authors demonstrate the tool's functionality using a sample sentence about a "spin-off" relation involving Hitachi. They also mention developing 657 patterns and using 6406 words in lexicons across several use cases, including an end-to-end argument generation system in debating.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Abstraction is Key: The ability to abstract syntax trees into generalized patterns significantly simplifies the process of defining relations, moving beyond rigid path-based queries.
  • Empowering Non-Experts: StruAP's intuitive design and workflow support make relation extraction pattern development accessible to users without deep linguistic or programming expertise, such as translators and software engineers.
  • Efficiency Gains: The tool aims to reduce the development time for custom relation extraction modules from days or weeks to hours.
  • Flexibility for Custom Relations: The focus on defining case-specific relations rather than relying on universal taxonomies is crucial for many real-world applications.
  • Integrated Workflow: Providing a seamless experience from text input to index generation is vital for practical adoption.

Key Results

The paper reports on the effectiveness of StruAP through an efficiency investigation. Two non-researcher users (a translator and a software engineer) developed patterns and lexicon words within an hour. Developer A created 8 patterns and 3 words for "spin-off," and 7 patterns and 5 words for "sue." Developer B created 12 patterns and 2 words for "spin-off," and 10 patterns and 4 words for "sue." Overall, the tool has been used to develop 657 patterns and 6406 words in lexicons. The authors conclude that the tool is effective for defining case-specific relations, especially when non-researchers are involved.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the "bracketed syntax" for defining patterns might be arguable, though they believe it's faster than graphical tree editors. A limitation identified is the lack of sufficient words in lexicons for actual applications, and the tool doesn't actively help increase the variety of predicate or clue words.

Future work directions include:

  • Developing semi-automatic abstraction techniques using frequent subtree mining.
  • Integrating methods to collect clue words for lexicon reference.
  • Supporting collaboration among users to avoid pattern duplication.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{yanai2017struap,
  author = {Kohsuke Yanai and Misa Sato and Toshihiko Yanase and Kenzo Kurotsuchi and Yuta Koreeda and Yoshiki Niwa},
  title = {{StruAP: A Tool for Bundling Linguistic Trees through Structure-based Abstract Pattern}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure