Strong Genetic Influence on a UK Nationwide Test of Educational Achievement at the End of Compulsory Education at Age 16

Nicholas G. Shakeshaft, Maciej Trzaskowski, Andrew McMillan, Kaili Rimfeld, Eva Krapohl, Claire M. A. Haworth, Philip S. Dale, Robert PlominPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract

We have previously shown that individual differences in educational achievement are highly heritable in the early and middle school years in the UK. The objective of the present study was to investigate whether similarly high heritability is found at the end of compulsory education (age 16) for the UK-wide examination, called the General Certificate of Secondary Education (GCSE). In a national twin sample of 11,117 16-year-olds, heritability was substantial for overall GCSE performance for compulsory core subjects (58%) as well as for each of them individually: English (52%), mathematics (55%) and science (58%). In contrast, the overall effects of shared environment, which includes all family and school influences shared by members of twin pairs growing up in the same family and attending the same school, accounts for about 36% of the variance of mean GCSE scores. The significance of these findings is that individual differences in educational achievement at the end of compulsory education are not primarily an index of the quality of teachers or schools: much more of the variance of GCSE scores can be attributed to genetics than to school or family environment. We suggest a model of education that recognizes the important role of genetics. Rather than a passive model of schooling as instruction (instruere, 'to build in'), we propose an active model of education (educare, 'to bring out') in which children create their own educational experiences in part on the basis of their genetic propensities, which supports the trend towards personalized learning.

Introduction

The "nature vs. nurture" debate in education often assumes that if we just provide better schools and teachers, we can close the achievement gap. While previous research showed high heritability in early childhood education, it wasn't clear if this persisted through the end of compulsory schooling. This study addresses the extent to which performance on the General Certificate of Secondary Education (GCSE)—the high-stakes standardized exams taken by nearly all UK 16-year-olds—is influenced by genetics versus the "shared environment" (factors like attending the same school or living in the same home). If achievement is primarily a reflection of school quality, we would expect the shared environment to play a dominant role. If genetics lead the way, it suggests students "select and create" their own educational experiences based on their innate predispositions.

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the Twins Early Development Study (TEDS), a longitudinal study of twins born in England and Wales between 1994 and 1996. The final sample included 11,117 individuals, representing a broad cross-section of the UK population. GCSE results were primarily parent-reported and validated against the UK National Pupil Database with high correlations (0.95–0.98).

The study employed the classic twin method, comparing monozygotic (MZ) twins, who share 100% of their segregating alleles, with dizygotic (DZ) twins, who share roughly 50%. Using ACE modeling, phenotypic variance was partitioned into three components: Additive Genetic (A), Shared Environment (C), and Non-shared Environment (E).

The ACE model for twin studies

Key Results

Heritability was substantial across all core subjects. For the mean GCSE grade, genetics accounted for 58% of the variance, while shared family and school influences accounted for approximately 36%. Notably, science subjects showed the highest heritability (58%), while humanities were lower (42%). While some quantitative differences emerged between genders, no qualitative sex differences were found, suggesting the same genes influence achievement in both boys and girls.

Variance components for GCSE performance

Discussion

The Paradox of Equity

A counterintuitive insight from this data is that high heritability can be an index of educational equality. If every child receives the exact same high-quality instruction (the environment is equalized), then the remaining differences in scores must be driven by genetic factors.

"Educare" vs. "Instruere"

The authors contrast two models of education: Instruere (to build in), which views the student as a passive recipient, and Educare (to bring out), which views the student as an active participant. High heritability suggests that students' genetic propensities drive them to seek out different books, ask different questions, and engage with subjects uniquely. This supports a shift toward personalized learning that recognizes the active role students play in creating their own educational environments.

Achievement vs. Intelligence

Educational achievement (GCSEs) appears to be more heritable than general intelligence (IQ) at this age. This suggests that academic success taps into more than just raw cognitive ability; it also involves genetically influenced traits like personality, motivation, and persistence.

Limitations and Future Work

While the twin method is robust, it relies on the "equal environments" assumption. Furthermore, while this study shows that genes matter, it does not identify which specific genes are involved; molecular genetics remains the next frontier. Future work will also focus on multivariate analysis to determine if the same genes influence all subjects (the "generalist genes" hypothesis) and will incorporate specific school-quality data to further refine environmental estimates.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have previously shown that individual differences in educational achievement are highly heritable in the early and middle school years in the UK. The objective of the present study was to investigate whether similarly high heritability is found at the end of compulsory education (age 16) for the UK-wide examination, called the General Certificate of Secondary Education (GCSE). In a national twin sample of 11,117 16-year-olds, heritability was substantial for overall GCSE performance for compulsory core subjects (58%) as well as for each of them individually: English (52%), mathematics (55%) and science (58%). In contrast, the overall effects of shared environment, which includes all family and school influences shared by members of twin pairs growing up in the same family and attending the same school, accounts for about 36% of the variance of mean GCSE scores. The significance of these findings is that individual differences in educational achievement at the end of compulsory education are not primarily an index of the quality of teachers or schools: much more of the variance of GCSE scores can be attributed to genetics than to school or family environment. We suggest a model of education that recognizes the important role of genetics. Rather than a passive model of schooling as instruction (instruere, 'to build in'), we propose an active model of education (educare, 'to bring out') in which children create their own educational experiences in part on the basis of their genetic propensities, which supports the trend towards personalized learning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shakeshaft2013strong,
  author = {Nicholas G. Shakeshaft and Maciej Trzaskowski and Andrew McMillan and Kaili Rimfeld and Eva Krapohl and Claire M. A. Haworth and Philip S. Dale and Robert Plomin},
  title = {{Strong Genetic Influence on a UK Nationwide Test of Educational Achievement at the End of Compulsory Education at Age 16}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0080341},
}
Figure