Statistical properties of fast radio bursts elucidate their origins: magnetars are favored over gamma-ray bursts

X. H. Cui, Chengmin Zhang, Shuangqiang Wang, Jianwei Zhang, Di Li, Bo Peng, Weiwei Zhu, R. G. Strom, Na Wang, Qingdong Wu, Changqing Ye, Dehua Wang, Y. G. Yang, Zhen-Qi DiaoResearch 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Fast radio bursts (FRBs) are extremely strong radio flares lasting several milliseconds, most of which come from unidentified objects at a cosmological distance. They can be apparently repeating or not. In this paper, we analyzed 18 repeaters and 12 non-repeating FRBs observed in the frequency bands of 400–800 MHz from Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment (CHIME). We investigated the distributions of FRB isotropic-equivalent radio luminosity, considering the K correction. Statistically, the luminosity distribution can be better fitted by Gaussian form than by power-law. Based on the above results, together with the observed FRB event rate, pulse duration, and radio luminosity, FRB origin models are evaluated and constrained such that the gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) may be excluded for the non-repeaters while magnetars or neutron stars (NSs) emitting the supergiant pulses are preferred for the repeaters. We also found the necessity of a small FRB emission beaming solid angle (about 0.1 sr) from magnetars that should be considered, and/or the FRB association with soft gamma-ray repeaters (SGRs) may lie at a low probability of about 10%. Finally, we discussed the uncertainty of FRB luminosity caused by the estimation of the distance that is inferred by the simple relation between the redshift and dispersion measure (DM).

Introduction

Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) represent one of the most intriguing mysteries in modern astrophysics. These millisecond-long, high-intensity radio flares originate from distant galaxies, yet their physical engines remain largely unknown. Since their discovery in 2007, the number of theoretical models has proliferated, ranging from cataclysmic stellar mergers to magnetar flares. A key question is whether repeating FRBs and non-repeating FRBs share a common origin or represent distinct classes of astronomical events. This study seeks to constrain these models by analyzing the statistical properties of FRB luminosity and duration.

Methodology

To minimize instrumental bias, the researchers analyzed a specific subset of data from the CHIME telescope, focusing on 18 repeating and 12 non-repeating FRBs detected in the 400–800 MHz band.

The analysis involved several critical steps:

  1. K-Correction: Observed luminosities were adjusted to account for redshift, ensuring a consistent comparison across cosmological distances.
  2. Distribution Fitting: The team compared the goodness-of-fit for the luminosity data against two primary models: a Gaussian (normal) distribution and a power-law (Schechter function).
  3. Comparative Analysis: The statistical findings were cross-referenced with known event rates and pulse durations for various candidate sources, including Long Gamma-Ray Bursts (LGRBs), Short Gamma-Ray Bursts (SGRBs), and magnetars.

Statistical Distribution of Luminosity

A pivotal finding of this research is that FRB luminosity distributions are significantly better described by a Gaussian curve than by a power-law. In statistical physics, a power-law often indicates scale-invariant, cataclysmic processes, whereas a Gaussian distribution suggests a preferred physical scale or a specific emission mechanism inherent to the source.

Figure 1: Radio luminosity distribution for repeating FRBs at 600MHz, showing the superior fit of the Gaussian curve compared to the Schechter (power-law) curve.

For repeating FRBs, the Gaussian fit achieved a confidence level of 0.927, while the power-law fit was only 0.013. Non-repeating FRBs showed a similar preference, with a 0.734 confidence for the Gaussian fit versus 0.006 for the power-law.

Evaluating Origin Models

By comparing the observed properties of FRBs with theoretical models, the researchers were able to narrow down the likely candidates. The table below summarizes the comparison across various potential sources.

Figure 3: Comparison of observed FRB properties with various theoretical models, highlighting the consistency of magnetars and NS-WD mergers with the data.

Ruling Out Gamma-Ray Bursts

Long Gamma-Ray Bursts (LGRBs) were effectively excluded as candidates for non-repeating FRBs. Their typical durations (seconds) and luminosity functions (which follow a Schechter/power-law distribution) do not align with the millisecond durations and Gaussian-distributed luminosities observed in FRB data.

Favored Candidates

Magnetars emerged as the most statistically plausible origin for repeating FRBs. For non-repeaters, models involving Neutron Star-White Dwarf (NS-WD) mergers or collisions showed high compatibility with the observed event rates and Gaussian luminosity distributions.

Discussion and Conclusions

The study also addressed the "tension" between the high birth rate of magnetars and the relatively lower detection rate of FRBs. The authors propose two potential explanations:

  • Beaming: FRB emission may be highly collimated (beamed) with a small solid angle of approximately 0.1 steradians, meaning only a fraction of bursts are directed toward Earth.
  • Low Association Probability: The association between FRBs and Soft Gamma-Ray Repeaters (SGRs) might be rare, with perhaps only 10% of SGR flares producing an observable FRB.

While the current sample size of 30 bursts is relatively small, the clear statistical preference for Gaussian distributions provides a strong constraint for future theoretical work. As more localized FRBs are detected with precise redshift measurements, these statistical models will become increasingly robust, further narrowing the search for the engines behind these cosmic flashes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Fast radio bursts (FRBs) are extremely strong radio flares lasting several milliseconds, most of which come from unidentified objects at a cosmological distance. They can be apparently repeating or not. In this paper, we analyzed 18 repeaters and 12 non-repeating FRBs observed in the frequency bands of 400–800 MHz from Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment (CHIME). We investigated the distributions of FRB isotropic-equivalent radio luminosity, considering the K correction. Statistically, the luminosity distribution can be better fitted by Gaussian form than by power-law. Based on the above results, together with the observed FRB event rate, pulse duration, and radio luminosity, FRB origin models are evaluated and constrained such that the gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) may be excluded for the non-repeaters while magnetars or neutron stars (NSs) emitting the supergiant pulses are preferred for the repeaters. We also found the necessity of a small FRB emission beaming solid angle (about 0.1 sr) from magnetars that should be considered, and/or the FRB association with soft gamma-ray repeaters (SGRs) may lie at a low probability of about 10%. Finally, we discussed the uncertainty of FRB luminosity caused by the estimation of the distance that is inferred by the simple relation between the redshift and dispersion measure (DM).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cui2021statistical,
  author = {X. H. Cui and Chengmin Zhang and Shuangqiang Wang and Jianwei Zhang and Di Li and Bo Peng and Weiwei Zhu and R. G. Strom and Na Wang and Qingdong Wu and Changqing Ye and Dehua Wang and Y. G. Yang and Zhen-Qi Diao},
  title = {{Statistical properties of fast radio bursts elucidate their origins: magnetars are favored over gamma-ray bursts}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1674-4527/21/8/211},
}
Figure