Statistical estimation of cell-cycle progression and lineage commitment in Plasmodium falciparum reveals a homogeneous pattern of transcription in ex vivo culture

Jacob E. Lemieux, Natalia Gomez‐Escobar, Avi Feller, Céline Carret, Alfred Amambua‐Ngwa, Robert Pinches, Felix R. Day, Sue Kyes, David J. Conway, Chris Holmes, Chris NewboldProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of analyzing gene expression in Plasmodium falciparum (the malaria parasite) by developing a novel statistical framework to accurately estimate parasite developmental stage. This allows them to demonstrate that gene expression in ex vivo cultures from patients is surprisingly homogeneous, suggesting that observed variations in previous studies might be due to cell-cycle asynchrony rather than distinct biological states.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Plasmodium falciparum is a major cause of malaria, and understanding its gene expression patterns is crucial for developing new treatments. However, analyzing these patterns is tricky because the parasite's gene expression is highly periodic, meaning it changes dramatically throughout its life cycle within red blood cells. When researchers analyze samples taken at different times from infected individuals (ex vivo), small differences in the parasite's developmental stage between samples can look like genuine differences in gene expression, leading to confusing or contradictory results. Previous studies have struggled to disentangle these two sources of variation. This paper aims to solve this by providing a robust statistical method to precisely determine the developmental stage of parasites in a sample, thereby enabling a more accurate comparison of gene expression profiles.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is a statistical likelihood-based framework for estimating the parasite's developmental age, measured in hours post invasion (HPI). This method leverages the highly periodic nature of gene expression:

  • Reference Set: They use a well-characterized, synchronized in vitro culture of P. falciparum (clone 3D7) as a reference, with known gene expression profiles at different HPI.
  • Likelihood Calculation: For each gene in a test sample (ex vivo or in vitro), they calculate how likely its expression level is given the reference expression at each HPI. The overall likelihood for a sample is the product of these individual gene likelihoods.
  • Maximum Likelihood Estimate (MLE): The HPI that maximizes this overall likelihood is the estimated developmental age of the sample.
  • Confidence Intervals: They use subsampling to robustly estimate confidence intervals for these age estimates.

Beyond just estimating age, they extend this framework to estimate lineage commitment:

  • Mixture Model: They treat each patient sample as a mixture of parasites committed to asexual development and those committed to sexual development (gametocytogenesis).
  • Two-Parameter Estimate: This model provides two estimates per sample: the HPI along the asexual cycle and the fraction of mRNA attributed to gametocyte expression patterns (denoted as 'α').

Datasets

  • Ex vivo patient isolates: Blood samples were collected from patients with mild and severe malaria in The Gambia. These were cultured briefly before RNA extraction.
  • In vitro cultured samples:
    • Reference data from a synchronized P. falciparum 3D7 clone (Bozdech et al., Le Roch et al.).
  • Published datasets from previous studies analyzing P. falciparum gene expression from patient samples (Daily et al.) and in vitro cultures (Cortes et al., Le Roch et al.).
  • In vitro gametocyte development time course data (Young et al.).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cell-cycle asynchrony is a major confounder: The paper strongly suggests that much of the "discrete variation" observed in previous studies of ex vivo P. falciparum transcriptomes is not due to fundamentally different biological states (like distinct disease states) but rather to subtle differences in the developmental stage of parasites within the samples.
  • Homogeneous transcription in ex vivo culture: When samples are matched for developmental age, the transcriptional profiles of ex vivo cultured parasites from patients with diverse clinical profiles are remarkably similar to each other and to in vitro cultured parasites. This challenges the idea of distinct "in vivo" transcriptional states.
  • Sexual commitment is a continuous spectrum: Reanalyzing a previous dataset (Daily et al.), their mixture model reveals that the variation observed is best explained by a continuous spectrum of parasite commitment to sexual development, rather than discrete "states."
  • Economical gene regulation: The finding that asexual genes are also expressed in gametocytes suggests that P. falciparum might reuse transcriptional machinery (like AP2 transcription factors) for both asexual and sexual development, indicating an efficient regulatory strategy.

Key Results

  • The developed statistical method accurately estimates parasite age (HPI) for various P. falciparum clones and experimental conditions, showing good agreement with morphological data.
  • Analysis of ex vivo patient isolates, after accounting for developmental age, revealed little large-scale transcriptional variation between samples from patients with different clinical presentations.
  • Reanalysis of the Daily et al. (2007) dataset using the mixture model showed that the observed variation was consistent with a continuous gradient of sexual lineage commitment, with samples from Daily et al. exhibiting a higher proportion of sexual mRNA compared to the ex vivo cultured samples in this study.
  • They identified 278 genes (≈5% of the genome) differentially expressed between their ex vivo isolates and time-matched in vitro profiles, with enrichment for genes involved in DNA replication and protein catabolism.
  • A single rif gene (PFL2585c) was consistently up-regulated in patient samples, validated by RT-PCR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the small sample size of their ex vivo study, further reduced by the need to match parasites for developmental age, limited their ability to detect subtle transcriptional differences between severe and mild malaria.
  • In vitro vs. In vivo: While their ex vivo cultures resembled in vitro profiles, they note that determining whether observed differences reflect genuine field variation or adaptation to in vitro culture requires further experiments.
  • Sexual mRNA Proportion: The 'α' parameter in their mixture model estimates the fraction of mRNA attributed to gametocyte expression, not necessarily the true proportion of sexual cells, due to unknown relative mRNA expression levels.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that their statistical methods are valuable for quality control in expression profiling experiments, simplifying the identification of differentially expressed genes and providing insights into transcriptional control. Further work is needed to explore the functional implications of the identified differentially expressed genes and the conserved rif gene.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have cultured Plasmodium falciparum directly from the blood of infected individuals to examine patterns of mature-stage gene expression in patient isolates. Analysis of the transcriptome of P. falciparum is complicated by the highly periodic nature of gene expression because small variations in the stage of parasite development between samples can lead to an apparent difference in gene expression values. To address this issue, we have developed statistical likelihood-based methods to estimate cell cycle progression and commitment to asexual or sexual development lineages in our samples based on microscopy and gene expression patterns. In cases subsequently matched for temporal development, we find that transcriptional patterns in ex vivo culture display little variation across patients with diverse clinical profiles and closely resemble transcriptional profiles that occur in vitro. These statistical methods, available to the research community, assist in the design and interpretation of P. falciparum expression profiling experiments where it is difficult to separate true differential expression from cell-cycle dependent expression. We reanalyze an existing dataset of in vivo patient expression profiles and conclude that previously observed discrete variation is consistent with the commitment of a varying proportion of the parasite population to the sexual development lineage.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lemieux2009statistical,
  author = {Jacob E. Lemieux and Natalia Gomez‐Escobar and Avi Feller and Céline Carret and Alfred Amambua‐Ngwa and Robert Pinches and Felix R. Day and Sue Kyes and David J. Conway and Chris Holmes and Chris Newbold},
  title = {{Statistical estimation of cell-cycle progression and lineage commitment in <i>Plasmodium falciparum</i> reveals a homogeneous pattern of transcription in ex vivo culture}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.0811829106},
}
Figure