Strong direct and indirect influences of climate change on water yield confirmed by the Budyko framework

Hui Yang, Hao Xu, Chris Huntingford, Philippe Ciais, Shilong PiaoGeography 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that climate change, not vegetation changes as previously thought, is the primary driver of global runoff changes. By using the Budyko framework and advanced vegetation models, the study shows that shifts in rainfall patterns and intensity, along with indirect effects on vegetation, significantly alter water yield, especially in arid and sparsely vegetated regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how global water resources are changing is crucial for managing water scarcity and predicting future availability. While the Budyko framework offers a simplified yet powerful way to model how precipitation is partitioned into runoff and evapotranspiration, there's been ongoing debate about what factors are most influential in altering this balance. Specifically, previous research suggested that changes in vegetation cover were the main drivers of shifts in water yield (represented by the 'n-parameter' in the Budyko framework). This paper aims to resolve this controversy by investigating the relative contributions of climate change, rising atmospheric CO2, and land-use change to observed changes in the Budyko framework's 'n-parameter' and, consequently, to global runoff.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Hydrological Measurements and Budyko Framework: They used observed river discharge data from 41 large basins worldwide and precipitation/potential evapotranspiration data. Using the Budyko framework, they derived the 'n-parameter' (representing terrestrial water retention) for different periods and calculated the changes in this parameter (Δn) between 1980-1992 and 1993-2005. They also used a first-order Taylor expansion of the Budyko equation to quantify how changes in the aridity index (AI) and the n-parameter affect water yield.
  2. Dynamic Global Vegetation Models (DGVMs): To disentangle the drivers of Δn, they utilized outputs from 13 DGVMs. These models were run with factorial simulations to isolate the effects of:
  3. Elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration.
  4. Climate change (temperature, precipitation, radiation, etc.).
  5. Land-use change. By comparing these simulations, they could attribute the observed changes in Δn to each of these factors.

Datasets

  • River Discharge Data: Measurements from 41 large basins globally, with over 80% data availability for the 1980-2005 period. Sourced from the river discharge archive by Dai et al. (2009) and the China Statistical Yearbook.
  • Climate Data: Observation-based gridded data for precipitation (P) and potential evapotranspiration (PET) for 1980-2005 from the Climate Research Unit (CRU v3.25).
  • DGVM Outputs: Simulations from 13 DGVMs (part of the TRENDY v6 project ensemble) for the period 1980-2005. These included control simulations and factorial simulations isolating CO2, climate, and land-use change impacts.
  • Land Cover Change Data: LUH2v2h reconstruction for annual fractional data on primary and secondary vegetation and transitions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Climate Change Reigns Supreme: Contrary to some previous studies, this research strongly indicates that climate change, particularly alterations in rainfall intensity and seasonality, is the dominant factor driving changes in water yield.
  • Indirect Pathways Matter: Climate change doesn't just act directly; it also influences vegetation properties (like leaf area and stomatal conductance), which in turn affect water yield. This highlights the complex, interconnected nature of the terrestrial water cycle.
  • Arid Regions are More Sensitive: The study reveals that water yield is more sensitive to changes in the n-parameter in arid and sparsely vegetated regions. This means that even small shifts in retention can have a significant impact on water availability in these already water-stressed areas.
  • Budyko Framework's Enduring Relevance: The paper reaffirms the Budyko framework's utility as a parameter-sparse yet effective tool for understanding and projecting runoff changes, especially when combined with advanced modeling techniques.

Key Results

  • Climate Change Dominates Δn: For 26 out of 41 large catchments, climate change was identified as the primary driver of changes in the n-parameter.
  • CO2 is a Secondary Driver: Elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration was the second most important factor, influencing n-parameter changes in 13 out of 41 catchments.
  • Land Use Has Minor Influence: Land-use change generally had a smaller impact on the n-parameter compared to climate and CO2, though it was pronounced in specific tropical regions.
  • Model-Observation Agreement: The DGVMs' estimates of n-parameter changes showed good agreement with observed data, validating their use for attribution studies.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Water yield is more sensitive to decreases in the n-parameter than increases. The sensitivity of water yield to n-parameter changes increases with aridity index up to a point (AI ~ 1.5) and is also higher in regions with lower initial n-parameter values (indicating lower water retention).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Uncertainties: While DGVMs showed good agreement, the paper acknowledges that individual model simulations can vary, and the effects of elevated CO2 on vegetation can be complex and sometimes opposite across models.
  • Data Limitations: The study relies on available data, and some regions have insufficient data for comprehensive analysis (indicated by grey areas in maps).
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for ongoing investigation into climate forcing to generate more refined and reliable projections of future water availability. They also suggest that understanding the interplay between climate, land surface characteristics, and water yield is crucial for sustainable development under climate change.

Summary updated

Abstract

Research findings concerning the main processes influencing water resources differ substantially, and so the topic remains controversial. Recent studies indicate that the changes in water yield, expressed through the n-parameter of Budyko framework, are associated with vegetation coverage changes. Here, we use runoff measurements and outputs from 13 dynamic global vegetation models, to investigate the underlying drivers of the n-parameter changes. Unlike previous studies, we instead find that climate change is the primary driver of adjustments on water resources. Changing climatic characteristics, particularly the intensity and seasonality of rainfall, modulates the runoff generation process. Indirect effects of climate change occur through altering vegetation properties, which in turn also impact river flow. We also find that in the arid and sparse vegetation regions, water yield is more sensitive to changes in n-parameter. Thus, the Budyko framework provides a reliable parameter-sparse representation of runoff changes, and reveals that terrestrial water cycle is changing substantially under climate change. This climate forcing requires on-going investigation to generate more refined and reliable projections of future water availability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2021strong,
  author = {Hui Yang and Hao Xu and Chris Huntingford and Philippe Ciais and Shilong Piao},
  title = {{Strong direct and indirect influences of climate change on water yield confirmed by the Budyko framework}},
  booktitle = {Geography},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.geosus.2021.11.001},
}
Figure