Steady-state Stability Assessment of AC-busbar Plug-in Electric Vehicle Charging Station with Photovoltaic

Rui Wang, Qiuye Sun, Dehao Qin, Yushuai Li, Xiangke Li, Peng WangJournal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Although the deployment of alternating current (AC) -busbar plug-in electric vehicle (PEV) charging station with photovoltaic (PV) is a promising alternative, the interaction among subsystems always causes the instability problem. Meanwhile, the conventional generalized Nyquist criterion (GNC) is complex, and it is not suitable for the design of the AC system. Therefore, this paper proposes a modified infinity-one-norm (MION) stability criterion based on the impedance method to assess the stability of the foresaid charging station. Firstly, the typical structure and operation modes of the charging station are studied. Furthermore, each subsystem impedance matrix is built by small-signal method, and the MION stability criterion based on impedance method is proposed to assess the charging station stability. Compared with the previous simplified stability criteria based on the norm, the proposed criterion has lower conservatism. Furthermore, the design regulation for the controller parameters is provided, and the stability recovery way is provided by connecting the doubly-fed line and energy storage equipment, which are selected based on intermediate variable, i.e., short-circuit ratio (SCR). Finally, the effectiveness and conservatism of the proposed stability criterion are validated through simulation and experimental results.

Introduction

As the world shifts toward greener infrastructure, AC-busbar charging stations that integrate PV arrays and PEVs are becoming increasingly common. However, these systems are "converter-dominated," characterized by power electronics that exhibit negative damping and low inertia. These traits often lead to instability when subsystems interact, particularly in "weak grids" with high impedance.

Typical architecture of an AC-busbar charging station integrated with PV and PEV units.

Engineers traditionally rely on the Generalized Nyquist Criterion (GNC) to assess stability, but its mathematical complexity makes it difficult to apply to practical controller design. Simplified "norm-based" criteria exist but are often overly conservative, potentially flagging stable systems as unstable and leading to inefficient designs.

Methodology: The MION Stability Criterion

To address these challenges, this paper introduces the Modified Infinity-One-Norm (MION) stability criterion. The methodology follows several key steps:

  1. Small-Signal Modeling: Detailed mathematical models of PEV rectifiers and PV inverters are constructed in the $d-q$ rotating reference frame.
  2. Impedance Matrix Derivation: Input and output impedance matrices are derived for each subsystem (Grid, PV, and PEV) across various operation modes.
  3. MION Criterion Development: By analyzing the eigenvalues of the system's "minor loop gain" (the ratio of source impedance to load admittance), the authors proposed a criterion that takes the minimum of the matrix infinity-norm and the one-norm.
Simplified impedance model of the integrated system used for small-signal analysis at the Point of Common Coupling (PCC).

This approach significantly reduces conservatism. While the Infinity-Norm (IN) or One-Norm (ION) alone might overestimate instability, taking the minimum of these norms provides a tighter bound that closely tracks the actual stability limit of the system.

Results and Validation

The MION criterion was validated using both simulation and experimental hardware. In simulations of various operation modes, MION remained below the stability threshold (1.0) while other criteria (GN, ION, IN) incorrectly flagged the system as unstable. Time-domain simulations confirmed the system's actual stability, proving MION's superior accuracy.

Furthermore, the study provides design regulations for Proportional-Integral (PI) controller parameters. It demonstrates that stability can be recovered in "ultra-weak" grids (Short-Circuit Ratio < 2) by tuning controller bandwidth or adding energy storage equipment. Experimental tests on a low-voltage laboratory prototype mirrored these findings, correctly predicting voltage oscillations as grid resistance increased.

Conclusion

The proposed MION stability criterion offers a mathematically simpler and less conservative tool for assessing AC-busbar charging stations. By linking stability directly to the Short-Circuit Ratio and providing clear controller design guidelines, this research facilitates the deployment of stable, high-performance renewable energy infrastructure. Future work will extend this criterion to more complex multi-bus microgrids and diverse environmental conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although the deployment of alternating current (AC) -busbar plug-in electric vehicle (PEV) charging station with photovoltaic (PV) is a promising alternative, the interaction among subsystems always causes the instability problem. Meanwhile, the conventional generalized Nyquist criterion (GNC) is complex, and it is not suitable for the design of the AC system. Therefore, this paper proposes a modified infinity-one-norm (MION) stability criterion based on the impedance method to assess the stability of the foresaid charging station. Firstly, the typical structure and operation modes of the charging station are studied. Furthermore, each subsystem impedance matrix is built by small-signal method, and the MION stability criterion based on impedance method is proposed to assess the charging station stability. Compared with the previous simplified stability criteria based on the norm, the proposed criterion has lower conservatism. Furthermore, the design regulation for the controller parameters is provided, and the stability recovery way is provided by connecting the doubly-fed line and energy storage equipment, which are selected based on intermediate variable, i.e., short-circuit ratio (SCR). Finally, the effectiveness and conservatism of the proposed stability criterion are validated through simulation and experimental results.
BibTeX
@article{wang2020steady,
  author = {Rui Wang and Qiuye Sun and Dehao Qin and Yushuai Li and Xiangke Li and Peng Wang},
  title = {{Steady-state Stability Assessment of AC-busbar Plug-in Electric Vehicle Charging Station with Photovoltaic}},
  journal = {Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.35833/mpce.2020.000182},
}
Figure