Stochastic Ratchet Mechanisms for Replacement of Proteins Bound to DNA

Simona Cocco, John F. Marko, Rémi MonassonPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Experiments indicate that unbinding rates of proteins from DNA can depend on the concentration of proteins in nearby solution. Here we present a theory of multistep replacement of DNA-bound proteins by solution-phase proteins. For four different kinetic scenarios we calculate the dependence of protein unbinding and replacement rates on solution protein concentration. We find (1) strong effects of progressive "rezipping" of the solution-phase protein onto DNA sites liberated by "unzipping" of the originally bound protein, (2) that a model in which solution-phase proteins bind nonspecifically to DNA can describe experiments on exchanges between the nonspecific DNA-binding proteins Fis-Fis and Fis-HU, and (3) that a binding specific model describes experiments on the exchange of CueR proteins on specific binding sites.

Introduction

In classical biochemistry, the dissociation rate ($k_{off}$) of a protein from DNA is typically considered a constant intrinsic to the protein-DNA complex. However, recent single-molecule experiments have challenged this view, revealing that $k_{off}$ can increase significantly with the concentration of proteins in the surrounding solution—a phenomenon known as "facilitated dissociation."

This behavior is puzzling because it suggests that solution-phase proteins can actively "crowd out" a bound protein. Standard "all-or-nothing" binding models fail to explain this concentration dependence. Understanding this mechanism is vital, as the crowded cellular environment necessitates rapid protein turnover for cells to respond dynamically to environmental signals.

Theoretical Framework: The Stochastic Ratchet

The authors propose a "stochastic ratchet" theory based on Master Equations to describe the multi-step dynamics of protein replacement. A protein is modeled as a chain of $N$ units, each bound to DNA with energy $\epsilon$. Thermal fluctuations cause these units to intermittently detach ("unzip"). In isolation, they would simply re-bind ("rezip"). However, in the presence of solution-phase proteins, an "invader" can occupy these temporarily vacated sites, preventing the original protein from re-binding. This acts as a ratchet, progressively driving the original protein toward full dissociation.

The paper explores four distinct kinetic scenarios for this process:

  1. Non-Zipping (NZ): Invaders bind only to vacated sites without further "zipping."
  2. Zipping-Non-Specific (Z-NS): Invaders bind to any free site and then sequentially bind (zip) to adjacent sites.
  3. Zipping-Specific-Non-Specific Binding (Z-S-NSB): Invaders bind to nearby non-specific sites before zipping into a specific site.
  4. Zipping-Specific-Specific Binding (Z-S-SB): Invaders bind specifically to the first available site after unzipping begins.
Schematic of the four kinetic models (NZ, Z-NS, Z-S-NSB, Z-S-SB) illustrating the multi-step replacement process.

Results and Validation

The theoretical models were validated against experimental data for several protein systems, including Fis (a bacterial nucleoid-associated protein), CueR (a transcription factor), and DNA Polymerase.

A key finding is that "zipping"—the ability of an invader to sequentially occupy adjacent sites—is essential for matching experimental unbinding rates. Without zipping (the NZ model), the predicted replacement rate is orders of magnitude slower than observed. Furthermore, the scaling of the replacement rate $R$ with the number of binding units $N$ differs by mechanism: $R$ decays exponentially with $N$ in the Z-NS model but only algebraically ($1/N$) in the Z-S-NSB model. This explains why specific DNA-binding proteins like CueR can be replaced much more rapidly than non-specific ones.

Comparison of the Z-NS and Z-S-NSB models with experimental unbinding rates for Fis-Fis, Fis-HU, and CueR exchange.

Specific results include:

  • Fis-Fis/Fis-HU: The Z-NS model accurately fits the data with $N \approx 14-19$ units and $\epsilon \approx 2 k_BT$ per unit, consistent with known non-specific binding properties.
  • CueR: The Z-S-NSB model successfully explains why CueR exchange is ~1,000 times faster than Fis, fitting the data with $N \approx 15$ and $\epsilon \approx 1.36 k_BT$.
  • DNA Polymerase: The model accounts for observed exchange rates by assuming a large footprint ($N \approx 35$), matching the enzyme's physical structure.

Discussion and Future Directions

The stochastic ratchet model provides a quantitative framework for understanding how cells can tune protein turnover rates simply by adjusting competitor concentrations. However, the model currently assumes a homogeneous binding energy $\epsilon$ along the DNA. Future work should incorporate DNA sequence heterogeneity, which likely influences zipping speeds. Additionally, exploring "heterogeneous replacement" where invaders have different affinities than the bound protein could provide deeper insights into competitive binding in complex cellular environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Experiments indicate that unbinding rates of proteins from DNA can depend on the concentration of proteins in nearby solution. Here we present a theory of multistep replacement of DNA-bound proteins by solution-phase proteins. For four different kinetic scenarios we calculate the dependence of protein unbinding and replacement rates on solution protein concentration. We find (1) strong effects of progressive "rezipping" of the solution-phase protein onto DNA sites liberated by "unzipping" of the originally bound protein, (2) that a model in which solution-phase proteins bind nonspecifically to DNA can describe experiments on exchanges between the nonspecific DNA-binding proteins Fis-Fis and Fis-HU, and (3) that a binding specific model describes experiments on the exchange of CueR proteins on specific binding sites.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cocco2014stochastic,
  author = {Simona Cocco and John F. Marko and Rémi Monasson},
  title = {{Stochastic Ratchet Mechanisms for Replacement of Proteins Bound to DNA}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.112.238101},
}
Figure