Stochastic Goal Recognition Design

Christabel WayllaceAAAI 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Goal Recognition Design (GRD) is a proactive framework for modifying environments to force agents to reveal their intentions as early as possible. While traditional goal recognition focuses on passive observation, GRD allows for offline environmental changes—such as blocking specific paths—to minimize ambiguity. However, early GRD models relied on idealized assumptions: optimal agent behavior, deterministic actions, and full observability. This work extends the GRD framework to address real-world complexities, including stochastic action outcomes, partial observability, and limited sensor resolution.

Methods and Generalizations

The research introduces several key generalizations to transition GRD from theoretical models to practical applications. These advancements move the field toward handling the "messiness" of real-world environments where actions may fail and sensors are imperfect.

  • Stochastic GRD (S-GRD): Environments are modeled as Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) where actions have probabilistic outcomes, accounting for failures or "slips."
  • Partial Observability (POS-GRD): The framework is extended to scenarios where state information is incomplete, modeled via sensor partitions of the state space (e.g., low-resolution GPS data).
  • New Efficacy Metrics: Beyond the traditional Worst Case Distinctiveness ($wcd$), which measures the maximum steps before a goal is revealed, this work introduces Expected Case Distinctiveness ($ecd$). This metric provides a probabilistic average, offering a more realistic assessment for risk management.
  • Sensor Refinement: A novel design intervention where, instead of removing actions, the designer improves sensor precision in critical areas to resolve ambiguity.
Summary of GRD generalizations and contributions across literature, highlighting the shift toward stochastic actions and expected case metrics.

Key Insights

A fundamental shift in this research is the move from pessimism to probability. By replacing the pessimistic $wcd$ with the probabilistic $ecd$, the framework becomes better suited for real-world environments where absolute certainty is rare. Furthermore, treating environment design as sensor placement allows for more flexible interventions in domains like logistics or border security, where physical barriers may be impractical but improved monitoring is feasible. In partially observable environments, the computation becomes more complex as the set of possible goals depends on the entire history of observed states.

Results and Applications

The framework was evaluated using a realistic cybersecurity problem generator, simulating deceptive agents in complex network environments. Key milestones include:

  • Generalization to stochastic outcomes (Wayllace et al. 2016).
  • Implementation of the $ecd$ metric for practical efficacy measurement (Wayllace et al. 2017).
  • Addressing the "GPS resolution" problem in partially observable environments.
  • Developing pruning techniques to optimize sensor placement computationally, making the search space manageable.

Future Directions

Future work aims to address suboptimal and intentionally deceptive agents, explore entropy-based metrics for ambiguity, and scale the framework to larger, multi-start environments. A primary application remains cybersecurity, where strategic network design (e.g., honeypots or specific logging) can expose intruders' targets prematurely.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wayllace2019stochastic,
  author = {Christabel Wayllace},
  title = {{Stochastic Goal Recognition Design}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v33i01.33019904},
}
Figure