Status of landslides and influencing factors in Bao Yen district, Lao Cai province and Quan Hoa district, Thanh Hoa province: A community-based survey

Kieu Thi Duong, Bui Xuan Dung, Trần Thi Thúy, Ning An, Thu Anh Nguyen, Nguyen Thi Kim PhuongJournal of Forestry Science and Technology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates landslide occurrences and their driving factors in two Vietnamese mountainous districts, Quan Hoa and Bao Yen, using community surveys and the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). The findings highlight heavy rainfall and steep terrain as the primary culprits, underscoring the need for community-involved mitigation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Landslides are a significant natural hazard in Vietnam, particularly in its mountainous regions, leading to substantial loss of life and property. While the general causes of landslides are understood (natural and human factors), there's a need for localized, community-informed assessments to identify specific influencing factors and develop effective, context-appropriate mitigation strategies. This paper addresses this by focusing on two specific districts, Quan Hoa and Bao Yen, which have experienced notable landslide events, aiming to bridge the gap between scientific understanding and practical, community-based disaster risk reduction.

Methods

The research employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Community-Based Survey: This involved random interviews with local residents and officials in areas prone to landslides. The interviews aimed to gather data on landslide occurrences, their impacts, and perceived influencing factors. A total of 98 individuals were interviewed in Quan Hoa and 60 in Bao Yen.
  2. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): This established multi-criteria decision-making method was used to systematically prioritize the identified influencing factors. Seven key factors were considered: heavy/prolonged rainfall, high/steep terrain, overexploitation of resources, inappropriate agricultural practices, improper infrastructure construction, low vegetation cover/weak soil protection, and changing climatic factors. The AHP method involved pairwise comparisons of these factors to determine their relative importance.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it relied on:

  • Interview Data: Collected from 158 local residents and officials in Quan Hoa and Bao Yen districts between July 2024 and May 2025. This data formed the basis for understanding landslide status, impacts, and influencing factors from a community perspective.
  • Secondary Reports: Used to supplement interview data and provide context on landslide events and disaster policies.
  • GPS Coordinates: Collected during field surveys to map landslide locations, which were then plotted using QGIS 10.3 software.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Community Voice is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that local community perceptions are vital for understanding landslide risks and developing effective solutions. Their insights directly informed the identification and prioritization of influencing factors.
  • Rainfall Reigns Supreme: The overwhelming consensus, both from community interviews and the AHP analysis, points to heavy and prolonged rainfall as the single most significant factor driving landslides in these regions. This highlights the direct impact of meteorological events.
  • Terrain Matters: Steep and high terrain is consistently identified as the second most critical factor, reinforcing the inherent vulnerability of mountainous landscapes to mass movement.
  • Human Activities Compound Risk: While natural factors dominate, the study also clearly shows how human activities like overexploitation of resources, poor agricultural practices, and inadequate infrastructure exacerbate landslide risks.
  • Climate Change as an Amplifier: Although ranked lowest in direct influence, the study acknowledges that climate change acts as an amplifier, potentially intensifying extreme weather events like heavy rainfall, thereby increasing landslide frequency and severity.

Key Results

  • Landslide Incidents: Both Quan Hoa and Bao Yen districts recorded 36 landslide incidents each between 2020 and 2024. These events occurred along road embankments, steep slopes, and areas with sparse vegetation.
  • Household Impact: A significant majority of households were affected by landslides, with 82.9% in Quan Hoa and 75% in Bao Yen reporting impacts.
  • Prioritized Influencing Factors (AHP):
    • Heavy and prolonged rainfall (A): 42.7%
    • High and steep terrain (B): 25.0%
    • Overexploitation of soil, forests, and natural resources (C): 10.6%
    • Low vegetation cover and weak soil protection (F): 7.0%
    • Unsuitable agricultural practices (D): 5.7%
    • Improper infrastructure construction (E): 5.2%
    • Changing climatic factors (climate change) (G): 3.7%
  • Damage Assessment: Landslides caused significant damage, including loss of life (notably in Bao Yen), property damage, traffic disruption, and agricultural losses. Quan Hoa experienced more widespread flooding and minor landslides, while Bao Yen saw more severe events with fatalities.
  • Community Awareness: Residents demonstrated high awareness of landslide causes (75-89.4%) and the importance of forest protection. However, there's a noted gap in community participation in early warning and forecasting measures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that while community opinions are valuable, they might not always align perfectly with purely scientific assessments.
  • The reliance on interview data means that the accuracy of factor importance is based on subjective perceptions, although the AHP method helps to structure and quantify these perceptions.
  • The study did not cover all potential influencing factors, and the AHP analysis was limited to seven predefined criteria.
  • Future Work:
    • The paper proposes comprehensive solutions focusing on land management, resource mobilization, and infrastructure reinforcement.
  • It highlights the need for increased investment in early landslide forecasting and warning systems, especially in Bao Yen.
  • There's a call for enhanced training for officials in management and rescue operations.
  • Long-term forest protection and afforestation are recommended for slope stability.
  • The study suggests that policies supporting infrastructure development and insurance for vulnerable households, while lower priority, should be consistently implemented.
  • The authors suggest that future studies could leverage advanced tools to further refine mitigation strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aimed to evaluate the status of landslide incidents and the factors influencing them in two mountainous districts: Quan Hoa (Thanh Hoa province) and Bao Yen (Lao Cai province). The primary method was used by random interviews with selective sampling of local residents and officials in areas frequently affected by landslides. Additionally, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method was employed to assess the importance of influencing factors. The main findings showed that in Quan Hoa, over the past five years from 2020 to 2024, there were 36 landslide incidents, occurring along road embankments, in areas with steep slopes, or regions lacking vegetation cover. Similarly, in Bao Yen district, 36 landslide incidents were recorded over the same period. The AHP analysis revealed the order of importance of factors affecting landslides in both areas, from most to least significant, as follows: heavy and prolonged rainfall (A, 42.7%), high and steep terrain (B, 25.0%), overexploitation of resources (C, 10.6%), low vegetation cover with weak soil protection (F, 7.0%), inappropriate agricultural practices (D, 5.7%), improper construction of infrastructure (E, 5.2%), and changing meteorological factors due to climate change (G, 3.7%). Based on these findings, existing local measures and community feedback, the study proposed a comprehensive set of solutions focusing on land management, resource mobilization, and infrastructure reinforcement to mitigate landslide risks and minimize their impacts in these high-vulnerability upland regions.
BibTeX
@article{duong2025status,
  author = {Kieu Thi Duong and Bui Xuan Dung and Trần Thi Thúy and Ning An and Thu Anh Nguyen and Nguyen Thi Kim Phuong},
  title = {{Status of landslides and influencing factors in Bao Yen district, Lao Cai province and Quan Hoa district, Thanh Hoa province: A community-based survey}},
  journal = {Journal of Forestry Science and Technology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.55250/jo.vnuf.10.2.2025.061-071},
}
Figure