Stimulating the medial prefrontal cortex disrupts inhibitory control over memory by modulating frontal and parietal brain regions

Ahsan Khan, Chun Hang Eden Ti, Kai Yuan, Maité Crespo‐García, Michael C. Anderson, Raymond Kai‐Yu TongbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study used transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) to investigate the role of the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) in retrieval-induced forgetting (RIF). They found that stimulating the mPFC reduced RIF, suggesting it disrupts the brain's ability to actively suppress competing memories. This disruption was linked to changes in beta-band activity in the prefrontal and parietal cortices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When we recall a specific memory, it can paradoxically lead to forgetting other related memories. This phenomenon is called retrieval-induced forgetting (RIF). Researchers believe that RIF is mediated by inhibitory control mechanisms in the brain, particularly in the prefrontal cortex. However, the precise neural mechanisms and causal role of specific brain regions, like the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC), in this process are not fully understood. This study aims to clarify the causal involvement of the mPFC in inhibitory control during memory retrieval and its impact on RIF.

Methods

The researchers employed a randomized controlled trial design with 50 participants. They used high-definition transcranial direct current stimulation (HD-tDCS) to stimulate the mPFC with an anodal (excitatory) protocol for 15 minutes. Participants were then subjected to a retrieval practice phase, where they repeatedly recalled specific "target" memories. Brain activity was monitored using electroencephalography (EEG) throughout the retrieval practice. Finally, a test phase assessed memory recall for both practiced (target) and unpracticed (non-target) memories to measure RIF.

Key techniques included:

  • HD-tDCS: A non-invasive brain stimulation technique used to modulate neural activity in specific brain regions.
  • RIF Paradigm: A standard experimental setup to induce and measure retrieval-induced forgetting.
  • EEG: Used to record brain activity (specifically time-frequency representations of neural oscillations) during memory retrieval.
  • Source Localization: Applied to EEG data to pinpoint the brain regions generating the observed electrical activity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used participant data collected during the experiment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • mPFC is causally involved in inhibitory control for memory: The study provides strong evidence that stimulating the mPFC directly impacts the brain's ability to suppress competing memories. This moves beyond correlational findings to establish a causal link.
  • RIF and memory facilitation are independent: The results support the inhibitory model of RIF, which posits that forgetting (RIF) and strengthening of retrieved memories (facilitation, FAC) are separate processes, not directly tied to each other.
  • Beta-band activity as a marker of disrupted inhibition: The observed changes in beta-band desynchronization in the left-DLPFC and parietal cortex appear to be reliable neural signatures of disrupted inhibitory control during memory retrieval.
  • Timing matters for inhibitory control: The early beta desynchronization in the left-DLPFC, occurring shortly after the retrieval cue, is particularly linked to the disruption of inhibitory control, suggesting that inhibition is an early process in memory retrieval.

Key Results

  • Reduced RIF: Participants who received mPFC stimulation showed significantly less RIF, meaning they were better at recalling non-target memories after retrieval practice compared to the sham group. Specifically, recall for non-target items (RP- items) was higher in the stimulated group (62.33%) than the sham group (57.33%).
  • No effect on Memory Facilitation (FAC): Stimulation did not affect the recall of practiced target memories (RP+ items), indicating that the effect was specific to inhibitory control and not general memory enhancement.
  • Beta Desynchronization in Left-DLPFC: An early (0.24-0.32 sec) and significant beta desynchronization (15-17Hz) was observed in the left-DLPFC in the stimulation group compared to the sham group. This early beta desynchronization positively correlated with reduced RIF in the stimulation group.
  • Parietal Beta Desynchronization: A later, sustained beta desynchronization was observed in the parietal cortex (precuneus) in the stimulation group, which was correlated with the early left-DLPFC effect, suggesting network-level modulation.
  • Flanker Task Performance: The stimulation group also showed a marginally significant trend towards a larger "flanker effect" in a distractor task, suggesting that mPFC stimulation might impair general inhibitory control beyond memory tasks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theta Band Activity: The study did not find significant effects of stimulation on theta band activity, which has previously been linked to conflict reduction during memory retrieval. The authors suggest this might be due to the overpowering effect of beta band activity or that the disruption of inhibitory control in this study is mediated by other neural processes.
  • Generalizability of Findings: While the study focused on the mPFC, future research could explore the roles of other prefrontal regions and their interactions with parietal areas.
  • Timing of Stimulation: The study used "offline" stimulation (before retrieval practice). Future work could investigate the effects of "online" stimulation (during retrieval practice) to further understand the temporal dynamics of inhibitory control.
  • Individual Differences: The correlation between left-DLPFC beta desynchronization and RIF was significant in the stimulation group but not the sham group. This highlights the importance of individual differences and how stimulation might interact with existing neural mechanisms.
  • Network-Level Effects: The observed parietal effects suggest network-level modulation. Future studies could employ more advanced network analysis techniques to better understand these interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary The act of recalling memories can paradoxically lead to the forgetting of other associated memories, a phenomenon known as retrieval-induced forgetting (RIF). This effect is thought to be mediated by inhibitory control mechanisms in the prefrontal cortex of the brain. Here we investigated whether stimulation of the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) with transcranial direct current stimulation modulates inhibitory control during memory retrieval in a RIF paradigm. In a randomized study, fifty participants received either real or sham stimulation, before performing retrieval practice on target memories. After retrieval practice, a final test was administered to measure the impact of stimulation on RIF. We found that stimulation selectively increased the retrieval accuracy of non-target memories and thus decreased RIF, suggesting a disruption of inhibitory control. Meanwhile, no change arose for the retrieval accuracy of target memories. The reduction in RIF was caused by a more pronounced beta desynchronization within the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (left-DLPFC), in an early time window (<500 msec) after the onset of the cue during retrieval practice. This, in turn, led to a stronger beta desynchronization within the parietal cortex in a later time window, an established marker for successful memory retrieval. Together, our results establish the causal involvement of the mPFC in actively suppressing competing memories and we demonstrate that while forgetting arises as a consequence of retrieving specific memories, these two processes are functionally independent. Finally, we demonstrate that beta desynchronization in the fronto-parietal brain regions indicates the disruption of inhibitory control.
BibTeX
@misc{khan2024stimulating,
  author = {Ahsan Khan and Chun Hang Eden Ti and Kai Yuan and Maité Crespo‐García and Michael C. Anderson and Raymond Kai‐Yu Tong},
  title = {{Stimulating the medial prefrontal cortex disrupts inhibitory control over memory by modulating frontal and parietal brain regions}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.01.30.577598},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure