Strategic Grazing in Beef-Pastures for Improved Soil Health and Reduced Runoff-Nitrate-A Step towards Sustainability

Subash Dahal, Dorcas H. Franklin, Anish Subedi, M. L. Cabrera, Dennis W. Hancock, Kishan Mahmud, Laura Ney, Cheolwoo Park, Deepak R. MishraSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that a "strategic grazing" (STR) system, incorporating cattle exclusion from vulnerable areas and overseeding, significantly improves soil health indicators like active carbon and soil respiration, while simultaneously reducing nitrate runoff compared to conventional continuous grazing. This approach offers a promising pathway towards more sustainable beef production, especially in the face of changing climate conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of improving the sustainability of beef pasturelands, particularly in the Southeastern USA. These regions often feature marginal, erosion-prone lands that provide crucial ecosystem services but are vulnerable to nutrient loss. Conventional continuous grazing practices can exacerbate these issues by concentrating cattle activity, leading to nutrient hotspots, soil compaction, and increased runoff of pollutants like nitrate. The authors aim to quantify the effectiveness of a novel "strategic grazing" (STR) system, which integrates several best management practices, in mitigating these negative impacts and enhancing soil health.

Methods

The study employed a farm-scale, before-and-after, and with-and-without experimental design over four years (2015-2018) in eight beef pastures across two sites in Georgia. Four pastures were converted to the STR system, while four continued with a modified continuous grazing system that included hay distribution (CHD).

Key methods included:

  • Soil Health Indicators:
    • Permanganate Oxidizable Carbon (POXC): Measured as an indicator of active carbon, reflecting soil health and microbial activity.
  • Soil Respiration: Measured using alkali traps to assess CO2 efflux, another key indicator of soil biological activity.
  • Potentially Mineralizable Nitrogen (PMN) and Inorganic Nitrogen (IN): Assessed to understand nitrogen cycling within the soil.
  • Runoff Analysis:
    • Nitrate (NO3⁻) in Runoff: Collected using pour-point collectors and analyzed for concentration.
  • Runoff Volume: Estimated using the curve number method.
  • Nitrate Load: Calculated by multiplying concentration and volume.
  • Cattle Locus Index: Wildlife GPS collars were used to track cattle movement and density within pastures, helping to understand the spatial distribution of their activity.
  • Statistical Analysis: Student's t-tests and non-parametric Wilcoxon Rank Sum tests were used for comparisons, along with linear regression to explore relationships between variables.

The STR system's unique components included: strategic placement of pasture equipages (water, shade, hay), exclusion of vulnerable areas (AOIs) using electric fences, overseeding these AOIs with a forage mix, and flash grazing of these exclusions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized field data collected over four years from eight beef pastures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • STR is More Than Just Rotational Grazing: The study highlights that "strategic grazing" is a multifaceted approach, combining elements like cattle exclusion, overseeding, and managed movement of resources, which goes beyond simple rotational grazing.
  • Vulnerable Areas are Key: Excluding cattle from and actively managing "Areas of Interest" (AOIs) – typically areas prone to compaction and nutrient loss – proved critical for improving soil health and reducing runoff.
  • Resilience to Extreme Weather: The STR system demonstrated a greater ability to maintain soil health indicators (like POXC and soil respiration) and recover from extreme weather events (drought and heavy rain) compared to the CHD system.
  • Nitrogen Cycling Optimization: STR facilitated more efficient mineralization of soil nitrogen and its subsequent uptake, leading to reduced nitrate loss in runoff.
  • Reduced Pollutant Runoff: The most significant finding is the substantial reduction in nitrate runoff from STR pastures, directly addressing a major environmental concern in agricultural watersheds.

Key Results

  • Active Carbon (POXC): STR pastures showed significantly greater POXC (87.1, 63.4, and 55.6 mg kg⁻¹ at 0-5, 5-10, and 10-20 cm, respectively) compared to CHD pastures in 2018.
  • Soil Respiration: STR pastures had significantly higher soil respiration (235 mg CO2 m⁻² 24 h⁻¹) in 2018 compared to CHD pastures.
  • Runoff Nitrate: STR pastures had significantly lower runoff nitrate loss (0.08 kg ha⁻¹) per event compared to baseline and after-treatment CHD pastures.
  • Nitrogen Mineralization: While PMN levels didn't differ significantly between treatments, overseeding in STR exclusions led to a significant increase in inorganic nitrogen (28.6 mg kg⁻¹ at 0-5 cm), indicating improved nitrogen availability.
  • Cattle Locus vs. Runoff: Before treatment, increased cattle activity near runoff collectors correlated with higher nitrate runoff. After STR treatment, this relationship was eliminated, demonstrating the effectiveness of the management practices.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Farm-Scale Limitations: The authors acknowledge that farm-scale studies can be challenging to control for all environmental and managerial factors.
  • Limited Depth of Analysis: POXC analysis was limited to 20 cm depth, and the authors suggest longer-term research with deeper sampling to fully understand carbon sequestration.
  • Applicability: While promising, further research is needed to assess the actual applicability of the STR system on a wider range of farmers' fields.
  • Long-Term Evaluation: A long-term study is recommended to comprehensively evaluate the beneficial effects of STR and CHD on carbon sequestration, soil health, and nitrogen cycling.
  • Broader Ecosystem Services: While the study focused on soil health and nitrate runoff, future work could explore other ecosystem services influenced by these grazing systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Generally, improvement in the soil health of pasturelands can result in amplified ecosystem services which can help improve the overall sustainability of the system. The extent to which specific best management practices have this effect has yet to be established. A farm-scale study was conducted in eight beef-pastures in the Southern Piedmont of Georgia, from 2015 to 2018, to assess the effect of strategic-grazing (STR) and continuous-grazing hay distribution (CHD) on soil health indicators and runoff nitrate losses. In 2016, four pastures were converted to the STR system and four were grazed using the CHD system. Post-treatment, in 2018, the STR system had significantly greater POXC (by 87.1, 63.4, and 55.6 mg ha−1 at 0–5, 5–10, and 10–20 cm, respectively) as compared to CHD system. Soil respiration was also greater in the STR system (by 235 mg CO2 m-2 24 h−1) and less nitrate was lost in the runoff (by 0.21 kg ha−1) as compared to the CHD system. Cattle exclusion and overseeding vulnerable areas of pastures in STR pastures facilitated nitrogen mineralization and uptake. Our results showed that the STR grazing system could improve the sustainability of grazing systems by storing more labile carbon, efficiently mineralizing soil nitrogen, and lowering runoff nitrate losses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dahal2020strategic,
  author = {Subash Dahal and Dorcas H. Franklin and Anish Subedi and M. L. Cabrera and Dennis W. Hancock and Kishan Mahmud and Laura Ney and Cheolwoo Park and Deepak R. Mishra},
  title = {{Strategic Grazing in Beef-Pastures for Improved Soil Health and Reduced Runoff-Nitrate-A Step towards Sustainability}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12020558},
}
Figure