Statistical Model Checking Based Calibration and Analysis of Bio-pathway Models

Sucheendra K. Palaniappan, Benjamin M. Gyori, Bing Liu, David Hsu, P. S. ThiagarajanCMSB 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel statistical model checking (SMC) framework to analyze and calibrate complex biological pathway models that exhibit cell-to-cell variability. By integrating probabilistic temporal logic with SMC, the authors enable robust parameter estimation and sensitivity analysis, offering deeper insights into the dynamics of these systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biological systems are inherently complex and exhibit significant variability at the cellular level. This variability, stemming from differences in initial molecule concentrations and kinetic rate constants between cells, poses a major challenge for traditional mathematical modeling approaches, particularly those based on Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs). While ODEs offer computational tractability, they often struggle to capture this cell-to-cell heterogeneity. Existing methods for analyzing these models are either computationally prohibitive for large systems or lack the rigor to handle probabilistic properties and experimental data simultaneously. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a statistically sound and scalable framework that explicitly accounts for cell-to-cell variability in ODE-based bio-pathway models, facilitating both calibration and in-depth analysis.

Methods

The core of this work is a statistical model checking (SMC) framework designed for ODE-based bio-pathway models. The authors extend the concept of ODEs to incorporate cell-to-cell variability by defining probability distributions over initial concentrations and kinetic rate constants. This probabilistic approach generates a space of possible ODE trajectories, which are then analyzed using a bounded linear time temporal logic (BLTL).

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Probabilistic ODE Representation: Instead of fixed values, initial concentrations and rate constants are treated as random variables with specified probability distributions (e.g., uniform over an interval). This allows the model to represent a population of cells.
  • Bounded Linear Time Temporal Logic (BLTL): A formal logic is used to express both quantitative experimental data (e.g., concentration ranges at specific time points) and qualitative dynamic trends (e.g., transient activation).
  • Statistical Model Checking (SMC) Procedure: This procedure poses the verification of BLTL formulas as a hypothesis test. It adaptively samples trajectories from the probabilistic ODE model until a statistically guaranteed decision can be made about whether the property holds with a desired confidence level. This approach is efficient as its complexity is independent of the system size.
  • SMC-based Parameter Estimation: The framework is used to estimate unknown model parameters (initial concentrations and rate constants). It defines an objective function that quantifies the "goodness of fit" of a parameter set to experimental data and qualitative trends, using the SMC procedure to evaluate this fit. A global optimization strategy (SRES) is then employed to search for the best parameter values.
  • Property-Based Sensitivity Analysis: By coupling SMC with multi-parametric sensitivity analysis (MPSA), the authors can identify which parameters significantly affect specific pathway properties. This allows for a more targeted understanding of system behavior.

Datasets

The authors evaluated their framework on two well-established bio-pathway models from the BioModels database:

  • Segmentation Clock Pathway: A model with 16 differential equations and 75 kinetic rate parameters.
  • Thrombin-dependent MLC Phosphorylation Pathway: A larger model with 105 differential equations and 197 kinetic rate parameters.

For these models, they generated synthetic experimental data by assuming a ±5% range around nominal initial concentrations and averaging 104 random trajectories. This synthetic data was then split into training and testing sets. Qualitative trends were also formulated as BLTL properties.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Deterministic and Stochastic Views: The framework elegantly combines the computational advantages of ODEs with the need to capture stochasticity and variability inherent in biological systems.
  • Formalizing Biological Intuition: BLTL provides a powerful language to translate biological knowledge (qualitative trends) and experimental measurements into formal specifications that can be rigorously verified.
  • Scalable Analysis of Complex Systems: The SMC approach's independence from system size is crucial for analyzing large and complex bio-pathway models, which are common in systems biology.
  • Robust Parameter Estimation: By accounting for variability and using a statistically grounded fitness measure, the parameter estimation method yields more robust estimates that better reflect the biological reality.
  • Targeted Understanding of Dynamics: Property-based sensitivity analysis allows researchers to pinpoint critical parameters for specific pathway behaviors, leading to more insightful hypotheses about system control and regulation.

Key Results

  • The proposed SMC framework was successfully applied to two large bio-pathway models, demonstrating its scalability and efficiency.
  • The parameter estimation procedure yielded good parameter estimates that were robust to cell-to-cell variability. For the segmentation clock pathway, 39 rate parameters were estimated, and for the thrombin pathway, 100 parameters were estimated.
  • The method was able to distinguish between model predictions and experimental observations, highlighting discrepancies that suggest missing components or interactions in existing models (e.g., for the thrombin-MLC pathway).
  • Sensitivity analysis revealed key parameters driving specific pathway behaviors. For the segmentation clock pathway, parameters related to the FGF pathway were identified as crucial for overall dynamics, while specific parameters were found to be dominant for nuclear NicD oscillations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions on Distributions: The paper assumes uniform distributions for initial concentrations and rate constants. While reasonable, exploring other distribution types could further enhance the model's realism.
  • Computational Cost: While the SMC complexity is independent of system size, the numerical integration of ODEs can still be computationally intensive, especially for very large systems.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the framework to other model classes like continuous-time Markov chains (CTMCs) and stochastic differential equations (SDEs). They also propose developing a GPU-based implementation to further accelerate the generation of trajectories and exploit massive parallelism.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{palaniappan2013statistical,
  author = {Sucheendra K. Palaniappan and Benjamin M. Gyori and Bing Liu and David Hsu and P. S. Thiagarajan},
  title = {{Statistical Model Checking Based Calibration and Analysis of Bio-pathway Models}},
  booktitle = {CMSB},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-40708-6\_10},
}
Figure