Stone Free Rate of Lower Pole Calyceal Stone Versus Other Calyces in Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery

Rajiv Ratn Shah, Tika Devi Kandel, Deepak AdhikariJournal of College of Medical Sciences-Nepal 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery (RIRS) using Holmium lasers achieves high stone-free rates for lower pole kidney stones (86.2%) that are statistically comparable to stones located in other parts of the kidney (93.9%). The findings suggest that modern endoscopic advancements have made RIRS a safe and effective "equalizer" for treating stones in anatomically difficult locations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of urology, the "lower pole" of the kidney is a notoriously difficult neighborhood. Because of gravity and the sharp, hook-like angle (the infundibulopelvic angle) required to reach it, stones located here are harder to clear than those in the upper or middle sections. Traditional non-invasive treatments like Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy (SWL) often struggle with lower pole stones because the fragmented "dust" has to travel uphill to exit the kidney.

Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery (RIRS)—which involves threading a flexible scope through the urinary tract and using a laser to pulverize stones—has emerged as a powerful alternative. However, the technical difficulty of maneuvering a flexible scope into the lower pole raises a critical question: Does the location of the stone still dictate the success of the surgery? This paper evaluates whether RIRS can achieve the same "Stone Free Rate" (SFR) in the lower pole as it does elsewhere.

Methods

The authors conducted a retrospective cross-sectional study at Chitwan Medical College and Teaching Hospital in Nepal, analyzing 62 adult patients treated between March 2021 and February 2022.

The surgical protocol was standardized:

  • Access: Under general anesthesia, a flexible ureteroscope was introduced via a 9.5Fr ureteral access sheath.
  • Fragmentation: A 100-watt Holmium laser (using 200 μm or 365 μm fibers) was used to "dust" or fragment the stones.
  • Post-Op: All patients received a Double-J (DJ) stent for four weeks to assist fragment passage and prevent strictures.
  • Evaluation: Success was defined as being "Stone Free"—having no fragments or only "Clinically Insignificant Radiological Fragments" (CIRF) smaller than 4mm, as measured by ultrasound or CT scan 4–6 weeks post-surgery.

Datasets

As a clinical retrospective study, the "dataset" consisted of the medical records of 62 patients. These were divided into two cohorts:

  1. Lower Calyx Group: 29 patients.
  2. Other Calyces Group: 33 patients.

Variables tracked included patient demographics, stone density (Hounsfield Units), stone size, operative time, and hospital stay duration.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Anatomical Neutralization: The most significant takeaway is that modern flexible ureteroscopes, with their improved deflection angles and fiber optics, have largely neutralized the anatomical disadvantage of the lower pole.
  • The "Dusting" Preference: The surgeons prioritized "dusting" (turning the stone into fine powder) over "fragmenting" (breaking it into small chunks). This technique is particularly useful in the lower pole, as fine dust is more likely to wash out spontaneously than larger fragments that might get trapped by gravity.
  • Hospital Stay Paradox: The study noted a relatively long hospital stay (average ~6 days) compared to international standards. The authors insightfully attribute this not to medical necessity, but to patient preference and a "fear of untoward complications" once they return to remote homes—a common factor in regional medical studies.

Key Results

The study found no statistically significant difference in outcomes between the two groups, suggesting RIRS is equally effective regardless of stone location:

  • Stone Free Rate (SFR): 86.2% for the lower pole vs. 93.9% for other locations ($p = 0.405$). While the raw percentage is lower for the lower pole, the difference was not statistically significant.
  • Operative Time: Nearly identical, with ~63.8 minutes for lower pole stones and ~65.9 minutes for others.
  • Stone Characteristics: Both groups had similar mean stone sizes (~11mm) and densities (~1000 Hounsfield Units).
  • Safety: There were zero major complications in either group. Minor complications like flank pain and post-operative fever were distributed similarly across both cohorts.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations that are common in clinical research:

  • Sample Size: With only 62 patients, the study may lack the statistical power to detect very subtle differences in outcomes.
  • Study Design: Being a retrospective, single-center study, it is subject to inherent selection biases.
  • Follow-up: The study relies on a relatively short follow-up window (6 weeks).

The authors suggest that future research should involve large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with longer follow-up periods to confirm these findings and further refine the technical approach to lower pole stones.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Miniaturization of endoscopic instruments has gained wide popularity in the treatment of renal calculi. Retrograde intra-renal surgery (RIRS) and laser in combination has already proven their superiority when compared to other modalities in the treatment of renal calculi. This study was conducted to assess the stone-free rate (SFR) of lower pole calyceal stone versus other pole calyces in RIRS. Methods: This retrospective study analyzed the stone free rate of lower pole calyx stone versus other pole calyces in retrograde intra renal surgery (RIRS) adults above 15 years of age from March 2021 to February 2022 at Chitwan Medical College and Teaching Hospital, Nepal. The stone-free rate was assessed descriptively on post operative complications, stone size, operative time, hospital stay, and need for the second procedure. Results: A total of 62 patients underwent retrograde intrarenal surgery. The mean age of the study population was 38.41 ± 10.54years in the lower caliceal group against 39.09 ±13.53 years with p value of 0.829.The mean hounsfield of lower caliceal stone was 1023.31±252.96 to that of other caliceal stones 1004.00±349.22 with p value of 0.806. The sizes of the stones were 11.07±2.10 mm in lower caliceal stones versus 10.67±2.51mm in other caliceal stones with p value of 0.507. The duration of operation time in 1st group was 63.82±23.57minutes to that of 65.93±28.96 in 2nd group with p value of 0.756. The hospital stay in lower caliceal stones were 6.13±1.43days to that of other caliceal stones 5.87±0.99 with significant p value of 0.412. There were no major complications in both arms. The stone free rate was 25 (86.2%) in lower caliceal stones as compared to 31(93.93%) in other caliceal stones with no significant p value of 0.405. Conclusions: Retrograde intrarenal surgery is a better procedure that continues to undergo significant advancements. It is a technically safe and effective procedure for the treatment option for treating the lower pole calyx calculus with optimal post-surgical morbidity and stone-free rate.
BibTeX
@article{shah2023stone,
  author = {Rajiv Ratn Shah and Tika Devi Kandel and Deepak Adhikari},
  title = {{Stone Free Rate of Lower Pole Calyceal Stone Versus Other Calyces in Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery}},
  journal = {Journal of College of Medical Sciences-Nepal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3126/jcmsn.v19i1.49849},
}
Figure