Statistical Learning with a Nuisance Component (Extended Abstract)

Dylan J. Foster, Vasilis SyrgkanisIJCAI 2020 · OpenReview

Abstract

We provide excess risk guarantees for statistical learning in a setting where the population risk with respect to which we evaluate a target parameter depends on an unknown parameter that must be estimated from data (a "nuisance parameter"). We analyze a two-stage sample splitting meta-algorithm that takes as input two arbitrary estimation algorithms: one for the target parameter and one for the nuisance parameter. We show that if the population risk satisfies a condition called Neyman orthogonality, the impact of the nuisance estimation error on the excess risk bound achieved by the meta-algorithm is of second order. Our theorem is agnostic to the particular algorithms used for the target and nuisance and only makes an assumption on their individual performance. This enables the use of a plethora of existing results from statistical learning and machine learning literature to give new guarantees for learning with a nuisance component. Moreover, by focusing on excess risk rather than parameter estimation, we can give guarantees under weaker assumptions than in previous works and accommodate the case where the target parameter belongs to a complex nonparametric class. We characterize conditions on the metric entropy such that oracle rates—rates of the same order as if we knew the nuisance parameter—are achieved. We also analyze the rates achieved by specific estimation algorithms such as variance-penalized empirical risk minimization, neural network estimation and sparse high-dimensional linear model estimation. We highlight the applicability of our results in four settings of central importance in the literature: 1) heterogeneous treatment effect estimation, 2) offline policy optimization, 3) domain adaptation, and 4) learning with missing data.

Introduction

In standard statistical learning, we typically minimize a loss function that is fully observable. However, in many high-stakes domains—such as personalized medicine, econometrics, and reinforcement learning—the "true" loss function depends on variables that are not directly observed. These are known as nuisance parameters.

For example, to estimate the heterogeneous treatment effect (HTE) of a drug, one must account for the "propensity score" (the probability a patient receives the drug based on their characteristics). Because the true propensity score is unknown, it must be estimated from the data. Traditionally, errors in this first-stage estimation "bleed" into the second-stage target estimation, often leading to biased results or slower convergence rates. This paper introduces a theoretical framework to "de-bias" these models, ensuring that the final model remains robust even when the nuisance parameters are estimated using complex, black-box machine learning algorithms.

The Two-Stage Meta-Algorithm

The authors propose a general meta-algorithm designed to decouple the estimation of the nuisance parameter from the estimation of the target parameter. The process follows a Two-Stage Estimation with Sample Splitting strategy:

  1. Data Partitioning: The dataset is divided into two independent halves (or folds).
  2. Stage 1 (Nuisance Estimation): The first half of the data is used to train an arbitrary algorithm (e.g., a Random Forest, Lasso, or Deep Neural Network) to produce an estimate of the nuisance parameter, denoted as $\hat{g}_n$.
  3. Stage 2 (Target Learning): The second half of the data is used to learn the target parameter $\hat{\theta}_n$. This is done by minimizing an empirical risk function where the nuisance estimate $\hat{g}_n$ from Stage 1 is "plugged in."

By splitting the data, the algorithm avoids the overfitting issues that arise when the same data is used to estimate both the nuisance and the target parameters simultaneously.

The Role of Neyman Orthogonality

The core theoretical requirement for this framework is a property known as Neyman orthogonality. A loss function is Neyman orthogonal if its sensitivity to the nuisance parameter is zero at the true parameter values.

Mathematically, this means that the first-order derivative (or Gateaux derivative) of the population risk with respect to the nuisance parameter vanishes. When this condition is met, small errors in the first-stage nuisance estimation have only a second-order impact on the final model's performance. This allows researchers to use "slow-converging" or highly complex nuisance estimators without destroying the "fast" convergence of the primary target model.

Key Theoretical Insights

1. Oracle Rates

The paper proves that under Neyman orthogonality, the learner can achieve "oracle rates." This means the convergence rate of the final model is of the same order as if the true nuisance parameters were known from the start. This holds even when the target parameter belongs to a complex, high-dimensional, or nonparametric class, such as a deep neural network.

2. Performance Regimes

The research identifies two distinct regimes for excess risk:

  • Fast Rates: In settings where the risk is strongly convex (common in treatment effect estimation), the impact of the nuisance error is minimized to the power of four, allowing for extremely high precision.
  • Slow Rates: In settings like policy optimization, where the risk may not be convex, the impact remains manageable, typically proportional to the square of the nuisance estimation error.

3. Algorithmic Agnosticism

One of the most significant contributions is that the theory is "black-box agnostic." It does not dictate which specific machine learning models must be used. As long as the chosen algorithms for both stages have known performance bounds (expressed via metric entropy or similar measures), the framework provides a guaranteed bound for the final excess risk.

Applications

The authors demonstrate that this framework unifies and improves upon existing specialized bounds in four critical areas:

  • Heterogeneous Treatment Effects: Estimating how different individuals respond to interventions.
  • Offline Policy Optimization: Learning optimal decision rules from logged historical data (e.g., reinforcement learning without active exploration).
  • Domain Adaptation: Training a model on one distribution and applying it to a different but related one.
  • Learning with Missing Data: Handling datasets where certain features or labels are systematically absent.

Limitations and Considerations

While the framework is powerful, it relies on the existence of an orthogonal loss function. While "doubly robust" estimators often provide such a structure, constructing an orthogonal loss for entirely new problems can be mathematically challenging. Additionally, the current abstract focuses on sample splitting; while the authors acknowledge "cross-fitting" (a technique to use all data by swapping folds), the primary theoretical guarantees are derived for the split-sample case. Finally, the complexity (metric entropy) of the target class must be balanced against the nuisance error to ensure the oracle rates are maintained.

Summary updated

Abstract

We provide excess risk guarantees for statistical learning in a setting where the population risk with respect to which we evaluate a target parameter depends on an unknown parameter that must be estimated from data (a "nuisance parameter"). We analyze a two-stage sample splitting meta-algorithm that takes as input two arbitrary estimation algorithms: one for the target parameter and one for the nuisance parameter. We show that if the population risk satisfies a condition called Neyman orthogonality, the impact of the nuisance estimation error on the excess risk bound achieved by the meta-algorithm is of second order. Our theorem is agnostic to the particular algorithms used for the target and nuisance and only makes an assumption on their individual performance. This enables the use of a plethora of existing results from statistical learning and machine learning literature to give new guarantees for learning with a nuisance component. Moreover, by focusing on excess risk rather than parameter estimation, we can give guarantees under weaker assumptions than in previous works and accommodate the case where the target parameter belongs to a complex nonparametric class. We characterize conditions on the metric entropy such that oracle rates---rates of the same order as if we knew the nuisance parameter---are achieved. We also analyze the rates achieved by specific estimation algorithms such as variance-penalized empirical risk minimization, neural network estimation and sparse high-dimensional linear model estimation. We highlight the applicability of our results in four settings of central importance in the literature: 1) heterogeneous treatment effect estimation, 2) offline policy optimization, 3) domain adaptation, and 4) learning with missing data.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{foster2020statistical,
  author = {Dylan J. Foster and Vasilis Syrgkanis},
  title = {{Statistical Learning with a Nuisance Component (Extended Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uWvJIPSff3f},
}
Figure