Stochastic Inertial Dynamics Via Time Scaling and Averaging

Rodrigo Maulen-Soto, Jalal Fadili, Hédy Attouch, Peter OchsarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper provides a unified mathematical framework for analyzing stochastic "accelerated" optimization algorithms by viewing them as continuous-time dynamical systems. By applying a clever "time scaling and averaging" technique, the authors prove that these second-order inertial systems can achieve fast convergence rates ($o(1/t^2)$) and almost sure convergence to minimizers, even when dealing with non-smooth objective functions and stochastic noise.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of optimization, there is a deep connection between continuous-time differential equations and the discrete algorithms we run on computers (like SGD). First-order systems (gradient flow) are well-understood, but second-order "inertial" systems—which model accelerated methods like Nesterov’s—are much harder to analyze, especially when you add two complicating factors:

  1. Stochasticity: The gradients are noisy (common in machine learning).
  2. Non-smoothness: The objective function might have "kinks" (like L1 regularization), requiring the use of subgradients rather than standard gradients.

Existing proofs for these stochastic inertial systems are often bespoke and mathematically grueling. The authors sought a systematic way to "transfer" the well-established convergence properties of simpler first-order stochastic equations to these complex second-order ones.

Methods

The authors utilize two primary mathematical "pillars" to bridge the gap between first-order and second-order dynamics:

  • Time Scaling and Averaging: This is the core novelty. Instead of analyzing the second-order system directly, they show it can be viewed as a time-scaled version of a first-order system where the position is an "average" of past states. This allows them to inherit convergence results from first-order theory.
  • Stochastic Differential Inclusions (SDI): To handle non-smooth functions, they use differential inclusions (where the derivative belongs to a set of possible subgradients) rather than standard equations.
  • Implicit Hessian-driven Damping: They focus on a specific type of damping that accounts for the "curvature" (Hessian) of the function. Crucially, they use an implicit form because the explicit form would require differentiating stochastic noise—a mathematical impossibility since Brownian motion is nowhere differentiable.
  • Tikhonov Regularization: They incorporate a vanishing regularization term to force the algorithm to converge not just to any minimizer, but to the one with the minimum norm.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical work focused on proving mathematical convergence properties and rates; it does not include empirical benchmarks on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Transfer" Principle: The most significant "aha moment" is that you don't need to reinvent the wheel for second-order systems. If you can prove a property for a first-order stochastic gradient flow, the time-scaling and averaging framework provides a recipe to move that result to an accelerated inertial system.
  • Damping Roles: The research reveals that viscous damping (the friction term) is the primary lever for controlling noise sensitivity. In contrast, geometric damping (Hessian-driven) helps reduce oscillations but doesn't directly impose stricter requirements on the noise level.
  • Overcoming Martingale Non-Differentiability: By choosing the "implicit" version of Hessian damping, the authors bypassed the classic roadblock where stochastic noise (modeled as an Itô martingale) cannot be differentiated to calculate damping terms.
  • Local Linear Convergence: They successfully established local linear convergence rates under the Polyak-Łojasiewicz (PŁ) inequality, which is notoriously difficult to achieve for second-order stochastic systems.

Key Results

  • Fast Convergence: For a standard accelerated setup ($\alpha > 3$), the objective value converges at a rate of $o(1/t^2)$ almost surely.
  • Weak Convergence: The authors prove that the trajectory of the system weakly converges to a minimizer of the objective function almost surely.
  • Strong Convergence: By tuning a Tikhonov regularization parameter, they ensure the trajectory converges strongly to the minimum-norm solution.
  • Complexity Analysis: The paper provides a comprehensive set of convergence rates in expectation for various geometries, including convex, strongly convex, and PŁ cases.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Convexity Dependency: The "averaging" proof strategy relies heavily on Jensen’s inequality, which essentially mandates that the objective function be convex. Extending these specific results to non-convex landscapes remains a challenge.
  • Discretization Gap: While the authors argue that these SDEs are excellent models for algorithms like SGD, there is always a "discretization gap" when moving from continuous time to discrete steps. Future work could further tighten the bounds on this transition.
  • Non-Potential Operators: The authors suggest extending this framework to situations where the "drift" isn't just a gradient of a function, but a more general "non-potential co-coercive operator," which would have applications in game theory and equilibrium problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our work is part of the close link between continuous-time dissipative dynamical systems and optimization algorithms, and more precisely here, in the stochastic setting. We aim to study stochastic convex minimization problems through the lens of stochastic inertial differential inclusions that are driven by the subgradient of a convex objective function. This will provide a general mathematical framework for analyzing the convergence properties of stochastic second-order inertial continuous-time dynamics involving vanishing viscous damping and measurable stochastic subgradient selections. Our chief goal in this paper is to develop a systematic and unified way that transfers the properties recently studied for first-order stochastic differential equations to second-order ones involving even subgradients in lieu of gradients. This program will rely on two tenets: time scaling and averaging, following an approach recently developed in the literature by one of the co-authors in the deterministic case. Under a mild integrability assumption involving the diffusion term and the viscous damping, our first main result shows that almost surely, there is weak convergence of the trajectory towards a minimizer of the objective function and fast convergence of the values and gradients. We also provide a comprehensive complexity analysis by establishing several new pointwise and ergodic convergence rates in expectation for the convex, strongly convex, and (local) Polyak-Lojasiewicz case. Finally, using Tikhonov regularization with a properly tuned vanishing parameter, we can obtain almost sure strong convergence of the trajectory towards the minimum norm solution.
BibTeX
@misc{maulensoto2024stochastic,
  author = {Rodrigo Maulen-Soto and Jalal Fadili and Hédy Attouch and Peter Ochs},
  title = {{Stochastic Inertial Dynamics Via Time Scaling and Averaging}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2403.16775},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16775},
}
Figure