Streaming Algorithm for Balance Gain and Cost with Cardinality Constraint on the Integer Lattice

Jingjing Tan, Chuannan Ge, Fan Wang, Zhenqi LiSSRN 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces efficient bicriteria streaming algorithms for the team formation problem, aiming to balance team gain and cost under a cardinality constraint on an integer lattice. The work extends existing methods by handling both submodular and non-submodular objective functions, offering theoretical guarantees for optimal solutions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The team formation problem, prevalent in areas like project management and workforce allocation, seeks to assemble a team that maximizes benefits while minimizing costs. This is often framed as an optimization problem where we select a set of individuals (or resources) to maximize an objective function, typically a balance between gain and cost, subject to constraints. A key challenge is the "cardinality constraint," which limits the total number of individuals selected.

This paper specifically tackles this problem within the framework of "integer lattices," which are mathematical structures that generalize vectors and allow for more complex relationships between elements. The authors extend previous work by considering two main scenarios:

  1. Submodular Gain Function: When the gain function exhibits diminishing returns (i.e., adding more members to a team yields progressively smaller increases in gain), and the cost function is linear.
  2. Non-submodular Gain Function: When the gain function does not necessarily exhibit diminishing returns (e.g., "a-weakly submodular"), which is a more general and challenging case.

The goal is to develop algorithms that can process data in a "streaming" fashion, meaning they can make decisions as data arrives without needing to store the entire dataset. This is crucial for large-scale applications where data volume is immense.

Methods

The paper proposes two main algorithmic approaches:

  • Algorithm 1 (for Submodular Gain): This algorithm leverages a combination of a lattice binary search and a threshold method. It processes incoming elements and decides whether to include them in the team based on a threshold. The binary search is used to efficiently determine the optimal "level" or quantity of an element to include, ensuring the cardinality constraint is met.
  • Algorithm 3 (for Non-submodular Gain): This algorithm extends the streaming approach to handle "a-weakly submodular" functions. It also uses a thresholding mechanism and a binary search sub-algorithm. A key innovation here is the use of a "lattice submodular rate" to quantify the deviation from submodularity, allowing for theoretical guarantees even in this more complex scenario.

Both algorithms are designed to be bicriteria, meaning they optimize two objectives simultaneously (gain and cost) and are streaming, processing data sequentially. The core idea is to maintain a current solution and, for each incoming element, decide how much of it to add to the solution to improve the overall objective while respecting the cardinality constraint and the threshold.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithm design and analysis rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Submodular and Non-submodular: A significant contribution is the development of algorithms that can handle both submodular and more general "a-weakly submodular" gain functions. This broadens the applicability of streaming team formation algorithms.
  • Lattice Binary Search for Quantities: The use of lattice binary search is a novel approach to efficiently determine the optimal quantity of an element to include in the team, especially when dealing with continuous or fractional contributions before discretizing to integer lattice values.
  • Streaming with Cardinality and Bicriteria Objectives: The paper successfully combines the challenges of streaming data, a strict cardinality constraint, and optimizing two conflicting objectives (gain and cost) into a cohesive algorithmic framework.
  • Theoretical Guarantees: The algorithms are accompanied by theoretical analyses that provide approximation ratios, ensuring that the solutions found are provably close to the optimal solution.

Key Results

The paper presents theoretical results in the form of bicriteria ratios for the proposed algorithms. These ratios quantify how close the objective function value of the algorithm's output is to the optimal solution.

  • For the submodular case (Algorithm 1), the bicriteria ratio is shown to be dependent on parameters related to the objective functions and constraints, with specific formulas provided in Theorem 1.
  • For the a-weakly submodular case (Algorithm 3), Theorem 2 establishes a similar bicriteria ratio, demonstrating the effectiveness of the algorithm for this more general class of functions.

The analysis also provides bounds on the space complexity, showing that the memory required is $O(k \log k / \epsilon)$ and the query number per element is $O(\log K)$, where $k$ is the cardinality constraint and $\epsilon$ is related to the desired approximation quality.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical Focus: The paper is primarily theoretical, focusing on algorithm design and proof of approximation guarantees. Empirical evaluation on real-world datasets is not presented, which would be a natural next step to validate the practical performance of these algorithms.
  • Specific Lattice Structures: While the paper works with integer lattices, future work could explore the performance and applicability of these algorithms on different types of lattice structures or more complex constraint types (e.g., matroid constraints).
  • General Non-submodularity: The paper addresses "a-weakly submodular" functions. Extending these streaming algorithms to handle arbitrary non-submodular functions would be a significant advancement.
  • Dynamic Environments: The current algorithms assume a static stream of data. Adapting them to dynamic environments where elements can be added or removed from the stream over time could be a valuable extension.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{tan2025streaming,
  author = {Jingjing Tan and Chuannan Ge and Fan Wang and Zhenqi Li},
  title = {{Streaming Algorithm for Balance Gain and Cost with Cardinality Constraint on the Integer Lattice}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.5277326},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure