Streaming Min-max Hypergraph Partitioning

Dan Alistarh, Jennifer Iglesias, Milan VojnovicNeurIPS 2015 · OpenReview

Introduction

In modern data processing, we frequently encounter "richly structured" data that can be represented as a hypergraph. This paper introduces a simple yet powerful greedy algorithm for partitioning these hypergraphs in a streaming setting, where items arrive one by one and must be assigned irrevocably to components. By focusing on minimizing the maximum number of "topics" (hyperedges) per component, the authors demonstrate that their strategy can recover hidden structures in data while outperforming traditional load-balancing heuristics and even some offline methods.

The Min-Max Hypergraph Partitioning Problem

To understand the problem, visualize a bipartite graph where one side represents items (like users, documents, or customers) and the other represents topics or associations (like interests, tags, or purchased products). In hypergraph terminology, items are vertices and topics are hyperedges.

A simple bipartite graph illustrating the relationship between items and topics.

The core challenge is Min-Max Hypergraph Partitioning: how do we split a massive set of items into $k$ different bins (servers or components) such that the maximum number of distinct topics covered by any single bin is minimized?

Solving this is crucial for two main reasons:

  1. Load Balancing: Ensuring no single server is overwhelmed by having to track too many distinct topics.
  2. Clustering: Grouping similar items together to create parsimonious, meaningful summaries.

While this partitioning is already NP-hard in an offline setting, this paper tackles the significantly harder streaming model. In this environment, items arrive sequentially, assignments are permanent, and the system operates with memory limited to be at most linear in the number of components (not the number of items).

A Greedy Item Placement Strategy

The authors propose a straightforward Greedy Item Placement Strategy. When a new item arrives with its set of associated topics, the algorithm follows three steps:

  1. Intersection Check: It calculates how many of the item's topics are already present in each of the $k$ components.
  2. Greedy Assignment: It assigns the item to the component with the largest topic intersection.
  3. Tie-breaking & Balancing: If there is a tie, it selects the least-loaded component. To prevent massive imbalances in the number of items per bin, a "balancing constraint" (a slack parameter $c$) is included to prevent any bin from exceeding the average load by too much.

The theoretical backbone of this approach is the proof of Balanced Asymptotic Recovery. Using a coupling argument, the authors show that this greedy process behaves like a Polya urn process with "rich-get-richer" dynamics. Once a component begins to specialize in a certain cluster of topics, it becomes increasingly likely to attract more items from that same cluster, eventually leading to a near-perfect recovery of the underlying data structure.

Key Insights and Empirical Results

The algorithm was evaluated on four diverse real-world bipartite datasets: Book Ratings, Facebook App Data, Retail Data, and Zune Podcast Data. They also utilized synthetic datasets generated via a Hidden Co-Clustering (HC) model, a bipartite generalization of the Stochastic Block Model where items have a "home" cluster of topics they connect to with high probability $p$, and a "noise" set they connect to with low probability $q$.

Performance comparison across four real-world datasets showing the Greedy approach outperforming baselines.

Several key insights emerged from the evaluation:

  • Random is Detrimental: While uniform random assignment is a standard go-to for load balancing, it is highly ineffective for this specific objective. Randomly spreading items ensures that almost every component ends up seeing almost every topic, maximizing the "topic load" everywhere.
  • The Power of Greed: By simply looking for the "best fit" locally, the algorithm naturally discovers global community structures. This "rich-get-richer" effect allows a streaming algorithm with no look-ahead to perform exceptionally well.
  • Information Density Matters: The algorithm performs significantly better when items arrive in decreasing order of their topic count. Items with many topics provide more "structural information" early on, helping the components specialize faster.
  • Submodularity: The cost function (number of distinct topics) is submodular, a mathematical property that makes the greedy approach particularly effective for this type of load balancing.

Ultimately, the greedy strategy consistently outperformed other online heuristics (like "Random," "Balance Big," and "Prefer Big") across all real-world datasets. Surprisingly, the streaming greedy approach even provided assignments with up to 3x to 5x lower max partition load than PARSA (an offline partitioning tool) on certain graph types.

Limitations and Future Work

While powerful, the theoretical recovery depends on specific bounds for the connection probabilities $p$ and $q$. If the noise ($q$) is too high or the number of hidden clusters is too small relative to $k$, the "rich-get-richer" effect might fail to trigger correctly. Furthermore, the paper focuses on a "grow-only" model where items arrive sequentially; it does not explicitly address dynamic scenarios where items or topics might be deleted or updated over time. Exploring the tightness of these recovery conditions and testing the algorithm on a wider variety of graph models remain important next steps.

Summary updated

Abstract

In many applications, the data is of rich structure that can be represented by a hypergraph, where the data items are represented by vertices and the associations among items are represented by hyperedges. Equivalently, we are given an input bipartite graph with two types of vertices: items, and associations (which we refer to as topics). We consider the problem of partitioning the set of items into a given number of parts such that the maximum number of topics covered by a part of the partition is minimized. This is a natural clustering problem, with various applications, e.g. partitioning of a set of information objects such as documents, images, and videos, and load balancing in the context of computation platforms.In this paper, we focus on the streaming computation model for this problem, in which items arrive online one at a time and each item must be assigned irrevocably to a part of the partition at its arrival time. Motivated by scalability requirements, we focus on the class of streaming computation algorithms with memory limited to be at most linear in the number of the parts of the partition. We show that a greedy assignment strategy is able to recover a hidden co-clustering of items under a natural set of recovery conditions. We also report results of an extensive empirical evaluation, which demonstrate that this greedy strategy yields superior performance when compared with alternative approaches.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alistarh2015streaming,
  author = {Dan Alistarh and Jennifer Iglesias and Milan Vojnovic},
  title = {{Streaming Min-max Hypergraph Partitioning}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2015},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=B1VvMwWdZB},
}

Loading related content...

Figure