Streaming PTAS for Binary 𝓁 0 -Low Rank Approximation.

Anup Bhattacharya, Dishant Goyal, Ragesh Jaiswal, Amit Kumar2019

TL;DR

This paper introduces the first streaming algorithms for binary $l_0$-low rank approximation and constrained binary k-means, achieving constant passes and polylogarithmic space. This is a significant step towards efficient data analysis in streaming settings for these fundamental problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Low-rank approximation is a crucial technique in data analysis, aiming to find a lower-rank matrix that closely approximates a given matrix. The $l_0$-low rank approximation problem, specifically, seeks to minimize the number of differing entries between the original and approximated matrices. This problem, along with the constrained binary k-means problem, has practical applications but is computationally challenging (NP-hard). While approximation algorithms exist, achieving efficient streaming algorithms (processing data in a single pass with limited memory) has been a major open challenge. This paper tackles this by developing streaming algorithms for these problems, building upon recent theoretical advancements.

Methods

The core of this work lies in leveraging a connection between the constrained binary k-means problem and the binary $l_0$-low rank approximation problem. The authors first design a streaming PTAS (Polynomial Time Approximation Scheme) for the constrained binary k-means problem. This involves:

  • Streaming Constant Factor Approximation for Binary k-means: They utilize a known result for a one-pass streaming algorithm that provides a constant-factor approximation for the unconstrained binary k-means problem.
  • Obtaining Good Centers from Uniform Samples: A key challenge is obtaining good cluster centers even with uniform samples. The paper builds on prior work showing that with estimated cluster sizes and uniform samples, good centers can be found.
  • D²-sampling: To handle situations where uniform sampling might not be sufficient (e.g., clusters of vastly different sizes), the authors employ the D²-sampling technique. This method samples points with probability proportional to their squared distance from existing centers, effectively boosting the sampling probability of points in under-represented clusters.
  • Reduction to $l_0$-Low Rank Approximation: The streaming PTAS for constrained binary k-means is then used to derive a streaming PTAS for the binary $l_0$-low rank approximation problem via a known reduction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithm design and analysis for general matrix and point set inputs rather than specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap to Streaming: The paper successfully translates complex theoretical results on low-rank approximation and k-means into practical streaming algorithms, a significant advancement for handling large datasets.
  • The Power of D²-sampling in Streaming: The adaptation of D²-sampling for streaming settings proves crucial for overcoming challenges in obtaining representative samples from diverse clusters, a common issue in streaming algorithms.
  • Leveraging Existing Connections: The authors effectively utilize the established connection between constrained binary k-means and $l_0$-low rank approximation to solve both problems within a streaming framework.
  • Constant Passes are Achievable: Demonstrating that these problems can be solved with a small, constant number of passes (3 or 4) is a major practical advantage for streaming algorithms.

Key Results

  • 3-Pass Streaming PTAS for Constrained Binary k-means: The algorithm achieves a $(1+\epsilon)$-approximation for the constrained binary k-means problem using 3 passes and polylogarithmic space.
  • 4-Pass Streaming PTAS for Binary $l_0$-Low Rank Approximation: By reducing the problem to constrained binary k-means, they obtain a $(1+\epsilon)$-approximation for the binary $l_0$-low rank approximation problem in 4 passes and polylogarithmic space.
  • First Constant-Pass Streaming Algorithms: These are the first constant-pass, polylogarithmic-space streaming algorithms for either of these problems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Number of Passes: While constant passes are achieved, the paper poses the question of whether a single-pass algorithm is possible.
  • Space Complexity: The current algorithms require polylogarithmic space, primarily due to the need to guess cluster sizes. The authors question if a logspace algorithm is achievable.
  • Generalization to Other Fields: The paper focuses on binary matrices and specific inner products. Extending these results to more general fields or matrix types could be a future direction.
  • Open Question: The paper explicitly asks: "Does there exist a single-pass, logspace PTAS for the constrained binary k-means problem and the generalised binary lo-rank-r approximation problem?" This highlights a key open research direction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{bhattacharya2019streaming,
  author = {Anup Bhattacharya and Dishant Goyal and Ragesh Jaiswal and Amit Kumar},
  title = {{Streaming PTAS for Binary \&\#120001; 0 -Low Rank Approximation.}},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure