Strategy implementation for the CTA Atmospheric monitoring program

M. Doro, M. K. Daniel, R. de los Reyes, M. Gaug, M. C. MaccaroneSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

The Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) needs precise atmospheric monitoring to achieve its goal of better than 10% energy reconstruction accuracy for gamma-ray astronomy. This paper outlines a comprehensive strategy for implementing a suite of instruments and methods to characterize the atmosphere, ensuring high-quality data and maximizing observation time.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes (IACTs), like the upcoming CTA, detect very-high-energy gamma rays by observing the Cherenkov light produced by particle showers in the atmosphere. The accuracy of reconstructing the primary gamma-ray's energy and direction is critically dependent on understanding the atmospheric conditions. The atmosphere affects Cherenkov light production and transmission through molecular and aerosol extinction. Current IACTs often use atmospheric data primarily for selecting good observation time, with limited routine correction. This leads to systematic uncertainties, particularly in energy reconstruction, which CTA aims to reduce to below 10%. Therefore, a robust and integrated atmospheric monitoring program is essential for CTA's success.

Methods

The paper proposes a multi-faceted approach to atmospheric monitoring, integrating various instruments and data analysis techniques. Key methods include:

  • Raman Lidars: These are the primary instruments for detailed, height-resolved atmospheric profiling, measuring molecular and aerosol content. Several institutes are developing independent prototypes with different optical and mechanical designs.
  • Ceilometers: Used for continuous, eye-safe monitoring of cloud presence and vertical visibility, complementing lidar data.
  • All-Sky Cameras (ASC): Passive, non-invasive systems to monitor cloud cover and overall atmospheric quality across the entire sky, helping to identify clear regions for observation.
  • Stellar Photometers (UVscope, FRAM): These instruments measure atmospheric transparency by tracking stars, allowing for the evaluation of light absorption as a function of air mass. UVscope is designed for direct photon counting in the UV-blue range, while FRAM uses a wide-field camera for broader sky coverage.
  • Cherenkov Transparency Coefficient (CTC): A method derived from CTA's own Cherenkov data (trigger rates, muon efficiency) to estimate atmospheric transparency. While it doesn't provide height information, it shows good correlation with independent measurements and can be used for data quality selection.
  • Molecular Profile Measurement: Approximated by global assimilation systems like GDAS, with plans for dedicated radiosonde campaigns for validation and local characterization.

The strategy is organized into five key tasks: Climatology Build-up, Off-line Data Selection, Off-line Data Correction, On-line Smart Scheduling, and Weather Now-cast, Fore-cast, Alerts and Protection.

Datasets

The paper discusses the use of various existing datasets and the generation of new data through the proposed instruments:

  • Existing Datasets:
    • Global atmospheric data assimilation systems (e.g., GDAS).
  • Commercial weather station data.
  • National weather radars.
  • Satellite data (e.g., CALIPSO, MODIS, GOES).
  • Historical data from meteorological networks.
  • Data from existing IACT sites (e.g., H.E.S.S., MAGIC).
  • AERONET (for sun photometer validation).
  • Newly Generated Data:
    • Data from Raman lidars, ceilometers, all-sky cameras, UVscope, and FRAM at CTA sites.
  • Data from radiosonde campaigns.
  • Cherenkov Transparency Coefficient (CTC) derived from CTA data.

No specific new benchmarks are introduced, but the paper emphasizes the need for standardized algorithms and inter-comparison of data from different instruments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Atmospheric Characterization is Paramount: The paper strongly emphasizes that achieving CTA's ambitious scientific goals hinges on precisely understanding and correcting for atmospheric effects, which are a major source of systematic uncertainty in current IACTs.
  • Integrated Approach is Crucial: No single instrument is sufficient. A combination of ground-based lidars, cameras, stellar photometers, and analysis of CTA's own data is required for comprehensive monitoring.
  • Beyond Data Selection: The strategy moves beyond simply discarding "bad weather" data. It aims to enable routine correction of data taken under non-optimal conditions, thereby increasing the effective duty cycle and scientific yield.
  • Smart Scheduling: The atmospheric monitoring data will feed into an intelligent scheduling system to optimize observations based on real-time atmospheric conditions and physics requirements.
  • Leveraging Existing Networks: CTA plans to integrate with existing global atmospheric monitoring networks, benefiting from their long-term data and contributing data from its remote sites.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results from a fully implemented CTA system, as it is still in the design stage. Instead, it outlines the strategy and expected capabilities:

  • Improved Energy Reconstruction: The primary goal is to control systematic uncertainties in energy reconstruction to better than 10%.
  • Increased Duty Cycle: By enabling data correction and smart scheduling, the effective observation time will be maximized.
  • Comprehensive Climatology: A detailed understanding of the atmospheric behavior at CTA sites will be built over time.
  • Validation of Models: The proposed instruments will allow for validation and refinement of atmospheric models used in data analysis.
  • High Correlation of CTC: The Cherenkov Transparency Coefficient (CTC) has shown a correlation factor of ~0.85 with aerosol optical depth measurements from satellites and ground-based instruments, demonstrating its utility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Height Profile Uncertainty: The CTC method, while useful, does not provide information about the height profile of atmospheric disturbances, which is crucial for full data correction. This highlights the necessity of instruments like Raman lidars.
  • Instrument Inter-comparison and Calibration: A significant effort will be required to calibrate and inter-compare the data from the various atmospheric monitoring instruments to ensure consistency and accuracy.
  • Integration with Data Pipelines: Seamless integration of atmospheric data into CTA's data reconstruction and analysis pipelines is a key challenge.
  • Future Work: The paper implies ongoing development and testing of individual instruments, as well as the need for detailed studies on how to best combine data from different sources for optimal atmospheric correction and scheduling. The establishment of a dedicated radiosonde campaign is also planned.

Summary updated

Abstract

\nThe Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) is the next generation facility of Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes. It reaches unprecedented sensitivity and energy resolution in very-high-energy gamma-ray astronomy. CTA detects Cherenkov light emitted within an atmospheric shower of particles initiated by cosmic-gamma rays or cosmic rays entering the Earth's atmosphere. From the combination of images the Cherenkov light produces in the telescopes, one is able to infer the primary particle energy and direction. A correct energy estimation can be thus performed only if the local atmosphere is well characterized. The atmosphere not only affects the shower development itself, but also the Cherenkov photon transmission from the emission point in the particle shower, at about 10–20 km above the ground, to the detector. Cherenkov light on the ground is peaked in the UV-blue region, and therefore molecular and aerosol extinction phenomena are important. The goal of CTA is to control systematics in energy reconstruction to better than 10%. For this reason, a careful and continuous monitoring and characterization of the atmosphere is required. In addition, CTA will be operated as an observatory, with data made public along with appropriate analysis tools. High-level data quality can only be ensured if the atmospheric properties are consistently and continuously taken into account. In this contribution, we concentrate on discussing the implementation strategy for the various atmospheric monitoring instruments currently under discussion in CTA. These includes Raman lidars and ceilometers, stellar photometers and others available both from commercial providers and public research centers.\n
BibTeX
@inproceedings{doro2015strategy,
  author = {M. Doro and M. K. Daniel and R. de los Reyes and M. Gaug and M. C. Maccarone},
  title = {{Strategy implementation for the CTA Atmospheric monitoring program}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1051/epjconf/20158902005/pdf},
}
Figure