Statistical geometry of particle packings. II. “Weak spots” in liquids

Srikanth Sastry, Pablo G. Debenedetti, Frank H. StillingerPhysical 1997 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the "inherent structures" of liquids – mechanically stable configurations found by minimizing energy. They discover that at lower densities, these structures become highly heterogeneous, featuring a large, interconnected void space. This void formation is linked to a mechanical instability, suggesting it plays a crucial role in liquid metastability, nucleation, and potentially the glass transition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Liquids, unlike crystalline solids, exhibit a rich structural diversity that underpins their unique dynamic and thermodynamic properties. While significant progress has been made in understanding liquid structure, a complete picture, especially concerning the mechanisms behind the decay of metastable states (like superheated or stretched liquids), remains elusive. Specifically, how do these metastable states break down, leading to phenomena like boiling or cavitation? This paper tackles this by investigating the "statistical geometry" of void space within liquids, particularly focusing on how these voids behave when the liquid is pushed to its limits of stability.

Methods

The core of the methodology involves two key steps:

  1. Simulation of Liquid Configurations: The researchers use a shifted-force Lennard-Jones potential to simulate a system of 256 particles (and in one case, 1372 particles) in various thermodynamic ensembles (NVE, NVT). They explore both equilibrium and metastable (superheated and stretched) liquid states across a range of densities and temperatures.
  2. Generation of Inherent Structures: For each simulated liquid configuration, they perform a "steepest-descent minimization" of the potential energy. This process maps the dynamic liquid configuration onto a local minimum in the potential energy landscape, resulting in a "mechanically stable" arrangement of particles called an inherent structure. This is akin to finding the lowest point in a bumpy landscape starting from any given spot.
  3. Void Space Analysis: They employ Voronoi and Delaunay tessellations to analyze the empty space (voids) within both the equilibrium liquid configurations and the generated inherent structures. This allows them to quantify void size distributions, identify connectivity, and distinguish between "bulk" and "surface" particles.

Datasets

The paper uses simulated data from a shifted-force Lennard-Jones potential. No experimental datasets are used. The simulations are performed for a system of 256 particles, with one specific state point (ρ=0.725, T=0.9) also simulated with 1372 particles to check for system size effects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inherent Structures Reveal Hidden Heterogeneity: The most striking finding is that inherent structures, even for seemingly homogeneous liquid states, can be remarkably heterogeneous. At lower densities, they develop a distinct structure with a large, system-spanning void region.
  • Mechanical Instability as a Trigger: The emergence of this void structure in inherent structures coincides with a density (ρ*=0.89) where the pressure-density curve for inherent structures reaches a minimum (negative pressure). This suggests that the system is undergoing a mechanical instability, similar to the spinodal concept in phase transitions, which triggers the formation of these voids.
  • "Weak Spots" in Liquids: Atoms in low-density regions ("weak spots") of the equilibrium liquid tend to map to the interface of the large cavity in the corresponding inherent structure. This directly links local density fluctuations in the liquid to the structure of its mechanically stable counterpart.
  • Implications for Nucleation and Glass Transition: The paper proposes that these "weak spots" and the associated void formation in inherent structures are crucial for understanding homogeneous nucleation (e.g., bubble formation in superheated liquids). Furthermore, since glasses can be viewed as liquids trapped in inherent structures, this mechanical instability might represent a fundamental lower density limit for glass formation.

Key Results

  • Bicontinuous Structure: Inherent structures at densities below ρ*=0.89 exhibit a bicontinuous morphology of a compact phase and a void region.
  • Single System-Spanning Cavity: The void region is predominantly a single, system-spanning cavity, whose volume fraction vanishes above ρ*=0.89.
  • Mechanical Instability at ρ*=0.89: The pressure-density curve for inherent structures shows a minimum at ρ*=0.89, indicating a point of mechanical instability and tension.
  • Surface vs. Bulk Atom Segregation: Atoms in low-density regions of the liquid preferentially become "surface" atoms in the inherent structure, forming the interface of the void.
  • Void Size and Surface Probability Correlation: Atoms associated with larger voids in equilibrium configurations are more likely to become surface atoms in the inherent structure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • System Size: The simulations were performed with a modest number of particles (256, with one case at 1372). The authors acknowledge that the asymptotic morphology of inherent structures for truly macroscopic systems remains to be studied.
  • Model System: The study uses a simplified shifted-force Lennard-Jones potential. The authors suggest extending this approach to more complex molecular liquids, particularly water, to understand phenomena like negative expansivity.
  • Glass Transition: While the paper speculates on the connection between mechanical instability and glass formation, this remains an open question and an area for future investigation.
  • Kinetics of Weak Spot Formation: The authors highlight the need for quantitative investigation into the density- and temperature-dependent kinetics of weak spot formation to build a rigorous theory of bubble nucleation.
  • Mechanical Failure at Interfaces: The role of surface inhomogeneity in creating favorable energetics for weak spot formation and the fate of these weak spots are also suggested as areas for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the statistical geometry of inherent structures (mechanically stable arrangements of particles generated by a steepest-descent mapping of equilibrium configurations to local potential minima) of liquid configurations of the shifted-force Lennard-Jones system, as an approach to elucidating mechanisms for the decay of metastable states. For a wide range of densities, including some higher than the triple point density, inherent structures are found to display remarkably heterogeneous geometry, with an apparently bicontinuous structure consisting of a compact phase and a void region. The void region is found to consist of a single system-spanning cavity. The volume fraction of this cavity vanishes above the density ${\ensuremath{\rho}}^{*}=0.89.$ This density coincides with the minimum in the pressure vs density curve for inherent structures, at negative pressure, indicating that the observed heterogeneity of the inherent structures is triggered by the crossing of a threshold of mechanical instability, much like the familiar spinodal concept. Analysis of spontaneous density fluctuations in the equilibrium and superheated liquid reveals that atoms present in regions of low density (weak spots) map predominantly to the cavity interface in the inherent structures. We discuss the relevance of these observations to limits of stability of the metastable liquid, nucleation, and, possibly, the glass transition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sastry1997statistical,
  author = {Srikanth Sastry and Pablo G. Debenedetti and Frank H. Stillinger},
  title = {{Statistical geometry of particle packings. II. “Weak spots” in liquids}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1997},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.56.5533},
}
Figure