Stimulus-specific regulation of visual oddball differentiation in posterior parietal cortex

Zhe Zhou, Wei Angel Huang, Yiyi Yu, Ehsan Negahbani, Iain Stitt, Morgan L. Alexander, Jordan P. Hamm, Hiroyuki Kato, Flavio FrӧhlichScientific 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the brain's posterior parietal cortex (PPC) processes stimuli based on their presentation frequency, specifically using a visual oddball paradigm. They found that individual neurons in the PPC differentiate between frequent and rare visual stimuli, but this differentiation is stimulus-specific, favoring stimuli that the neuron is already tuned to. This response is primarily driven by adaptation to repeated stimuli.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain needs to efficiently process incoming sensory information, and a key aspect of this is understanding how often a stimulus appears. Repeated stimuli are often less important than novel or unexpected ones. This ability to differentiate based on frequency, known as the "oddball effect" or "mismatch negativity" (MMN), is crucial for behavioral flexibility and is thought to be mediated by higher-order brain areas like the posterior parietal cortex (PPC). However, the precise neural mechanisms at the single-neuron level within the PPC for this process, especially how stimulus selectivity interacts with frequency processing, remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining how individual PPC neurons respond to visual stimuli presented at different frequencies, considering the neurons' own tuning properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining electrophysiology and 2-photon calcium imaging in head-fixed ferrets.

  • Electrophysiology: They recorded local field potentials (LFPs) and multi-unit activity (MUA) from the PPC. This allowed them to measure the overall neural response and identify patterns like the mismatch negativity (MMN) in the electrical signals. They also analyzed spectral decomposition of the LFP to look for changes in oscillatory activity, particularly in the gamma frequency band.
  • 2-Photon Calcium Imaging: This technique allowed them to visualize the activity of individual neurons (or regions of interest, ROIs) in real-time. By genetically engineering neurons to express a calcium indicator (GCaMP6f), they could track neuronal firing based on calcium influx. This provided a much higher spatial resolution than electrophysiology, enabling the study of individual neuronal responses.
  • Visual Oddball Paradigm: A standard paradigm was used where a "standard" stimulus (presented frequently, 90% of trials) and a "deviant" stimulus (presented rarely, 10% of trials) were interleaved. A "control" condition was also included, where a rare stimulus was presented without a history of repetition, to distinguish between novelty detection and adaptation. The stimuli were drifting gratings, and the researchers first characterized each neuron's preferred direction of motion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved experiments conducted by the researchers, not the use of pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stimulus-Specific MMN in PPC: The most striking finding is that the mismatch response (MMR) in the PPC is not uniform. It's significantly stronger for stimuli that the individual neuron is already tuned to (preferred stimulus) compared to stimuli it's less responsive to (opponent stimulus). This suggests that the PPC doesn't just detect any oddball, but rather prioritizes oddballs that are behaviorally relevant to its current processing.
  • Adaptation as the Primary Driver: While deviance detection (responding to novelty) is a component, the study strongly suggests that stimulus-specific adaptation (SSA) plays a dominant role in shaping the MMR. Neurons adapt to repeated stimuli, leading to a reduced response, and this adaptation is more pronounced for the preferred stimulus in the standard condition.
  • Gamma Band Oscillations and MMN: Electrophysiological analysis revealed that the MMN in the gamma frequency band (25-50 Hz) was also stimulus-specific, occurring only for the preferred stimulus. This links oscillatory activity to the observed single-neuron responses.
  • PPC's Role in Frequency-Dependent Processing: The findings reinforce the idea that the PPC is a critical hub for integrating sensory history and current input, enabling the brain to interpret stimuli based on their context and frequency.

Key Results

  • Electrophysiology: Significant MMN was observed in the PPC for the preferred stimulus in the deviant condition compared to the standard condition (150-250 ms epoch). This was not found for the opponent stimulus. Gamma band power was also higher for the deviant preferred stimulus.
  • Calcium Imaging: Individual neurons (ROIs) showed stimulus-specific MMR, with stronger responses to the preferred stimulus in the deviant condition. This MMR was primarily driven by stimulus-specific adaptation (SSA), where responses to the standard stimulus were significantly reduced.
  • Correlation with Tuning: The magnitude of the MMR for the preferred stimulus correlated positively with the neuron's control condition activity and its stimulus preference, indicating that neurons with stronger baseline responses to the preferred stimulus also exhibited stronger MMRs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Passive Viewing: The study used a passive visual oddball paradigm. Future work could incorporate behavioral tasks to understand how active engagement and decision-making influence these responses.
  • Stimulus Properties: The study focused on motion direction. Future research could explore how other stimulus features, like orientation, interact with frequency processing in the PPC.
  • GCaMP6s: The authors note that using GCaMP6s, which has better signal-to-noise ratio, might reveal additional responsive neurons.
  • Topographical Organization: The study hints at a topographical organization of stimulus preference within the PPC, suggesting that different spatial patches might process different stimulus directions. Further investigation across a larger area of PPC is needed to confirm this.
  • Deviance Detection (DD): While SSA was prominent, the evidence for pure deviance detection (MMR vs. control) was less clear. Future studies could further explore this aspect, especially the potential for suppressed responses in the deviant condition for the opponent stimulus.

Summary updated

Abstract

The frequency at which a stimulus is presented determines how it is interpreted. For example, a repeated image may be of less interest than an image that violates the prior sequence. This process involves integration of sensory information and internal representations of stimulus history, functions carried out in higher-order sensory areas such as the posterior parietal cortex (PPC). Thus far, there are few detailed reports investigating the single-neuron mechanisms for processing of stimulus presentation frequency in PPC. To address this gap in knowledge, we recorded PPC activity using 2-photon calcium imaging and electrophysiology during a visual oddball paradigm. Calcium imaging results reveal differentiation at the level of single neurons for frequent versus rare conditions which varied depending on whether the stimulus was preferred or non-preferred by the recorded neural population. Such differentiation of oddball conditions was mediated primarily by stimulus-independent adaptation in the frequent condition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2020stimulus,
  author = {Zhe Zhou and Wei Angel Huang and Yiyi Yu and Ehsan Negahbani and Iain Stitt and Morgan L. Alexander and Jordan P. Hamm and Hiroyuki Kato and Flavio Frӧhlich},
  title = {{Stimulus-specific regulation of visual oddball differentiation in posterior parietal cortex}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-70448-6},
}
Figure