Statistical Mechanics of Torque Induced Denaturation of DNA

Simona Cocco, Rémi MonassonPhysical 1999 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A unifying theory of the denaturation transition of DNA, driven by temperature $T$ or induced by an external mechanical torque $\Gamma$ is presented. Our model couples the hydrogen-bond opening and the untwisting of the helicoidal molecular structure. We describe denaturation as a first order transition from $B$-DNA to $d$-DNA phases. The coexistence region is naturally parametrized by the degree of supercoiling $\sigma$. The denaturation free energy, the temperature dependence of the twist angle, the phase diagram in the $T,\Gamma$ plane, and isotherms in the $\sigma,\Gamma$ plane are calculated and show a good agreement with experimental data.

Introduction

DNA is not merely a static repository of genetic information; it is a dynamic mechanical structure. While the "melting" or denaturation of DNA via heating is a well-studied phenomenon, biological processes such as transcription and replication exert mechanical forces that can also induce strand separation.

Historically, research focused primarily on thermal melting or longitudinal stretching. However, experimental advancements in the late 1990s demonstrated that mechanical torque—the twisting or untwisting of the molecule—could also trigger denaturation. This paper addresses the need for a unified theoretical framework capable of explaining both thermal and mechanical denaturation while accounting for the complex helicoidal geometry of the DNA molecule.

Methods

The authors construct a statistical mechanics model of the Watson-Crick double helix by integrating several physical components.

Geometric and Potential Modeling

The molecule is represented geometrically by the radius ($r$) and twist angle ($\phi$) of each base pair. The sugar-phosphate backbone is modeled as a series of rigid rods of fixed length ($L$), as shown in Figure 1.

Geometric model of the DNA double helix showing base pair radius $r_n$, twist angle $\phi_n$, and backbone length $L$.

The system's total potential energy includes:

  • Morse Potential: To model the hydrogen bonds holding base pairs together.
  • Stacking Potential: To account for the attractive interactions between adjacent base pairs along the strand.
  • Elastic Energy: To describe molecular vibrations and the coupling between base pair distance and twist angle.
  • Torque Integration: An external mechanical torque ($\Gamma$) is added to the potential energy to simulate mechanical stress.

Mathematical Approach

The authors employ the Transfer Integral Method to calculate the partition function of the system. This allows for the determination of the free energy of DNA across various temperatures and torque levels, facilitating the identification of phase transitions.

Key Insights: Denaturation as a Phase Transition

A central finding of this work is that DNA denaturation behaves as a first-order phase transition, analogous to the transition between liquid and gas. The model identifies a "coexistence region" where the standard double helix (B-DNA) and the denatured state (d-DNA) can exist simultaneously on the same strand.

This coexistence is parametrized by the degree of supercoiling ($\sigma$), which represents the deviation from the natural twist of the molecule. In the denatured state, the model describes a "purely entropic" phase where, once hydrogen bonds are broken, the strands are governed by the physical constraints of the backbone rather than specific chemical attractions.

Results and Experimental Validation

The model's predictions align closely with established experimental data, particularly from single-molecule experiments on $\lambda$ DNA.

Torque $\Gamma$ as a function of supercoiling $\sigma$ for various temperatures, illustrating the coexistence region and critical torque values.

Key quantitative results include:

  • Denaturation Free Energy: The predicted value of $\Delta G \approx 0.022$ eV is in excellent agreement with the experimental estimate of $0.025$ eV for AT-rich regions.
  • Twist Sensitivity: The calculated temperature dependence of the twist angle ($-1.4 \times 10^{-4}$ rad/K) matches the experimental value of $-1.7 \times 10^{-4}$ rad/K.
  • Critical Torque and Supercoiling: The model predicts denaturation begins at a critical torque ($\Gamma_c$) of $-0.035$ eV/rad and a critical supercoiling ($\sigma_c$) of $-0.01$. These values are consistent with experimental observations of $-0.05$ eV/rad and $-0.015$, respectively.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the model provides a robust unifying theory, it currently assumes a homogeneous sequence, treating all base pairs as identical. In biological reality, the ratio of Adenine-Thymine (AT) to Guanine-Cytosine (GC) pairs significantly influences the stability of the helix. Furthermore, the model focuses on torque without fully integrating longitudinal stretching forces.

Future work aims to extend this framework to account for sequence heterogeneity and the combined effects of torque and stretching, providing a more comprehensive mechanical description of DNA dynamics in vivo.

Summary updated

Abstract

A unifying theory of the denaturation transition of DNA, driven by temperature $T$ or induced by an external mechanical torque $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ is presented. Our model couples the hydrogen-bond opening and the untwisting of the helicoidal molecular structure. We describe denaturation as a first order transition from $B$-DNA to $d$-DNA phases. The coexistence region is naturally parametrized by the degree of supercoiling $\ensuremath{\sigma}$. The denaturation free energy, the temperature dependence of the twist angle, the phase diagram in the $T,\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ plane, and isotherms in the $\ensuremath{\sigma},\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ plane are calculated and show a good agreement with experimental data.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cocco1999statistical,
  author = {Simona Cocco and Rémi Monasson},
  title = {{Statistical Mechanics of Torque Induced Denaturation of DNA}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.83.5178},
}
Figure