Stratospheric ozone changes under solar geoengineering: implications for UV exposure and air quality

Peer Nowack, Nathan Luke Abraham, Peter Braesicke, J. A. PyleAtmospheric 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Various forms of geoengineering have been proposed to counter anthropogenic climate change. Methods which aim to modify the Earth's energy balance by reducing insolation are often subsumed under the term solar radiation management (SRM). Here, we present results of a standard SRM modelling experiment in which the incoming solar irradiance is reduced to offset the global mean warming induced by a quadrupling of atmospheric carbon dioxide. For the first time in an atmosphere–ocean coupled climate model, we include atmospheric composition feedbacks for this experiment. While the SRM scheme considered here could offset greenhouse gas induced global mean surface warming, it leads to important changes in atmospheric composition. We find large stratospheric ozone increases that induce significant reductions in surface UV-B irradiance, which would have implications for vitamin D production. In addition, the higher stratospheric ozone levels lead to decreased ozone photolysis in the troposphere. In combination with lower atmospheric specific humidity under SRM, this results in overall surface ozone concentration increases in the idealized G1 experiment. Both UV-B and surface ozone changes are important for human health. We therefore highlight that both stratospheric and tropospheric ozone changes must be considered in the assessment of any SRM scheme, due to their important roles in regulating UV exposure and air quality.

Introduction

Solar Radiation Management (SRM) is frequently discussed as a potential "emergency brake" for global warming. By intentionally reducing the amount of sunlight reaching the Earth's surface—for instance, through space-based mirrors or stratospheric aerosol injection—proponents suggest we could stabilize global temperatures even as greenhouse gas concentrations continue to rise. However, the atmosphere is not merely a physical system governed by radiative balance; it is a complex chemical reactor.

This study addresses a critical oversight in many early geoengineering assessments: the impact of SRM on atmospheric composition. Specifically, the researchers investigate how the "G1" geoengineering scenario—where solar dimming offsets a quadrupling of $CO_2$—alters the ozone layer. Ozone plays a dual role in human health: in the stratosphere, it protects life from harmful ultraviolet (UV) radiation, while at the surface, it acts as a toxic respiratory pollutant.

Methodology and Experimental Design

The researchers employed a state-of-the-art atmosphere–ocean coupled chemistry-climate model (the UK Met Office’s Unified Model with the UKCA chemistry scheme). This model is unique in allowing atmospheric chemistry to react dynamically to changes in temperature, humidity, and light, creating a feedback loop between the geoengineered climate and the air's chemical makeup.

The study followed the standardized protocols of the Geoengineering Model Intercomparison Project (GeoMIP), specifically the G1 experiment. In this scenario, atmospheric $CO_2$ is abruptly quadrupled ($4 \times CO_2$), and the solar constant is simultaneously reduced by approximately 3.6% (49 $Wm^{-2}$) to return the global mean surface temperature to pre-industrial levels (piControl).

Global mean surface temperature anomalies for piControl (black), $4 \times CO_2$ (blue), and G1 (red) experiments.

As shown in the figure above, the G1 experiment effectively stabilizes the global mean surface temperature, bringing it back in line with pre-industrial conditions. This provides a stable baseline to examine the secondary chemical effects of the intervention.

Key Results: The Chemical Side Effects of Solar Dimming

While the "thermostat" of solar dimming successfully manages global mean temperatures, it triggers significant shifts in atmospheric chemistry.

Stratospheric Ozone Surge and the UV-B Deficit

The combination of high $CO_2$ and reduced solar radiation leads to a substantial increase in stratospheric ozone. $CO_2$-induced cooling of the stratosphere slows down the chemical reactions that naturally destroy ozone. Simultaneously, reducing the solar constant decreases the photolysis (breakdown by light) of ozone molecules.

The result is an approximately 8% increase in global mean column ozone relative to pre-industrial levels. This thicker ozone layer, combined with the dimmed sun, causes a 10–20% drop in surface UV-B radiation in Northern Hemisphere mid-to-high latitudes during spring and summer. While this reduces skin cancer risks, it poses a significant threat to public health by potentially inducing widespread Vitamin D deficiency.

Surface Ozone and Air Quality Degradation

Counter-intuitively, the study finds that SRM makes surface-level air quality worse. The intervention weakens the hydrological cycle, leading to a drier atmosphere. In this lower-humidity environment, the production of the hydroxyl radical (OH)—the atmosphere's primary "detergent"—is reduced. With less OH available to scrub pollutants and less UV light to drive certain photolytic cycles, surface ozone concentrations increase by roughly 5% globally.

Spatial distribution of surface temperature changes relative to piControl for (a) the $4 \times CO_2$ scenario and (b) the G1 solar geoengineering scenario.

While G1 stabilizes the global mean, regional temperature anomalies persist, particularly in the polar regions and over landmasses. These regional climate shifts further influence local chemical reaction rates and air quality patterns.

Limitations and Future Outlook

The G1 experiment is an idealized scenario (representing "space mirrors"). A more realistic SRM approach, such as injecting sulfate aerosols into the stratosphere, would introduce even more complex heterogeneous chemistry. Aerosol surfaces can catalyze ozone-depleting reactions, potentially offsetting the ozone increases seen here or creating severe regional ozone holes. Furthermore, this study used pre-industrial levels of anthropogenic pollutants like $NO_x$; future research must account for how modern and future emission profiles will interact with a geoengineered climate.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that solar geoengineering cannot be viewed simply as a temperature control mechanism. The chemical "side effects"—specifically the increase in stratospheric ozone and the degradation of surface air quality—are substantial and have direct implications for human health. Any future assessment of SRM must move beyond simple climate metrics to include a comprehensive 3D modeling of atmospheric composition and its impacts on UV exposure and the air we breathe.

Summary updated

Abstract

Various forms of geoengineering have been proposed to counter anthropogenic climate change. Methods which aim to modify the Earth's energy balance by reducing insolation are often subsumed under the term solar radiation management (SRM). Here, we present results of a standard SRM modelling experiment in which the incoming solar irradiance is reduced to offset the global mean warming induced by a quadrupling of atmospheric carbon dioxide. For the first time in an atmosphere–ocean coupled climate model, we include atmospheric composition feedbacks for this experiment. While the SRM scheme considered here could offset greenhouse gas induced global mean surface warming, it leads to important changes in atmospheric composition. We find large stratospheric ozone increases that induce significant reductions in surface UV-B irradiance, which would have implications for vitamin D production. In addition, the higher stratospheric ozone levels lead to decreased ozone photolysis in the troposphere. In combination with lower atmospheric specific humidity under SRM, this results in overall surface ozone concentration increases in the idealized G1 experiment. Both UV-B and surface ozone changes are important for human health. We therefore highlight that both stratospheric and tropospheric ozone changes must be considered in the assessment of any SRM scheme, due to their important roles in regulating UV exposure and air quality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nowack2016stratospheric,
  author = {Peer Nowack and Nathan Luke Abraham and Peter Braesicke and J. A. Pyle},
  title = {{Stratospheric ozone changes under solar geoengineering: implications for UV exposure and air quality}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-16-4191-2016},
}
Figure