Stroke Lesion Segmentation in FLAIR MRI Datasets Using Customized Markov Random Fields

Nagesh K. Subbanna, Deepthi Rajashekar, Bastian Cheng, Götz Thomalla, Jens Fiehler, Tal Arbel, Nils D. ForkertFrontiers in Neurology 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel two-step method for segmenting sub-acute ischemic stroke lesions from FLAIR MRI scans, utilizing Gabor texture features and a customized Markov Random Field (MRF). The approach achieves competitive accuracy using only FLAIR data, outperforming recent deep learning and level-set methods in head-to-head comparisons.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately measuring the volume of stroke lesions is increasingly important for clinical trials, serving as a more sensitive endpoint than traditional clinical scores. However, automatically segmenting these lesions from medical images, particularly FLAIR MRI sequences commonly used in follow-up scans, is challenging. Existing methods often struggle with variations in lesion shape, size, and location, as well as image artifacts common in multi-center datasets. A key difficulty is distinguishing actual stroke lesions from other white matter abnormalities, which can lead to over-segmentation. This paper aims to develop a robust and reliable method for stroke lesion segmentation using only FLAIR MRI, addressing the need for a standardized approach that can be applied across different imaging centers and scanners.

Methods

The proposed method employs a two-stage approach:

  1. Initial Bayesian Classification with Gabor Textures:
    • FLAIR images are processed using multi-window 2D Gabor transforms to extract texture features at each voxel. Gabor filters are chosen for their ability to capture local image characteristics at different orientations and scales.
  2. A Bayesian classifier then estimates the probability of each voxel belonging to either the "lesion" or "non-lesion" class based on these Gabor texture features.
  3. The Gabor filter parameters are optimized to maximize the separation between lesion and non-lesion classes, using a graph cut approach.
  4. Customized Markov Random Field (MRF) Refinement:
    • The initial classification is refined using a customized MRF model. This MRF goes beyond standard intensity-based models by incorporating:
  5. Intensity: The signal intensity of each voxel.
  6. Texture: The Gabor texture features extracted in the first step.
  7. Intensity Differences: The differences in intensity between a voxel and its neighbors, helping to preserve lesion boundaries.
  8. The MRF formulation considers various clique sizes (2, 3, and 4 voxels) to capture local spatial relationships.
  9. Gaussian distributions are used to model the likelihoods of tissue classes, intensity differences, and texture features. The model is trained using data from the ISLES challenge and other databases.
  10. The final segmentation is obtained by minimizing the MRF energy function using an iterated conditional modes (ICM) approach.

Datasets

The study utilized three multi-center FLAIR MRI datasets for development and evaluation:

  • SFB Database: 23 FLAIR MRI datasets from the University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Germany. Acquired on a 3T Siemens Skyra scanner.
  • I-KNOW Database: 108 FLAIR datasets from a prospective European multi-center stroke imaging study, acquired across five centers with varying 1.5T scanners and parameters.
  • ISLES Database: 28 FLAIR MRI datasets publicly available from the Ischemic Stroke Lesion Segmentation (ISLES) challenge. These were acquired on 3T MRI scanners but were registered and resampled to T1-weighted images, potentially introducing interpolation artifacts.

In total, 151 FLAIR datasets were used. A leave-one-patient-out cross-validation strategy was employed. Gabor parameters were optimized using datasets from one database to ensure unbiased evaluation on another.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Texture as a Key Differentiator: The paper highlights the crucial role of Gabor texture features in distinguishing stroke lesions from other white matter abnormalities, which is a significant challenge when using FLAIR MRI alone.
  • Customized MRF for Boundary Preservation: The MRF model's ability to incorporate intensity differences alongside intensity and texture is key to refining segmentation and preserving accurate lesion boundaries.
  • FLAIR-Only Robustness: Demonstrating competitive performance using only FLAIR MRI is significant, as FLAIR is a standard sequence in follow-up stroke imaging, making the method broadly applicable even when multi-modal data is unavailable.
  • Generalizability Challenges: The study acknowledges that while the method shows promise, variations in acquisition parameters across multi-center datasets can impact performance, necessitating careful preprocessing and potentially further optimization for specific scanner types.

Key Results

  • Overall Accuracy: The proposed method achieved an average Dice coefficient of 0.582 across all 151 datasets. This is competitive with state-of-the-art methods that often utilize multi-modal imaging.
  • Comparison to State-of-the-Art: The method outperformed two leading methods from the ISLES 2015 challenge: a convolutional neural network (CNN) approach (Dice 0.541) and a fuzzy C-means clustering with level-set method (Dice 0.524).
  • Small Lesion Segmentation: The method successfully segmented 258 out of 483 small lesion components (< 1 ml) as true positives, with 81 false positives, showing good performance in detecting these challenging cases.
  • Volumetric Analysis: While generally showing strong correlation (r=0.81) between manual and automatic lesion volumes, the method tended to underestimate larger lesions, particularly at the borders. This led to a lower Dice score for the ISLES dataset, which had pre-processed, resampled images.
  • Computational Cost: Lesion segmentation took 20-30 minutes per dataset on standard datasets and 70-90 minutes on the interpolated ISLES datasets. Training the Gabor parameters was the most computationally intensive step, requiring several hours, but this is a one-time cost.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Volumetric Underestimation: The paper acknowledges that the method tends to underestimate lesion volumes, especially for larger lesions, which limits its immediate use for lesion volume as a clinical endpoint.
  • Generalizability: While tested across multiple datasets, the method's performance varied, particularly for the ISLES dataset due to pre-processing artifacts. A more independent validation set would be beneficial.
  • Parameter Optimization: The comparison methods (CNN and level-set) were not fully re-optimized, suggesting their performance could potentially be improved.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring non-uniform weighting of contrasts and textures based on voxel location to better handle lesion boundaries. They also note that integrating multi-modal MRI data is a potential avenue for further improvement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Robust and reliable stroke lesion segmentation is a crucial step toward employing lesion volume as an independent endpoint for randomized trials. The aim of this work was to develop and evaluate a novel method to segment sub-acute ischemic stroke lesions from fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) datasets. After preprocessing of the datasets, a Bayesian technique based on Gabor textures extracted from the FLAIR signal intensities is utilized to generate a first estimate of the lesion segmentation. Using this initial segmentation, a customized voxel-level Markov random field model based on intensity as well as Gabor texture features is employed to refine the stroke lesion segmentation. The proposed method was developed and evaluated based on 151 multi-center datasets from three different databases using a leave-one-patient-out validation approach. The comparison of the automatically segmented stroke lesions with manual ground truth segmentation revealed an average Dice coefficient of 0.582, which is in the upper range of previously presented lesion segmentation methods using multi-modal MRI datasets. Furthermore, the results obtained by the proposed technique are superior compared to the results obtained by two methods based on convolutional neural networks and three phase level-sets, respectively, which performed best in the ISLES 2015 challenge using multi-modal imaging datasets. The results of the quantitative evaluation suggest that the proposed method leads to robust lesion segmentation results using FLAIR MRI datasets only as a follow-up sequence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{subbanna2019stroke,
  author = {Nagesh K. Subbanna and Deepthi Rajashekar and Bastian Cheng and Götz Thomalla and Jens Fiehler and Tal Arbel and Nils D. Forkert},
  title = {{Stroke Lesion Segmentation in FLAIR MRI Datasets Using Customized Markov Random Fields}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2019.00541},
}
Figure