Stochastic quantization and the role of time in quantum gravity

J. Ambjørn, R. Loll, W. Westra, Stefan ZohrenPhysics 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper establishes a surprising connection between two seemingly different approaches to quantum gravity: causal dynamical triangulations (CDT) and stochastic quantization. By identifying the "proper time" in CDT with the "stochastic time" of stochastic quantization, the authors show that CDT can be reformulated as a stochastic process. This provides a new, nonperturbative way to understand quantum gravity, particularly in two dimensions, and suggests a deeper role for "external" time-like parameters in quantum gravity theories.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nature of time in quantum gravity is a notoriously difficult problem. In classical general relativity, spacetime is dynamic and its geometry is described by the metric tensor, which includes time. However, when trying to quantize gravity, the reparametrization invariance of the theory makes it challenging to define a consistent notion of time. This is particularly true in higher dimensions where perturbative approaches face issues like nonrenormalizability.

Two-dimensional quantum gravity serves as a valuable testing ground for these ideas. Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT) is a nonperturbative approach that uses a discrete lattice regularization to define a path integral over spacetime geometries. It imposes a causality condition and uses a global "proper time" foliation. Separately, stochastic quantization offers a way to define quantum field theories by introducing a fictitious "stochastic time" and a Langevin equation, which leads to a probability distribution that corresponds to the quantum partition function.

This paper addresses the question of how these two frameworks relate, specifically whether the sophisticated CDT approach can be understood through the lens of stochastic quantization, and what this implies for the role of time in quantum gravity.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in demonstrating an equivalence between the string field theory derived from two-dimensional CDT and a stochastic quantization of a simplified system.

  1. Stochastic Quantization Formalism: The authors begin by reviewing the standard formalism of stochastic quantization. This involves a Langevin equation for a variable $x(t)$ driven by a Gaussian white noise term, where $t$ is the stochastic time. The drift force is derived from a potential $S(x)$, and the resulting probability distribution $P(x, x_0; t)$ satisfies a Fokker-Planck equation, which is analogous to an imaginary-time Schrödinger equation.
  2. CDT String Field Theory: They then introduce the string field theory developed from two-dimensional CDT, which describes the dynamics of spacetime geometries, including topology changes (splitting and joining of spatial universes). This theory is formulated using a path integral over triangulated spacetime manifolds.
  3. The Equivalence: The crucial step is to show that the amplitude describing the propagation of spatial universes in the CDT string field theory, when viewed in a specific formulation (using Laplace transforms), satisfies the same differential equation as the probability distribution arising from a stochastic quantization of a zero-dimensional system. This equivalence is achieved by identifying the "proper time" in the CDT formulation with the "stochastic time" in the stochastic quantization.
  4. Nonperturbative Hamiltonian: This identification allows for the derivation of a nonperturbative quantum Hamiltonian for the CDT string field theory. This Hamiltonian naturally incorporates a sum over all spacetime topologies, a key feature of the CDT approach.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stochastic Time as Proper Time: The most significant insight is the identification of the "proper time" in CDT with the "stochastic time" in stochastic quantization. This is not a trivial identification, as proper time is usually associated with the intrinsic geometry of spacetime, while stochastic time is an external parameter introduced for quantization.
  • Stochastic Quantization as a Unifying Framework: The paper suggests that stochastic quantization can provide a unified and nonperturbative way to derive and understand complex quantum gravity theories, particularly those involving topology change.
  • External Character of Time: The authors argue that the "external" nature of stochastic time is a more general feature that might also apply to proper time or distance parameters in other nonperturbative quantum gravity correlation functions. This hints at a deeper conceptual link between how we define time in quantum gravity and how we construct correlation functions.
  • Natural Inclusion of Topology Change: The stochastic quantization approach naturally generates amplitudes that account for topology changes, which are introduced "by hand" in traditional string field theory formulations.

Key Results

  • The paper demonstrates that the string field theory derived from two-dimensional CDT can be viewed as a stochastic quantization of space.
  • This equivalence leads to a natural, nonperturbative quantum Hamiltonian for the CDT string field theory.
  • The framework provides a new interpretation for the proper time in CDT as stochastic time.
  • The analysis suggests that the "external" character of time-like parameters is a general feature in nonperturbative quantum gravity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dimensionality: The current work focuses on two-dimensional quantum gravity. Extending this framework to higher dimensions, where analytical solutions are not available, remains a significant challenge.
  • Hamiltonian Sector: The extended Hamiltonian derived in Section 4 is noted to capture only a sector of the full dynamics, specifically loop-loop amplitudes, and its relation to the complete dynamics in an "effective" way requires further understanding.
  • Generalization: While the paper suggests that the "external" nature of time might be a general feature, a rigorous demonstration and exploration of this in more general settings (e.g., higher dimensions, different matter couplings) is an ongoing area of investigation.
  • Physical Interpretation of "x": The variable $x$ in the stochastic quantization context, which is identified with the boundary cosmological constant via Laplace transform, could benefit from further physical interpretation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that the noncritical string field theory developed from two-dimensional quantum gravity in the framework of causal dynamical triangulations can be viewed as arising through a stochastic quantization. This requires that the proper time appearing in the string field theory be identified with the stochastic time of the stochastic formulation. The framework of stochastic quantization gives rise to a natural nonperturbative quantum Hamiltonian, which incorporates a sum over all spacetime topologies. We point out that the external character of stochastic time is a feature that pertains more generally to the proper time or distance appearing in nonperturbative correlation functions in quantum gravity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ambjrn2009stochastic,
  author = {J. Ambjørn and R. Loll and W. Westra and Stefan Zohren},
  title = {{Stochastic quantization and the role of time in quantum gravity}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2009.09.016},
}
Figure