Stochastic Neural Simulation Relations for Control Transfer

Alireza Nadali, Ashutosh Trivedi, Majid ZamaniNeuS 2025 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel neurosymbolic framework for transferring control logic between stochastic systems. By learning "stochastic neural simulation functions," the approach enables controllers to be transferred from a source system to a target system while guaranteeing probabilistic behavioral equivalence, even for complex, high-dimensional systems where traditional methods fail.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing controllers for safety-critical systems often relies on formal methods that provide provable guarantees. However, creating the necessary abstract models for these systems can be computationally intensive, limiting their widespread adoption. While neural networks offer scalability for controller synthesis, they often lack formal guarantees. Transfer learning aims to bridge this gap by leveraging knowledge from a source system to accelerate learning in a target system. However, existing transfer learning methods for control often struggle with:

  • Lack of Formal Guarantees: They may not provide rigorous assurances about the target system's behavior.
  • Need for Explicit Specifications: They often require detailed, formal specifications of the desired behavior for both source and target systems, which can be difficult to obtain, especially for legacy systems.
  • Model Dependency: Many approaches require a complete mathematical model of the systems, which is not always available.

This paper addresses the challenge of transferring control logic between stochastic systems while ensuring probabilistic behavioral equivalence and formal guarantees, without requiring explicit system models or specifications.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of Stochastic Neural Simulation Functions. These functions are designed to establish probabilistic observational equivalence between two black-box stochastic systems (a source $\hat{S}$ and a target $S$). The key ideas are:

  • Stochastic Simulation Relations: The authors extend the concept of simulation relations to the stochastic domain. A stochastic simulation relation $V$ between the state spaces of the source and target systems ensures that if two states are related by $V$, then their future states will also remain related probabilistically. This implies that any behavior on the source system can be mimicked on the target system.
  • Neural Network Parameterization: To learn these complex relations from data, the simulation function $V$ and an interface function $K$ (which acts as the transferred controller for the target system) are parameterized as neural networks. This allows for a data-driven approach.
  • Data-Driven Training: The neural networks $V$ and $K$ are trained using a loss function that aims to satisfy the conditions of a stochastic neural simulation function. This involves minimizing the difference between the predicted future states and the actual future states, while ensuring the outputs of the two systems remain probabilistically close.
  • Validity Conditions: To bridge the gap between training on finite data and guaranteeing performance over an infinite horizon, the authors introduce validity conditions. These conditions, based on Lipschitz continuity properties of the learned networks and system dynamics, provide theoretical guarantees that the learned stochastic neural simulation function is indeed a valid one, ensuring probabilistic correctness without post-hoc verification.
  • Specification-Agnostic Transfer: A key innovation is that the approach does not require explicit formal specifications of the desired behavior. Instead, it relies on "semantic anchors" (interface functions) to relate observations between the source and target systems.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses simulated systems for its case studies. These systems are described by their mathematical models, which are used for simulation purposes but not directly for training the neural networks. The authors mention using the SCOTS tool for designing controllers for the source systems in some experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Neuro-Symbolic Divide: The work effectively combines the scalability of neural networks with the formal guarantees of symbolic methods, a long-standing goal in control theory.
  • Data-Driven Formal Guarantees: The core insight is that formal guarantees can be learned from data by parameterizing simulation relations with neural networks and establishing validity conditions. This bypasses the need for explicit system models.
  • Probabilistic Observational Equivalence: The concept of stochastic simulation relations provides a powerful mathematical framework for ensuring that two systems behave similarly in a probabilistic sense, even with inherent randomness.
  • Transferring Controllers Without Specifications: The ability to transfer controllers without explicit formal specifications is a significant practical advantage, especially for complex or legacy systems.
  • Infinite Horizon Guarantees: The framework provides probabilistic guarantees over an infinite time horizon, which is crucial for many control applications.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of its approach through four case studies:

  • Vehicle Control Transfer (1D to 2D): Successfully transferred a controller from a 1D to a 2D vehicle model, achieving a probabilistic guarantee of output closeness with 99% confidence.
  • Vehicle Control Transfer (3D to 5D): Transferred control from a 3D unicycle model to a 5D car model. This case highlights the scalability of the approach to higher dimensions where traditional methods (like SCOTS) become infeasible. The results showed good empirical evidence of correctness.
  • Pendulum Control (Single-Jointed to Double-Jointed): Demonstrated transfer from a simpler inverted pendulum to a more complex double-jointed pendulum, achieving probabilistic guarantees.
  • Marine Vessel Control (3D to 6D): Transferred control for a marine vessel from a kinematic model to a full six-dimensional dynamic model. This case emphasizes the approach's utility for high-dimensional systems where formal guarantees are challenging to obtain.

In all cases, the method achieved probabilistic guarantees on output closeness, aligning well with theoretical predictions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lipschitz Continuity Assumption: The method relies on the assumption that the system dynamics and learned neural networks are Lipschitz continuous. While this is a common assumption in control theory, it might not hold for all systems.
  • Sample Complexity: While the approach is data-driven, the sample complexity for training the neural networks can still be a factor, especially for very high-dimensional or complex systems.
  • User-Defined Parameters: The approach involves several user-defined parameters (e.g., robustness parameters $\eta, \delta$, discretization parameters $\epsilon, \hat{\epsilon}$). Tuning these parameters can influence performance.

The authors suggest future work could focus on:

  • Reducing Sample Complexity: Leveraging structural properties of systems, such as monotonicity or mixed-monotonicity, to potentially reduce the amount of data needed for training.
  • Extending to Other System Types: Applying the framework to other classes of systems, such as continuous-time systems or systems with different types of noise.
  • More Complex Specifications: Exploring how to incorporate more complex temporal logic specifications into the transfer process.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper explores a neurosymbolic approach to probabilistic transfer of control logic from a source stochastic control system to a target system while ensuring approximately equivalent behavioral guarantees in both domains. Traditional methods struggle with this problem due to the absence of a complete characterization of behavioral specifications, which prevents a direct formulation in terms of loss functions. To address this challenge, we leverage the concept of stochastic simulation relations to establish probabilistic observational equivalence between the behaviors of two (black-box) stochastic systems. These functions ensure that the outputs of both systems, equipped with their respective controllers, remain probabilistically close over time. By parameterizing stochastic simulation functions with neural networks, we introduce the notion of stochastic neural simulation functions, enabling a data-driven mechanism to transfer any synthesized controller—along with its proof of correctness—without requiring explicit specification of behavioral constraints. This neurosymbolic integration combines the scalability of neural methods with the formal guarantees of symbolic approaches, bridging the gap between learning-based control synthesis and formal verification. Compared to prior methods, our approach eliminates the need for a closed-loop mathematical model and explicit requirement specifications for both the source and target systems, while providing probabilistic guarantees over an infinite horizon. We also introduce validity conditions that, when satisfied, ensure the closeness of the outputs of two systems equipped with their corresponding controllers, removing the need for post-facto verification. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach through four case studies, highlighting its potential to advance scalable, formally grounded, and transferable control synthesis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nadali2025stochastic,
  author = {Alireza Nadali and Ashutosh Trivedi and Majid Zamani},
  title = {{Stochastic Neural Simulation Relations for Control Transfer}},
  booktitle = {NeuS},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=WEXJ9napk7},
}
Figure