Stereo Particle Image Velocimetry Measurement of the Flow around SUBOFF Submarine under Yaw Conditions

Mo Chen, Nan Zhang, Ziyan Li, Junliang Liu, Lan Yu, Wentao Zheng, Xuan ZhangJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses stereo particle image velocimetry (SPIV) to meticulously map the complex flow fields around a SUBOFF submarine model at different yaw angles (6° and 9°) and Reynolds numbers. The findings provide crucial experimental data on the sail-tip vortex and hull-sail junction wake, offering a valuable benchmark for improving submarine flow simulations and understanding stealth characteristics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Submarines maneuvering at yaw angles generate intricate flow patterns, particularly around the sail and hull-sail junction. These complex flows can lead to increased flow-induced vibrations, noise, and significantly impact a submarine's stealth capabilities. While numerical simulations are powerful tools, accurately capturing these phenomena, especially flow separation and vortex dynamics, remains a challenge. Existing experimental data, particularly at higher Reynolds numbers and for specific maneuvering conditions like yaw, is limited. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing detailed, high-resolution experimental measurements of the flow field around a standard SUBOFF model under yaw conditions, thereby enhancing the validation database for computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models.

Methods

The researchers employed a Stereo Particle Image Velocimetry (SPIV) system to capture the three-dimensional velocity field. This technique involves seeding the flow with tiny oil droplets and illuminating them with a laser sheet. Two cameras, positioned at an angle to each other, record the particle movement from different perspectives. By analyzing the particle displacement in stereo, the system reconstructs the velocity vectors in a 2D plane.

The SPIV data processing involved:

  • Adaptive PIV technology: This algorithm adjusts the size of interrogation windows to optimize correlation peak detection, improving accuracy.
  • Two-dimensional fast Fourier transform (FFT): Used for accelerating correlation peak calculations.
  • Gaussian subpixel function: Enhances the precision of particle displacement determination.
  • Vector validation and replacement: Miscalculated vectors are identified and replaced using median filtering.
  • Calibration: A calibration function derived from calibration images is used to reconstruct the 3D velocity vector field from the 2D camera data.

The experiments were conducted in a large low-speed wind tunnel at the China Ship Scientific Research Center (CSSRC).

Datasets

This paper introduces a new experimental dataset of flow fields around the SUBOFF submarine model under specific yaw conditions and Reynolds numbers. The data consists of ensemble-averaged velocity and vorticity fields captured at two measurement planes along the hull (x/L = 0.595 and x/L = 0.818). This dataset is intended to serve as a benchmark for validating and improving numerical simulations of submarine wakes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Yaw angle significantly amplifies wake complexity: Increasing the yaw angle from 6° to 9° leads to a more pronounced sail-tip vortex, stronger vorticity, and higher turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) in the wake.
  • Downwash is a key characteristic of the sail-tip vortex: Under yaw conditions, the sail-tip vortex exhibits a noticeable downwash as it evolves downstream. This downwash becomes more significant with increasing yaw angle and Reynolds number.
  • Reynolds number has a subtle but measurable effect: While the overall flow patterns are similar across the tested Reynolds numbers (0.46 × 10⁷ and 1.08 × 10⁷), a higher Reynolds number results in a more pronounced downwash of the sail-tip vortex center and a slight deviation towards the suction side.
  • Asymmetric flow structures are prevalent: The lateral and vertical velocity distributions around the sail-tip vortex center are asymmetric, with distinct positive and negative values on the windward/leeward and upper/lower sides, respectively.
  • Vorticity and TKE are closely linked: The distribution of vorticity magnitude closely mirrors that of the TKE, indicating regions of concentrated momentum and high turbulence.

Key Results

  • Increased vorticity and TKE with yaw: At a larger yaw angle (9° vs. 6°), the vorticity magnitude and TKE of the wake are stronger.
  • Pronounced downwash at higher yaw and Re: The downwash of the sail-tip vortex center increases with yaw angle (1.2% to 2.9% decrease in vertical coordinate from 6° to 9°) and Reynolds number (0.5% to 1.5% relative decrease).
  • Reynolds number influences vortex center position: A higher Reynolds number causes a slight deviation of the sail-tip vortex center towards the suction side.
  • Lateral and vertical velocities increase with yaw: The maximum absolute values of lateral and vertical velocities near the vortex center increase with yaw angle.
  • Reynolds stresses and TKE peak at the vortex center: These turbulent quantities are highest at the vortex core and show slight increases with Reynolds number and significant increases with yaw angle.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited yaw angles and Reynolds numbers: The study focused on two specific yaw angles (6° and 9°) and two Reynolds numbers. Further investigations across a wider range would provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Focus on specific regions: The study concentrated on the wake of the sail and the hull-sail junction. Characterizing flow dynamics across broader regions of the hull remains an area for future research.
  • Experimental limitations: While SPIV is a powerful tool, it has inherent limitations in spatial and temporal resolution compared to some numerical methods. The paper acknowledges the need for further characterization of flow dynamics across broader regions.

The authors suggest that their experimental findings will be crucial for validating and improving numerical simulations of submarine wakes, contributing to better design and performance optimization of submarines.

Summary updated

Abstract

To gain a better understanding of the complex flow dynamics and stealth characteristics of submarines under maneuvering conditions, flow field experiments were conducted on the SUBOFF submarine model in the large low-speed wind tunnel at the China Ship Scientific Research Center (CSSRC). The three-dimensional velocity field above the hull at 6° and 9° yaw angles was captured using the stereo particle image velocimetry (SPIV) system. The experimental Reynolds numbers were selected as ReL = 0.46 × 107 and ReL = 1.08 × 107. The wake of the sail and the junction between the sail root and the hull were analyzed in detail, focusing on the core flow of the sail-tip vortex. The results revealed that at a larger yaw angle, the vorticity magnitude and turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) of the wake increased, and the downwash effect of the sail-tip vortex center became more pronounced. Furthermore, a higher Reynolds number resulted in an even more significant downwash of the vortex center, accompanied by a slight deviation towards the suction side. These experimental findings can contribute to the enrichment of the benchmark database for validating and improving numerical simulations of submarine wakes.
BibTeX
@article{chen2024stereo,
  author = {Mo Chen and Nan Zhang and Ziyan Li and Junliang Liu and Lan Yu and Wentao Zheng and Xuan Zhang},
  title = {{Stereo Particle Image Velocimetry Measurement of the Flow around SUBOFF Submarine under Yaw Conditions}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse12091576},
}
Figure