Strong strain dependence of friction in graphene kirigami allows engineering a negative coefficient of friction

Mikkel Metzsch Juel, Anders Malthe‐Sørenssen, Henrik Andersen SveinssonProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have engineered a novel graphene-based metamaterial that exhibits a negative coefficient of friction, meaning friction decreases as the applied load increases. This is achieved by combining kirigami-inspired cuts in graphene with a mechanical coupling that links normal load to sheet tension, leading to tunable friction properties previously unattainable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Friction, a ubiquitous force, typically behaves predictably: increasing the normal load (the force pressing surfaces together) increases the frictional force. This is quantified by the coefficient of friction, which is almost universally positive. While "negative friction" has been observed in niche scenarios, it's usually with very small magnitudes (less than 10⁻²) and under highly restrictive conditions, limiting practical applications. The challenge is to find mechanisms that can reliably produce larger negative friction coefficients and offer tunability, moving beyond these limitations.

Methods

The study employs molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the friction between a graphene sheet and a silicon substrate. The core innovation lies in two aspects:

  1. Kirigami Patterning: Graphene sheets are modified with kirigami-inspired cuts, creating specific out-of-plane buckling patterns (Tetrahedron and Honeycomb designs).
  2. Coupled Load-Tension System: A conceptual "nanomachine" is proposed where the applied normal load is mechanically coupled to induce tension in the graphene sheet. This coupling is modeled as a linear relationship (F_tension = T * F_normal), with a load-to-tension ratio (T) of 1.

The simulations explore how varying in-plane strain and normal load affects the friction force. They also analyze the concept of commensurability – the degree of alignment between the graphene lattice and the substrate lattice – as a key factor influencing friction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated through molecular dynamics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strain is King (for Friction): Unlike traditional friction models where normal load is dominant, this kirigami-graphene system shows a stronger dependence of friction on in-plane strain than on normal load. This is a crucial departure from conventional understanding.
  • Kirigami Unlocks Non-Monotonic Friction: The kirigami cuts, combined with strain, lead to a complex "increase-decrease-increase" relationship between friction and strain. This non-monotonic behavior is the foundation for achieving negative friction.
  • Commensurability as the Driver: The paper strongly suggests that the non-monotonic friction-strain behavior arises from changes in the commensurability between the graphene sheet and the silicon substrate. As the sheet deforms and buckles out-of-plane due to strain, the lattice alignment shifts, altering the friction.
  • Nanomachine for Tunable Friction: By coupling normal loading with sheet tension, the strain-dependent friction can be translated into a load-dependent friction. This allows for the engineering of specific friction behaviors, including negative coefficients.

Key Results

  • Negative Friction Coefficient Achieved: The study successfully demonstrates a negative friction coefficient of -0.08 for the Honeycomb-patterned graphene sheet under specific loading conditions. A value of -0.03 was also observed for the Tetrahedron pattern.
  • Strain Dominance: For kirigami sheets, a three-orders-of-magnitude increase in normal load resulted in only a negligible change in friction, while strain induced significant variations.
  • Hysteresis Observed: The coupled system exhibited some hysteresis in the friction-load curves during unloading, particularly for the Honeycomb pattern, attributed to a structural transition.
  • Scalability Potential: The proposed mechanism is argued to be scalable and offers a wide design space for creating tunable frictional surfaces, moving beyond the limitations of previous negative friction observations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conceptual Nanomachine: The paper proposes a nanomachine design but does not model its specific physical implementation. The coupling is assumed to be linear (F_tension = T * F_normal).
  • Simulation-Based: The results are derived from molecular dynamics simulations. Experimental validation would be the next critical step.
  • Material Specificity: While the principles are expected to apply to other 2D materials and substrates, the specific values and behaviors are tied to the graphene-silicon system.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring similar mechanisms in other 2D materials and even 3D porous materials. They also highlight the potential for designing new classes of metamaterials with complex and tunable friction properties. The influence of the load-to-tension ratio (T) on the negative friction coefficient is also an area for further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The friction force typically increases linearly with normal load with a constant of proportionality called the coefficient of friction. Most materials exhibit a positive friction coefficient, so that an increase in the normal load leads to an increase in the friction force. Recently, materials with negative friction coefficients have been observed at meticulously constructed interfaces due to an interplay between superstructures at heterojunctions, out-of-plane buckling, or the ordering of thin water films. However, the magnitude of the negative friction coefficient is typically much less than [Formula: see text], the geometries are highly restrictive, and the mechanisms are difficult to scale to larger systems. Here, we show that a friction coefficient of [Formula: see text]0.08 can be obtained for a graphene sheet modified with kirigami-inspired cuts when inducing sheet tension through a normal load coupling. We use molecular dynamics simulations to show that the frictional behavior of kirigami cut sheets exhibits a strong nonmonotonic dependence on in-plane strain, while only weakly influenced by normal loading. We argue that the strong influence of strain arises from changes in commensurability between the graphene sheet and the substrate when the sheet deforms and buckles out of plane. We propose a simple nanomachine design that couples normal loading and sheet tension which enables the realization of different frictional laws, including a negative coefficient of friction. This represents a unique approach to creating tunable frictional surfaces and opens up applications in sheet-like systems across scales.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{juel2025strong,
  author = {Mikkel Metzsch Juel and Anders Malthe‐Sørenssen and Henrik Andersen Sveinsson},
  title = {{Strong strain dependence of friction in graphene kirigami allows engineering a negative coefficient of friction}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2501728122},
}

Loading related content...

Figure