TL;DR
This study introduces and assesses "dual health literacy" (DHL) – the combined understanding of modern medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) – among Chinese residents. The findings reveal low DHL levels, highlighting significant disparities and the need for integrated health education strategies, particularly for vulnerable populations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In China, healthcare is a dual system, integrating both modern medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). However, individuals often struggle to navigate both, leading to fragmented health decisions and suboptimal outcomes. While health literacy (HL) in modern medicine and TCM-HL have been studied separately, their interplay and the concept of "dual health literacy" (DHL) – the ability to understand and utilize information from both systems – has been largely overlooked. This paper aims to bridge this gap by assessing the current status of DHL, identifying its key influencing factors, and providing evidence to support integrated healthcare approaches.
Methods
The researchers employed a cross-sectional study design, utilizing standardized questionnaires to assess both modern medicine health literacy (HL) and Traditional Chinese Medicine health literacy (TCM-HL) among Chinese residents aged 15-69. Data was collected via an online survey. Statistical analyses included Mann-Whitney U and Kruskal-Wallis tests for continuous variables and chi-square tests for categorical variables to compare group differences. Multivariate logistic regression was used to identify factors associated with HL, TCM-HL, and DHL.
Datasets
The study used data collected from a survey of 605 Chinese residents in January 2023. The survey employed two validated instruments:
- The "National Residents' Health Literacy Monitoring Questionnaire (Version 2017)" for modern medicine HL.
- The "Chinese Citizens' TCM Health Literacy Questionnaire (Version 2017)" for TCM-HL.
No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on applying existing instruments to a novel combined concept (DHL).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Interconnectedness of Health Literacies: A strong correlation (r=0.81) was found between modern HL and TCM-HL, suggesting that individuals who are health literate in one system are likely to be health literate in the other. This reinforces the idea that DHL is a meaningful and achievable concept.
- The "Dual" Challenge: The low attainment rate for DHL (6.8%) compared to HL (27.1%) and TCM-HL (10.9%) indicates that integrating knowledge from both systems is significantly more challenging than mastering just one.
- Disparities in Literacy: Significant differences in HL and TCM-HL were observed across various demographic groups, particularly in relation to education level and place of residence. This highlights that access to information and education plays a crucial role.
- Targeted Interventions Needed: The study identified specific areas of weakness within both HL (e.g., basic medical literacy, health skills) and TCM-HL (e.g., healthy lifestyle, public health methods), suggesting that interventions need to be tailored to address these specific gaps.
Key Results
- Overall Attainment: Standard attainment rates were 27.1% for HL, 10.9% for TCM-HL, and a low 6.8% for DHL.
- Demographic Associations:
- HL: Higher education level (AOR=1.64), urban residence (AOR=1.60), and health insurance coverage (AOR=2.74) were significantly associated with higher HL attainment.
- TCM-HL: Higher education level (AOR=1.78) was significantly associated with higher TCM-HL attainment.
- Specific Weaknesses: The lowest attainment rates were observed in basic medical literacy (13.2%), health skills (15.0%), and chronic disease prevention & control (16%) for HL, and healthy lifestyle (0%) and appropriate public health methods (3.5%) for TCM-HL.
- DHL Disparities: DHL was higher in suburban and urban areas (13.3% and 9.4%) compared to rural areas (4.7%).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Sampling Bias: The use of an online survey platform (Sojump) may introduce selection bias, potentially underrepresenting older adults, individuals without internet access, or those in remote areas. Future research should consider probability sampling or mixed-method approaches.
- Gender Skew: The sample had a disproportionately high number of female participants (69.4%), which may influence observed gender differences. Future studies should aim for more balanced gender representation.
The paper strongly suggests future work should focus on:
- Developing Integrated Curricula: Creating unified educational materials and teaching methods that emphasize the complementary roles of modern medicine and TCM.
- Addressing Cultural Stereotypes: Utilizing effective science communication to challenge cognitive biases and reshape public perceptions of both medical systems.
- Improving Access in Rural Areas: Expanding digital platforms and community-based initiatives to ensure equitable access to comprehensive health knowledge, especially for underserved populations.
- Targeted Interventions: Designing specific programs for rural residents, those with lower education levels, and the uninsured, focusing on identified literacy gaps.
- Policy Integration: Advocating for policies that support DHL and integrate modern and TCM health strategies.
Summary updated