Stimulus Dependence of Neuronal Correlation in Primary Visual Cortex of the Macaque

Adam Kohn, Matthew A. SmithJournal of Neuroscience 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that neuronal correlations in the primary visual cortex (V1) arise from two distinct mechanisms: one tied to stimulus orientation for precise, rapid synchrony, and another, contrast-sensitive mechanism driving slower, broader correlations. Understanding these distinct sources is crucial for deciphering how neural populations encode information and how noise affects perception.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain's ability to process information relies on the coordinated activity of many neurons. However, the responses of individual neurons aren't perfectly reliable; they exhibit trial-to-trial variability. This variability can be correlated between nearby neurons, meaning their responses tend to fluctuate together. These correlations, whether in the precise timing of spikes (synchrony) or in the overall spike count (noise correlation), are thought to stem from shared synaptic input. However, the precise origin and nature of this shared input, and how it's influenced by sensory stimuli, remained unclear. Specifically, researchers wanted to know if these different forms of correlation were affected by stimulus properties like orientation and contrast, and if so, how. This is important because if correlations are stimulus-dependent, they could play a role in how the brain represents sensory information, or conversely, they could be a source of noise that hinders accurate perception.

Methods

The researchers recorded the electrical activity of pairs of single neurons in the primary visual cortex (V1) of anesthetized macaque monkeys. They employed two main types of analysis:

  • Spike Count Correlation ($r_{sc}$): This measures the correlation between the number of spikes a neuron fires over a given period in response to repeated presentations of the same stimulus. They used the Pearson correlation coefficient.
  • Spike Timing Correlation (Cross-Correlogram, CCG): This analyzes the precise timing of spikes between two neurons. A peak in the CCG around zero time lag indicates synchronous firing, suggesting shared input. They developed a normalized CCG to quantify synchrony and its temporal characteristics.

To investigate stimulus dependence, they presented stimuli with varying:

  • Orientation: They tested gratings at different orientations to see how recruiting different neuronal populations affected correlation.
  • Contrast: They varied the contrast of gratings to probe the influence of sensory drive versus ongoing cortical activity.

They also analyzed spontaneous activity (when no stimulus was presented) to understand the baseline level of correlation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved recordings from 12 anesthetized macaque monkeys.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Nature of Correlation: The most significant finding is that neuronal correlation isn't a single phenomenon but arises from at least two distinct mechanisms operating on different timescales and with different stimulus sensitivities.
  • Orientation-Tuned Synchrony: Temporally precise synchrony (sharp peaks in the CCG) is strongly influenced by stimulus orientation. Neurons synchronize more when presented with stimuli that effectively drive both of them, suggesting this synchrony is linked to orientation-specific input pathways.
  • Contrast-Sensitive, Slow Correlation: Correlated response variability on longer timescales (reflected in the integrated CCG, $r_{ccg}$) is less dependent on orientation but is significantly affected by stimulus contrast. Lower contrast leads to broader, more sustained correlations, while high contrast suppresses them.
  • Spontaneous Activity as a Baseline: Spontaneous activity exhibits strong, broad correlations, suggesting that ongoing cortical activity provides a significant source of shared input even without effective sensory drive. High-contrast stimuli can disrupt this spontaneous synchrony.
  • Receptive Field Similarity Matters: Neurons with more similar receptive field properties (orientation, spatial frequency, etc.) tend to have stronger correlations, supporting the idea that common input is a key driver of these relationships.

Key Results

  • Orientation and Synchrony: CCG peak height (a measure of synchrony) was significantly higher for orientations that drove both neurons well compared to those that drove them poorly. Peak width, however, was largely unaffected by orientation.
  • Contrast and Correlation: Lowering stimulus contrast led to an increase in spike count correlation ($r_{sc}$) and a broadening of the CCG peak, indicating more sustained, less precise synchrony. High contrast reduced $r_{sc}$ and sharpened synchrony.
  • Timescale of Correlation: For effective orientations, the time scale of correlation ($r_{ccg}$) was shorter (tens of milliseconds), allowing for faster encoding of stimuli. For less effective orientations or low contrast, the correlation extended over longer timescales.
  • Spontaneous Activity: Mean $r_{sc}$ during spontaneous activity was high (0.29 ± 0.04), and spontaneous CCGs were consistently broader than those evoked by high-contrast stimuli.
  • Receptive Field Similarity: A weak but significant positive relationship was found between signal correlation (similarity in tuning) and spike count correlation ($r_{sc}$) ($r = 0.27$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Anesthesia: The study was conducted in anesthetized monkeys. While this allows for stable recordings, it might alter neuronal dynamics compared to awake, behaving animals. The authors acknowledge that spontaneous activity might be influenced by anesthesia but present evidence suggesting the broad CCGs are not solely an artifact.
  • Stimulus Set: The study primarily used gratings. Future work could explore how other stimulus types (e.g., natural images, complex objects) affect these correlations.
  • Single Electrode Limitation: For pairs recorded on the same electrode, it was difficult to detect simultaneous or near-simultaneous spiking, potentially affecting CCG peak width calculations in those specific cases.
  • Model Constraints: The authors note that their findings are not entirely consistent with some existing models of V1 circuitry (e.g., strictly feedforward models or specific implementations of recurrent models), suggesting the need for more complex models that incorporate realistic recurrent connectivity and spontaneous activity.
  • Functional Implications: While the study identifies distinct sources of correlation, its direct impact on perception and behavior requires further investigation. The authors suggest that understanding how downstream areas read out these stimulus-dependent correlations is a key future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nearby cortical neurons often have correlated trial-to-trial response variability, and a significant fraction of their spikes occur synchronously. These two forms of correlation are both believed to arise from common synaptic input, but the origin of this input is unclear. We investigated the source of correlated responsivity by recording from pairs of single neurons in primary visual cortex of anesthetized macaque monkeys and comparing correlated variability and synchrony for spontaneous activity and activity evoked by stimuli of different orientations and contrasts. These two stimulus manipulations would be expected to have different effects on the cortical pool providing input to the recorded pair: changing stimulus orientation should recruit different populations of cells, whereas changing stimulus contrast affects primarily the relative strength of sensory drive and ongoing cortical activity. Consistent with this predicted difference, we found that correlation was affected by these stimulus manipulations in different ways. Synchrony was significantly stronger for orientations that drove both neurons well than for those that did not, but correlation on longer time scales was orientation independent. Reducing stimulus contrast resulted in a decrease in the temporal precision of synchronous firing and an enhancement of correlated response variability on longer time scales. Our results thus suggest that correlated responsivity arises from mechanisms operating at two distinct timescales: one that is orientation tuned and that determines the strength of temporally precise synchrony, and a second that is contrast sensitive, of low temporal frequency, and present in ongoing cortical activity.
BibTeX
@article{kohn2005stimulus,
  author = {Adam Kohn and Matthew A. Smith},
  title = {{Stimulus Dependence of Neuronal Correlation in Primary Visual Cortex of the Macaque}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.5106-04.2005},
}
Figure