Stepwise Neofunctionalization of the NF-κB Family Member c-Rel during Vertebrate Evolution

Allison E. Daly, Abraham B. Chang, Prabhat Kumar Purbey, Kevin Jon Williams, George Yeh, Shuxing Li, Scott D. Pope, Byrappa Venkatesh, Benjamin D. Redelings, Sibon Li, Kaylin Nguyen, Joseph Rodrigues, Kelsey Jorgensen, Trevor Siggers, Lin Chen, Stephen T. SmaleBiorxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals how a key immune regulator, c-Rel, evolved a unique DNA-binding ability in mammals, enabling it to fine-tune adaptive immunity. This evolutionary shift, driven by specific amino acid changes, allowed c-Rel to bind novel DNA sequences, leading to more complex immune responses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The evolution of adaptive immunity in vertebrates is a complex process, and the NF-κB/Rel family of transcription factors plays a crucial role in this. While the basic NF-κB system is ancient, the specific roles and regulatory mechanisms of its family members, particularly c-Rel, have diversified over evolutionary time. This paper investigates how c-Rel acquired specialized functions, specifically its potent regulation of the Il12b gene, which is critical for T-cell development. The central question is how c-Rel evolved these unique capabilities, and whether this occurred early or late in vertebrate evolution, and what structural changes underpinned these functional shifts.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Phylogenetic Analysis: They constructed a phylogenetic tree of NF-κB family members from various species to understand their evolutionary relationships.
  • Biochemical Assays (EMSA, SPR, PBM): Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assays (EMSA), Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR), and Protein-Binding Microarrays (PBM) were used to characterize the DNA-binding affinities and specificities of different NF-κB dimers (homodimers and heterodimers) from various species.
  • ChIP-seq: Chromatin Immunoprecipitation followed by sequencing (ChIP-seq) was performed in macrophages to identify genomic regions bound by c-Rel and RelA in vivo, revealing their genome-wide binding preferences.
  • X-ray Crystallography: The crystal structure of a chimeric RelA(C46) protein (containing key c-Rel residues) bound to DNA was determined to pinpoint structural differences responsible for altered DNA binding.
  • Functional Assays (Reporter Assays, BAC Engineering): Luciferase reporter assays and experiments using engineered bacterial artificial chromosomes (BACs) in macrophages were used to assess the functional impact of specific NF-κB binding sites on Il12b gene expression.
  • RNA-seq: Nascent transcript RNA-seq was used to identify c-Rel-dependent genes in macrophages.

Datasets

  • Publicly available NF-κB RHR sequences: Used for phylogenetic analysis.
  • Nascent transcript RNA-seq data: Generated from wild-type and Rel⁻/⁻ mouse macrophages stimulated with lipid A.
  • ChIP-seq data: Generated from mouse macrophages stimulated with lipid A using antibodies against RelA, c-Rel, and p50.
  • Protein Data Bank (PDB): Used for structural comparisons (e.g., 2RAM.pdb, 1GJI.pdb).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Late Evolution of c-Rel's Unique DNA Binding: The key difference in DNA-binding affinity between c-Rel and RelA, which underpins c-Rel's specialized function, appears to have evolved relatively late in vertebrate evolution, specifically within mammals. This is a significant departure from the idea that fundamental immune system components evolved early.
  • c-Rel's Affinity for Non-Consensus Motifs: c-Rel homodimers possess a remarkably high intrinsic DNA-binding affinity, allowing them to bind to DNA motifs that are quite different from canonical NF-κB binding sites. This is a major functional advantage.
  • Structural Basis for Affinity Difference: X-ray crystallography identified a specific region (46 residues) and a key amino acid (Arg102 in mammals) within c-Rel that are responsible for its enhanced DNA-binding affinity compared to RelA.
  • Functional Specialization of Il12b Regulation: c-Rel's unique binding properties are directly linked to its potent and selective activation of the Il12b gene, a critical regulator of T-cell differentiation. This suggests a co-evolutionary relationship between c-Rel's structural changes and the development of more complex immune responses.
  • Implications for Adaptive Immunity: The evolution of c-Rel's specialized binding likely played a role in the emergence and increasing complexity of adaptive immunity, allowing for more nuanced immune regulation.

Key Results

  • Phylogenetic analysis showed that while the core NF-κB family is conserved, the RelA, c-Rel, and RelB lineages diverged significantly from invertebrate ancestors.
  • Biochemical experiments demonstrated that c-Rel homodimers bind to NF-κB motifs with significantly higher affinity than RelA homodimers, particularly to motifs that diverge from the consensus.
  • ChIP-seq revealed that c-Rel preferentially binds to genomic locations that often lack canonical NF-κB binding sites, especially in promoter regions of genes like Il12b.
  • X-ray crystallography identified Arg102 in mammals as a key residue contributing to c-Rel's enhanced DNA-binding affinity, a residue that is glutamine in non-mammalian vertebrates.
  • Functional assays confirmed that mutations in specific non-consensus NF-κB motifs in the Il12b promoter significantly reduced c-Rel-dependent activation.
  • Comparative analysis of RelA and c-Rel orthologs across vertebrates showed that the significant DNA-binding affinity difference was largely restricted to mammalian species.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Antibody Quality: The authors note that the smaller number of peaks obtained with the p50 ChIP-seq antibody might be due to relatively poor antibody quality, potentially affecting the completeness of the analysis.
  • c-Rel/RelA Binding Difference in Non-Mammals: While a DNA-binding affinity difference was observed with frog proteins, it was not as pronounced as in mammals, suggesting that other factors (protein differences or expression patterns) might have contributed to early divergence.
  • Role in Treg Development: The paper raises the question of whether the observed DNA-binding differences are critical for the distinct activities of RelA and c-Rel in Treg development and function, which remains to be determined.
  • Mechanism of Il12b Requirement: It is still unclear why Il12b acquired a critical requirement for c-Rel, while other NF-κB target genes are activated redundantly. Future work could explore unique regulatory mechanisms for c-Rel dimers.
  • Evolutionary Timing of Il12b Regulation: The question of whether Il12b induction in early vertebrates was c-Rel-dependent via a different mechanism or regulated by c-Rel-independent mechanisms remains open.

Summary updated

Abstract

SUMMARY Adaptive immunity and the five vertebrate NF-κB/Rel family members first appeared in cartilaginous fish, suggesting that divergence and specialization within the NF-κB family helped facilitate the evolution of adaptive immunity. One specialized function of the NF-κB c-Rel protein in macrophages is the activation of Il12b , which encodes a key regulator of T-cell development. We found that c-Rel is a far more potent regulator of Il12b than of any other inducible genes in macrophages, with c-Rel regulation of Il12b dependent on its heightened intrinsic DNA-binding affinity. c-Rel homodimers regulate Il12b transcription in part via motifs with little resemblance to canonical NF-κB motifs. ChIP-seq experiments further defined distinct c-Rel DNA-binding preferences genome-wide, and X-ray crystallography of a c-Rel/RelA chimeric protein identified key amino acid changes that support the unique c-Rel properties. Unexpectedly, these changes, along with the c-Rel/RelA binding affinity differences, were largely restricted to mammalian species. Together, our findings reveal how a transcription factor family member can undergo a structural transition at a late stage of vertebrate evolution, resulting in an increased intrinsic DNA binding affinity and with clear functional consequences, presumably to support the increasing complexity of immune regulation.
BibTeX
@misc{daly2024stepwise,
  author = {Allison E. Daly and Abraham B. Chang and Prabhat Kumar Purbey and Kevin Jon Williams and George Yeh and Shuxing Li and Scott D. Pope and Byrappa Venkatesh and Benjamin D. Redelings and Sibon Li and Kaylin Nguyen and Joseph Rodrigues and Kelsey Jorgensen and Trevor Siggers and Lin Chen and Stephen T. Smale},
  title = {{Stepwise Neofunctionalization of the NF-κB Family Member c-Rel during Vertebrate Evolution}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.01.23.575293},
  howpublished = {Biorxiv},
}
Figure