Statistics of Scalar Flux Transport of Major Species in Different Premixed Turbulent Combustion Regimes for H2-air Flames

Vassilios Papapostolou, Nilanjan Chakraborty, Markus Klein, H. G. ImFlow 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The statistical behaviour of turbulent scalar flux and modelling of its transport have been analysed for both major reactants and products in the context of Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes simulations using a detailed chemistry Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) database of freely-propagating H2-air flames (with an equivalence ratio of 0.7) spanning the corrugated flamelets, thin reaction zones and broken reaction zones regimes of premixed turbulent combustion. The turbulent scalar flux in the cases representing the corrugated flamelets and thin reaction zones regimes of combustion exhibit predominantly countergradient transport, whilst a gradient transport has been observed for the broken reaction zones regime flame considered here. It has been found that the qualitative behaviour of the various terms of the turbulent scalar flux transport equation for the major species such as H2, O2 and H2O in the cases representing the corrugated flamelets and thin reaction zones regimes of combustion are mostly similar, whilst the behaviour is markedly different for the case representing the broken reaction zone regime. However, the terms for the scalar flux transport equation for H2 and O2 show same signs whereas the corresponding terms for H2O show signs opposite to those for H2 and O2. The performances of the well-established existing models for the unclosed terms of the turbulent scalar flux transport equation have been found to be similar for H2, O2 and H2O Some of the existing models for turbulent flux, pressure gradient, molecular diffusion and reaction contributions have been found to yield reasonable performance for the cases representing the corrugated flamelets and thin reaction zones regimes but the existing closures for these terms have been found to be mostly inadequate for the broken reaction zones regime flames.

Introduction: The Challenge of Turbulent Scalar Flux

In industrial combustion modeling, researchers often rely on Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) simulations because they are computationally efficient. However, RANS requires "closure models" to describe how turbulence moves chemical species around—a process known as turbulent scalar flux.

The most common approach is the gradient hypothesis, which assumes species move from areas of high concentration to low concentration. But in premixed flames, the intense heat release creates local pressure gradients that can push species against the concentration gradient, a phenomenon known as counter-gradient transport. While this is well-documented for simple reactions, real-world fuels like hydrogen involve complex, multi-step chemistry. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how these transport mechanisms behave across different combustion regimes using detailed chemical kinetics.

Methods and Datasets

The study utilizes a 3D Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) database of statistically planar, freely propagating $H_2$-air flames (equivalence ratio 0.7). DNS provides a "ground truth" by solving the full Navier-Stokes and chemical species equations without modeling assumptions. The researchers analyzed three distinct cases representing different levels of turbulence intensity:

  • Case A (Corrugated Flamelets - CF): Low turbulence ($Ka = 0.75$), where the flame remains a thin, wrinkled sheet.
  • Case B (Thin Reaction Zones - TRZ): Moderate turbulence ($Ka = 14.4$), where turbulence begins to penetrate the flame structure.
  • Case C (Broken Reaction Zones - BRZ): High turbulence ($Ka = 126$), where strong turbulence disrupts the reaction zone.
3D visualizations of the flame structure for Case A (top), Case B (middle), and Case C (bottom), showing the transition from thin flamelets to broken reaction zones.

Key Insights: The Regime Flip

A critical finding of this research is the "regime flip" in transport behavior. In the CF and TRZ regimes (Cases A and B), transport is predominantly counter-gradient. However, in the BRZ regime (Case C), the transport flips to gradient-driven.

This shift is quantitatively captured by the parameter $\Lambda$, which represents the ratio of turbulent scalar flux to the mean scalar gradient. As shown in the data, $\Lambda$ remains negative for Cases A and B (indicating counter-gradient transport) but becomes positive for Case C. This transition is governed by the Bray number ($N_B$), which compares flame-induced acceleration to turbulent fluctuations. The study validated that counter-gradient transport occurs when $N_B > 1$.

Variation of the normalized scalar flux ratio Λ across the flame for Cases A, B, and C (top to bottom). Negative values indicate counter-gradient transport, while positive values in Case C indicate gradient transport.

Species Symmetry and Modeling Performance

The analysis revealed that the transport behavior of reactants ($H_2, O_2$) is qualitatively similar, while the product ($H_2O$) shows the exact opposite sign. This suggests that a unified modeling framework can work for multiple species if the reactant/product relationship is accounted for.

Regarding RANS closure models, the authors found that most existing models—originally designed for "flamelet" conditions—perform reasonably well for Cases A and B. However, these models fail significantly in the BRZ regime (Case C), where the underlying assumption of a bi-modal (burned or unburned) state breaks down. To address this, the authors proposed modified models (CC-M, DBML-M, and RB-M) that incorporate the local Karlovitz number ($Ka_L$) and Lewis number ($Le$), significantly improving agreement with DNS data across all regimes.

Conclusion

This work provides a practical roadmap for CFD engineers by identifying which closure models are optimal for different combustion regimes. While the proposed modifications improve accuracy in high-turbulence conditions, the authors note that the Broken Reaction Zone regime remains a significant challenge for RANS modeling, offering substantial scope for future research in high-intensity turbulent combustion.

Summary updated

Abstract

The statistical behaviour of turbulent scalar flux and modelling of its transport have been analysed for both major reactants and products in the context of Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes simulations using a detailed chemistry Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) database of freely-propagating H 2 -air flames (with an equivalence ratio of 0.7) spanning the corrugated flamelets, thin reaction zones and broken reaction zones regimes of premixed turbulent combustion. The turbulent scalar flux in the cases representing the corrugated flamelets and thin reaction zones regimes of combustion exhibit predominantly countergradient transport, whilst a gradient transport has been observed for the broken reaction zones regime flame considered here. It has been found that the qualitative behaviour of the various terms of the turbulent scalar flux transport equation for the major species such as H 2 , O 2 and H 2 O in the cases representing the corrugated flamelets and thin reaction zones regimes of combustion are mostly similar, whilst the behaviour is markedly different for the case representing the broken reaction zone regime. However, the terms for the scalar flux transport equation for H 2 and O 2 show same signs whereas the corresponding terms for H 2 O show signs opposite to those for H 2 and O 2 . The performances of the well-established existing models for the unclosed terms of the turbulent scalar flux transport equation have been found to be similar for H 2 , O 2 and H 2 O Some of the existing models for turbulent flux, pressure gradient, molecular diffusion and reaction contributions have been found to yield reasonable performance for the cases representing the corrugated flamelets and thin reaction zones regimes but the existing closures for these terms have been found to be mostly inadequate for the broken reaction zones regime flames.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{papapostolou2019statistics,
  author = {Vassilios Papapostolou and Nilanjan Chakraborty and Markus Klein and H. G. Im},
  title = {{Statistics of Scalar Flux Transport of Major Species in Different Premixed Turbulent Combustion Regimes for H2-air Flames}},
  booktitle = {Flow},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1007/s10494-018-9989-0},
}
Figure