State-Dependent tACS Effects Reveal the Potential Causal Role of Prestimulus Alpha Traveling Waves in Visual Contrast Detection

Jinwen Wei, Andrea Alamia, Ziqing Yao, Gan Huang, Linling Li, Zhen Liang, Li Zhang, Changsong Zhou, Zhenxi Song, Zhiguo ZhangJournal of Neuroscience 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The intricate relationship between prestimulus alpha oscillations and visual contrast detection variability has been the focus of numerous studies. However, the causal impact of prestimulus alpha traveling waves on visual contrast detection remains largely unexplored. In our research, we sought to discern the causal link between prestimulus alpha traveling waves and visual contrast detection across different levels of mental fatigue. Using electroencephalography alongside a visual detection task with 30 healthy adults, we identified a robust negative correlation between prestimulus alpha forward traveling waves (FTWs) and visual contrast threshold (VCT). Inspired by this correlation, we utilized 45/-45° phase-shifted transcranial alternating current stimulation (tACS) in a sham-controlled, double-blind, within-subject experiment with 33 healthy adults to directly modulate these alpha traveling waves. After the application of 45° phase-shifted tACS, we observed a substantial decrease in FTW and an increase in backward traveling waves, along with a concurrent increase in VCT, compared with the sham condition. These changes were particularly pronounced under a low fatigue state. The findings of state-dependent tACS effects reveal the potential causal role of prestimulus alpha traveling waves in visual contrast detection. Moreover, our study highlights the potential of 45/-45° phase-shifted tACS in cognitive modulation and therapeutic applications.

Introduction

Neuroscientists have long recognized alpha oscillations (8–13 Hz) as a "gatekeeper" for perception. Generally, lower alpha power in the posterior regions of the brain correlates with a higher likelihood of detecting faint visual stimuli. However, recent evidence suggests that alpha is not merely a stationary rhythm but moves across the cortex like ripples on a pond—phenomena known as traveling waves.

This study addresses two critical questions in the field:

  1. Does the direction of these traveling waves causally influence perception, or is it a byproduct of other brain activity?
  2. Why do the effects of brain stimulation vary so significantly between individuals and sessions?

The researchers hypothesized that "Forward Traveling Waves" (FTW), moving from the visual cortex to the frontal lobe, support sensory processing, while "Backward Traveling Waves" (BTW) might represent top-down inhibition. Furthermore, they suspected that the brain's internal state—specifically mental fatigue—determines the efficacy of external neuromodulation.

Methods

The research was conducted in two primary phases:

Experiment 1 (Correlation): 30 participants (13 female, 17 male) performed a visual contrast detection task involving faint Gabor patches while monitored with 64-channel EEG. Researchers employed a 2D Fast Fourier Transform (2D-FFT) to quantify alpha waves moving forward (occipital-to-frontal) versus backward.

Experiment 2 (Causality): 33 participants (23 female, 10 male) underwent phase-shifted transcranial alternating current stimulation (tACS). Unlike conventional tACS, this method utilized a 45° or -45° phase difference between frontal and occipital electrodes to induce directional electric fields. This experiment followed a double-blind, sham-controlled, within-subject design.

Experimental paradigm showing the trial structure (A) and the block structure of Experiment 1 (B).

Throughout both experiments, participants self-reported their fatigue levels, allowing the data to be categorized into "low fatigue" and "high fatigue" states to test for state-dependency.

Key Insights and Results

The Role of Directionality

The study revealed that alpha directionality is a critical predictor of performance. In Experiment 1, higher FTW power was significantly correlated with a lower Visual Contrast Threshold (VCT), meaning participants were better at detecting faint images when forward waves were dominant.

Causal Modulation via tACS

By using 45° phase-shifted tACS, the researchers successfully "steered" the brain's internal dynamics, decreasing FTW power and increasing BTW power relative to the sham condition. This shift in wave direction had a direct behavioral impact: participants' VCT increased, indicating a reduced ability to detect faint stimuli.

Conceptual summary of how tACS modulates traveling waves and visual contrast thresholds specifically in low fatigue states.

The Fatigue Gate

A pivotal finding was the state-dependency of these effects. The modulation of both traveling waves and behavioral performance was only significant when participants were in a low fatigue state. In high-fatigue states, the stimulation failed to produce significant changes. This suggests that low fatigue represents an optimal "excitation-inhibition balance," rendering the brain more plastic and responsive to external electrical intervention.

Discussion and Future Directions

These results establish a potential causal link between prestimulus alpha traveling waves and visual perception. The specificity of the findings—where effects were tied to the traveling nature of the waves rather than overall alpha power—highlights a new dimension of neural coding.

While promising, the study notes limitations such as the spatial resolution of scalp EEG. Future research using intracranial EEG could provide higher precision regarding wave speed and local dynamics. Additionally, moving from self-reported fatigue to objective biomarkers like pupil dilation or heart rate variability could refine our understanding of the "state-dependent" window for neuromodulation. Ultimately, the ability to manipulate the direction of cortical waves opens new avenues for treating sensory processing deficits and attention disorders.

Summary updated

Abstract

The intricate relationship between prestimulus alpha oscillations and visual contrast detection variability has been the focus of numerous studies. However, the causal impact of prestimulus alpha traveling waves on visual contrast detection remains largely unexplored. In our research, we sought to discern the causal link between prestimulus alpha traveling waves and visual contrast detection across different levels of mental fatigue. Using electroencephalography alongside a visual detection task with 30 healthy adults (13 females; 17 males), we identified a robust negative correlation between prestimulus alpha forward traveling waves (FTWs) and visual contrast threshold (VCT). Inspired by this correlation, we utilized 45/-45° phase-shifted transcranial alternating current stimulation (tACS) in a sham-controlled, double-blind, within-subject experiment with 33 healthy adults (23 females; 10 males) to directly modulate these alpha traveling waves. After the application of 45° phase-shifted tACS, we observed a substantial decrease in FTW and an increase in backward traveling waves, along with a concurrent increase in VCT, compared with the sham condition. These changes were particularly pronounced under a low fatigue state. The findings of state-dependent tACS effects reveal the potential causal role of prestimulus alpha traveling waves in visual contrast detection. Moreover, our study highlights the potential of 45/-45° phase-shifted tACS in cognitive modulation and therapeutic applications.
BibTeX
@article{wei2024state,
  author = {Jinwen Wei and Andrea Alamia and Ziqing Yao and Gan Huang and Linling Li and Zhen Liang and Li Zhang and Changsong Zhou and Zhenxi Song and Zhiguo Zhang},
  title = {{State-Dependent tACS Effects Reveal the Potential Causal Role of Prestimulus Alpha Traveling Waves in Visual Contrast Detection}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.2023-23.2024},
}
Figure