TL;DR
This paper introduces the first theoretical convergence rates for adaptive quadrature methods in Bayesian inference, specifically for approximating normalizing constants, posterior densities, and summary statistics. This work provides a rigorous foundation for using adaptive quadrature, like Adaptive Gauss-Hermite Quadrature (AGHQ), in complex Bayesian models, demonstrating its efficiency and accuracy compared to traditional MCMC methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Bayesian inference hinges on computing posterior distributions, which often involves intractable integrals. Numerical quadrature offers a way to approximate these integrals, but standard methods struggle when the integrand (the posterior) changes significantly with data. Adaptive quadrature techniques, which adjust to the shape of the integrand, have been used in practice but lacked theoretical guarantees on their convergence rates, especially in a stochastic setting where data influences the integrand's behavior. This paper bridges that gap by providing the first stochastic convergence rates for adaptive quadrature in Bayesian inference, offering a theoretical basis for its practical success.
Methods
The core contribution is the derivation of stochastic convergence rates for adaptive quadrature rules that satisfy a specific property, P(k,p), which essentially means they can exactly integrate Gaussian densities multiplied by polynomials up to a certain degree. The authors prove that for such rules, the relative error in approximating the posterior normalizing constant converges at a rate of $O(n^{-[(k+2)/3]})$, where $n$ is the sample size and $k$ is a parameter of the quadrature rule. This rate is then shown to extend to approximations of posterior densities, moments, and quantiles. The paper also details the implementation of these methods using Adaptive Gauss-Hermite Quadrature (AGHQ), a specific adaptive quadrature rule, and its application within a broader framework for high-dimensional models.
Datasets
The paper uses two real-world datasets for demonstrating the methods:
- Infectious Disease Spread Data: Data on the spread of an infectious disease in West Africa.
- Milky Way Galaxy Data: Astronomical data on star cluster positions and velocities used for estimating the Galaxy's mass.
- Zero-Inflated Geostatistical Binomial Regression Data: Data from Nigeria and Cameroon on tropical disease prevalence in villages.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Theoretical Guarantees for Adaptive Quadrature: The paper provides the first rigorous, stochastic convergence rates for adaptive quadrature in Bayesian inference, moving beyond empirical observations.
- AGHQ as a Powerful Tool: AGHQ is shown to be a computationally efficient and accurate method for approximating key Bayesian quantities, often outperforming MCMC in terms of speed.
- Bridging Low and High Dimensions: The work demonstrates how adaptive quadrature can be a fundamental component in both low-dimensional and complex high-dimensional Bayesian models.
- The
aghqR Package: The practical utility of the methods is underscored by the release of an R package, making these advanced techniques accessible to practitioners.
Key Results
- Convergence Rates: The paper establishes a convergence rate of $O(n^{-[(k+2)/3]})$ for the relative error of approximating the posterior normalizing constant using adaptive quadrature rules satisfying P(k,p). This rate is preserved for approximate posterior densities, moments, and quantiles.
- Computational Efficiency: In the infectious disease example, AGHQ achieved results comparable to MCMC in a fraction of the computational time. For the zero-inflated geostatistical model, AGHQ provided a complete and accurate solution in minutes, while MCMC struggled to converge or produced incomplete results even after days of computation.
- Accuracy: The AGHQ approximations were visually and numerically indistinguishable from MCMC results in several examples, with slight disagreements in tails for some parameters, which is crucial for accurate uncertainty quantification.
Limitations and Future Work
- Finite Sample Guarantees: The theoretical guarantees are asymptotic (as the sample size $n \to \infty$). Providing finite-sample guarantees that adapt to model properties like smoothness and sparsity is an open problem.
- Choice of $k$: A principled method for choosing the quadrature parameter $k$ for a given application is still an open question.
- High-Dimensional Guarantees: Full theoretical guarantees for the high-dimensional approximation method (using Gaussian approximation and AGHQ with reused points) are still needed.
- Quantiles and Credible Sets: While the paper shows the rate is preserved for quantiles and credible sets in ideal cases, robust computational methods with theoretical guarantees are still being developed.
- Computational Feasibility in Very High Dimensions: Developing methods with comparable accuracy to AGHQ but that are computationally feasible in very high dimensions remains a challenge.
Summary updated